UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY IFE. PSYCHOLOGIA An International Journal, Volume 9 No.1, 2001 Published by: Ife PsychologfA (RC 011934) Ife Center for Psychological Studies P.O. Box 1548, Ile-Ife,- Osun State, Nigeria. & I, .c:. I" P$YCHOLOGIA LTD (Re 83,305) '.i\ P.O, Box UC146 University of Cape Coast Cape Coast Ghana UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY ISSN: 1117-1421 PRINTED BY ANCHORPRINT LTD., ILE-IFE. ~ 036.232615. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY VOLUME NINE ISSN 1117-1421 NUMBER ONE MARCH 2001 Editorial i Contents iii C.HOF& Teenage Pregnancy-as an Issue of Human Rights A. RlCHTERS , for Women: The Case of Zimbabwe F.K. AMEDAHE 12 Combining Teacher Assessment Scores with External Examination Scores for Certification: Comparative Study of Four Statistical Models A.S. JEGEDE, 35 Public Health in Nigeria: From Cure to Care S.E.IDEMUDlA S.N.MADU J.H.NENTY 47 Tendency to Cheat during Mathematics Examination and some Achievement-Related Behaviour among Secondary School Students in Lesotho. B.O.OLLEY 65 Perceived Stigma: Prevalence and Related Factors AmongClinically Diagnosed Nigerian Individuals with Epilepsy J.A. ATHANASOU & 74 A Case' Study of Student Judgements of Interest in O. ANEW ALEHINMI A Subject A.J.mANGA 83 Aids Pandemic: Challenge for the &A.ZAMANI Nigerian Psychologists R.M. SCHROEDER 89 Stress and Copingamong Ghanaian School C.S. AKOTlA & Teachers A.K.APEKEY M.G. FAJONYOMI 99 Relative Effectiveness of Three Modes of Treatment on English Language Performance among Secondary School Students in Maiduguri F.A. KALGO 105 Sex and Age Trend of Field- IndependentlDependent among Secondary School Student in Sokoto State B.O. EHIGIE & liS Psychological Strategies in Managing Television N.A. SHENGE Commercial Efficacy M.A.BANKAT 123 Traditional Forms of Psychotherapy of the Fer People of Plateau State, Nigeria. s.s. OMOTOSHO 128 Learning Disability Problems Prevalent Among Elementary School Age Children in Ilorin Metropolis: Implications for Special Education and Counselling B.J.BILESANMIA-WODERU 134 The Relationship Between Nigerian High School Seniors' Performance in Theory and Practical Biology L.M. OLAYIWOLA 141 Infrastructural needs and Responses in Rural Nigeria Between 1960-1990: A Planner's Viewpoint , UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY PERCEI\"ED STIG:\IA: PRE\"ALE:\CE A:\D RELATED fACTORS .UIO:\G CLI:\ICALL Y DIAG:\OSED :\IGERL\:\ I:\DI\"IDLUS WITH EPILEPSY OLLEY; B.O Department of Psychology. Faculty of the Social Sciences. University ofIbadan. Ibadan Xigeria Abstract The theoretical model that epilepsy is globally stigmatizing \I'as tested llmong .\'igl'1'ian adults. The model suggested relationships among several characteristics (seizure control. agt' at onset of illness. duration 0/ epilepsy. seizure type) depression. neuroticism. social support and perceived stigma. Subjects Irere 26-1 adults. 21 to 60 years old. clinically diagnosed epilepsy. Using both correlational analysis of variables and a hierarchical multiple regression analysis. results of the study suggest that Nigerian individuals with epilepsy felt seriously stigmatized by the illness. Five variables: poor "seizure control. duration of epilepsy. depression. neuroticism and social supports were related to stigma. However depression and social support best predicted perception of stigma. Introduction The concept of stigma was formulated to explain the behavior. perceptions. beliefs. and development of the social and psychological self of stigmatized persons. Stigmatized persons can be broadly defined as individuals who possess an attribute that others see as negative. unfavorable, or in some way unacceptable. Examples of such individuals may include those with physical disabilities. facial deformities. facial deformities. mental retardation. and mental illness. A contention among contemporary researchers about the social consequences of epilepsy is that, it bears a universal and devastating stigma. From a modest beginning through the work of Temkin (1971). researches and concern regarding the effects of stigma on individuals with epilepsy have grown tremendously. All these studies have maintained that the illness bears a lot of stigma (Bagley. 1973; Janzik. Schmitz. Geiger. & Mayort. 1978; Schneider & Conrad, 1983; Awaritefe, 1985; Scambler & Hopkins 1980; Amston. Droge. Norton & Murray 1986; Hermann, Whitman, Wyler. Anton & Vanderzwagg 1990; Westbrook. Silver Coupey & Skinnar 1991; Westbrook. Bauman & Skinnar 1992; Westbrook 1995; Aziz. Akhatar & Hasan 1997; Chaplin 1998 And Amir. Roziner, Knoll. & Neufeld. 1999). Dell. (1986) documented that this stigma has resulted in the past a prohibition of mariage and adoption. mandatory sterilization and institutionalization for individuals with epilepsy. They are often a subject of prejudice and rejection (Bagley. 1973) and often less preferred compared to the psychotics (Awaritefe, 1985). These attribute. seemingly can result in various forms of psychosocial and psychiatric complications, the relationships. which have attracted much studies among contemporary researchers. For example Janzik et al (1978) reported a relationship between subjective feelings of stigmatization in social interaction and tendency to conceal the presence of the disorder. It was also reported that perception of stigma was related to direct exposure to rejection and disapproval from others. (Schneider & Conrad. 1983) and that epileptic persons did not 65 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY Ife Psychologia disclose their disorder to their employer and majority of them thought their careers had been inhibited (Scambler & Hopkins 1980). Amston et al (1986) found that perceived stigma was correlated with perceived helplessness, depression, anxiety, somatic symptoms, and low self- esteem. Similarly, Hermann et al (1990) found a significant association between feelings of stigma and psychiatric symptoms and Westbrook et aI., (1991) found a significant difference exist between adolescents with epilepsy and adolescents with other chronic illnesses in the way they disclosed their conditions to others. Those with epilepsy told fewer teachers and fewer friends about their disorders and found talking about their epilepsy more difficult. A behavioural pattern that is consistent with what was described as selective disclosure Goffman (1963) or the revealing of disease condition to only sympathetic others. Westbrook et al (1992) tested a theoretical model that sought to explain the association of stigma to self- esteem among adolescents (12-20 years old) . .They found using a hierarchical multiple regression analysis, perceived stigma, seizure type, and seizure frequency as predictors of low self-esteem. In Nigeria, there is a dearth of empirical studies about the perception of stigma in individuals with epilepsy and its effects on their psychological well being. Apart from the study of Danesi (1984) who documented evide~e of perceived non-acceptance in the sample of epileptics .he studied, no other study has docpmented stigma from the perspective of the individuals with epilepsy. Result from. Danesi (1984) study showed that individuals with epilepsy rated themselves lower, than individuals without epilepsy with regard to employability and higher with respect to emotional problems and tendencies toward violence. Two alternative model have been postulated in literature as capable cause of stigma in individuals with epilepsy: the first model assumes a direct influence of epilepsy on stigma, meaning that perception of stigma will increase as seizure severity and lack of maintaining seizure control increases. The second model, which is psychosocial, assumes that other individual characteristics are also important and therefore have an explanatory role in the degree of stigma perceived by an individual with epilepsy. This study hypothesized that epilepsy is not globally stigmatizing and that the psychosocial factors are equally important in explaining_perception of stigma among individuals with epilepsy. It foremost documents the prevalence of perceived stigma among a sample of patients with epilepsy and examined the causal factors of this stigma using some predictable variables·. Methods Subjects The subjects were selected from among patients on follow-up management at the clinics of two psychiatric facilities in Nigeria: the Neuro-psychiatric hospital Aro and the University College Hospital Ibadan. Most of the patients in these clinics are either self-referred or brought by relatives. Only a few of the new patients at these clinics would have received any form of orthodox medical care for their illness before presentation. A total of 264 subjects were interviewed over a 4 month counseling sessions at each of "the clinic days. This sample size was based on the 37% cases of psychiatric morbidity found in a previous study Gureje (1991) among epileptics seen at the Neuro-psychiatric hospital Aro Nigeria. Criteria for inclusion were: (a) epilepsy diagnosed on clinical and EEG findings, (b) adults epilepsy in the age range of 21-65 years, (c) absence of evidence of mental sub-normality or other gross diagnosable neurological disorders, (d) attendance at follow-up at the clinics for at least a period of three months prior to interview. This latter criterion is necessary so as to guarantee all vital investigations prior to clinical diagnosis. 66 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY Olley, B.: Perceived Stigma Among Nigerian Individuals with Epileps)' Measures Perceived Stigma Due to the non-availability of an established culturally relevant instrument jo determine perceived stigma among epileptics in Nigeria, it was imperative or the researcher to develop an instrument, which will help in assessing the concept. This was accomplished by employing the judgment of experts and learning directly from epileptic patients themselves Nunnally, (1978). In order to achieve this, a focus group discussion (FGD) session was conducted separately with a purposive sampling of 10 (5 'men and 5 women) of epileptic patients who were on follow-up at the neurology clinic of the Neuro-psychiatric Hospital Aro, Abeokuta. The FGD was instituted due to the nature of the concept and the relative lack of background information. It was made to encourage patients to talk about what they perceived to be stigmatizing about their illness and what they perceived as their limitations as patients with epilepsy. They were asked questions on their general knowledge about their illness, the causes and the management of the illness. The researcher who also served as the moderator jotted points. -A psychologist youth corper served as an observer. The subsequent scripts were reviewed, and it was possible to produce a list of 19 potential stigma items. Responses to the items were coded on a five point Likert format scale, ranging from never (score of zero) to often (score of four). The 19-item scale was pre-tested among 71 other epileptics who were also on follow-up at the same clinic. The purpose of the pre-testing was to further establish validity as well as the reliability of instrument. Internal consistency was established by obtaining a significant relationship between each item and the total score. . Correlation between each item and the total score ranged from +0.41 to +0.52 p