THE TRANSFORMATION OF CORRESPONDENCE EDUCATION TO DISTANCE EDUCATION IN NIGERIA, 1927-1987 By Gbolagade Adekanmbi B.Ed. Adult Education; M.Ed. Industrial Education {Ibadan} A Thesis in the Department of Adult Education Submitted to the College of Education in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy of the UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN September 1992 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY ii ABSTRACT This study examined the trqnsformation of correspondence education to distance education in N~geria, from 1927 to 1987. This was against the background of the transformation of the novel system of instruction in many other parts of the world. Investigations have shown the extreme attachment of the system in Nigeria to the old methods and media of instruction. This is in spite of the long history of correspondence education in Nigeria, where its first alumnus took his degree in 1927. Yet the prevalent use of the, term distance education to describe practices in the field gives the impression that there has indeed been a trans- formation. This study was thus carried out to examine the extent to which transformation has taken place. The historical approach'was adopted in which an extensive study of archivai materials and documents was carried out. Interviews were conducted with alumni, present students of the system and practitioners alike. The study identified a number of periods in the transformation process. These are: UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY iii i. the period of external examinations and foreign correspondence'colleges; ii. the period of local initiatives and entrepreneurship in correspondence education; iii. the period of university involvement; and iv. the transformation period in embryo. These four periods exposed the gradual transformation of the methods, the media, support services, two-way communication system, courses in and clientele of correspondence education, thus paving the way for the emergence of distance education. Some of the findings of the study are: i. the foundations for the transformation of correspondence education to distance education have not been totally laid; ii. most of the institutional'providers of correspondence educationiri Nigeria are not fully committed to the promotion of its transformation; iii. the impact of an increased number of radio and television stations in the country, UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY iv or of the satellite and computer systems has not been fully felt in the trans- formation process. In view of the above, the researcher recommends the following, among others: i. the need for more government involvement in the funding and quality control of / distance education systems in Nigeria; . " ... , ii. the need for distance education institutions to have policies on develop- ment aimed at further bridging,the distance between them and their clientele; iii. the need to make existing structures which signify media development in the country relevant to media growth in distance education. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am grateful to Professor Michael Omolewa, my Supervisor and mentor, whose support transcends the confines of this attempt at scholarship; to Professor Jones A. Akinpelu whose qualities were an inspiration; to Professor C.N. Anyanwu, who as Head of Department gave me the needed support; and to all the members of staff of the Department of Adult Education, University of Ibadan for their various forms Of encouragement. I acknowledge the assistance of Professor Borje Holmberg who linked me ~arly with The Institute for Research into Distance Education (ZIFF) in Germany whose materials helped clear the initial maze in this study. In a related respect, I also thank the Kellogg Project of the Syracuse University New York whose invitation to me for a one-month stay in Syracuse, U.S.A. from February 10 - March 10, 1991 made possible the use of the Stevenson Bird Library, the. George Arent's Research Library, and the contact with Don Ely of the Instructional Development Divisim of the University. It also provided a link with UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY vi Professor Emeritus and Professor (Mrs) Alexander Charters, and Professor Roger Hiemstra of the Univer- sity. I therefore acknowled~e the support of all these people including the Kellogg office staff. In particular is my gratitude to Terry Keenan, the Adult Education Manuscripts Librarian of Arent's for his assistance and friendship. My thanks also go to Michael Lambert of the National Home Study Council in Washington, U.S.A. who granted me an interview during my U.S. trip and eventually linked me up with Dennis Foltz of the Geomological Institute of 'America, who in turn sent me some correspondence education materials. I am also grateful to the Ajifowobajes in New York and the Taiwos in Maryland, U.S.A. who gave the needed support during my academic stay. Again, I wish to thank Anita Gay of the Augsburg College, Mineapolis, U.S .A. for her' Lnsp Lri.nq calls during my stay. I wish to thank the numerous heads of various organisations in Nigeria who granted me the opportunity for interviews. Some of these are Mrs. Okudolo, wife of the late founder of the Exam Success UNIVERSITY OF IBA AN LIBRARY vii Correspondence College, Lagos and Mr. P.Y. Folorunso of the same College; Mr. Hafiz Wali, founding Director of the National Teachers' Institute and former Director of the African Programmes and Information Services of the Commonwealth of Learning (COL); Mrs. Fagbuyi, Head of the Bilateral Agreements, commonwealth and African Affairs Branch (BACAA) of the Federal Ministry of Education; Lagos; Dr. Onyekwere and Mr. Olatunji of the same office; and Mrs. Lara Euler-Ajayi, who was the former Head of the Vocational and Non-Formal Education Section of the Federal Ministry of Education, and Mr. Bode Alalade, General Manager of NTA, Channel 7 (Ikeja) at Tejuoso for the documents given to me. I express my sincere gratitude to my friends for their support and encouragement. I remember Tunde Babalola, Philip Ait~ Lekan Ayantunji, Seyi Sadare, Julius Eniola, and ~specially, Mike Bola ~ M2jai (MBM) Avoseh for being a source of inspiration, motivation, and a fellow traveller on this scholarship road. I also thank Mr. Layi Ajayi of the Institute of Education, University of Ibadan who painstakingly typed this final draft. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY viii My thanks also go to my fellowship and Church, the Word Communication Ministries, whose Ministers and members continuously kept' the oil in their lamps during this research, and especially when I had to be on the road searching for needed data and information. I am extremely grateful to Dr. and Mrs Ogunsanwo of the University of Ibadan; to my family and in-laws; to the Muhammeds, the Alukos and the Adeniyis; to my brother, Mr. Lekan Adekanmbi, who, since December 1963, has been my father and mentor; to my children, Folasade and Bukola who tolerated my long absence; and to my wife, Arinola Rebecca, whose unflinching support and belief in this cause, were a constant source of inspiration. Finally, I acknowledge the dlv~~e presence of God in all the efforts that have now culminated in this work. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY ix DEDICATION To God from Whom my blessings flow UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY x CERTIFICA'rION I cortify that this work wa? carried out by Mr. GboJ wad~ Ad kanrnbi Ln the Depa~trnent of Adult Education, University of Ibadan. SUP~RVISOR M. A. Ornolewa B.A.; Ph.D. (Ibadan) Professor of Adult Education University of Ibadan Ibadan,' NIGERIA. 1 September 1992. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xi TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE Abstract -------------------------------------- ii Acknowledgements ------------------------------ v Dedication ------------------------------------ ix Certification --------------------------------- x Table of Contents ----------------------------- xi List of Tables -------------------------------- ~viii List of Figures ------------------------------- xix List of Abbreviations ------------------------- xx CHAPTER ONE : INTRODUCTION -------------------- 1.1 Background to the Study ------------- 1.2 Statement of the Problem ------------ 19 1.3 Objectives of the Study ----------,-- 21 1.4 Research Questions ------------------ 23 1.5 Scope of the Study ------------------ 25 1.6 Significance of the Study ----------- 28 1.7 Limitations of the Study ------------ 29 1.8 Definition of Terms ----------------- 30 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xii PAGE CHAPTER TWO: CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK ------------ 36 2.1 Introduction -----~------------------- 36 2.2 Analysis of the Concept of Transform- ation, Correspondence Education and Distance Education ----------------- 37 2.3 Models of Correspondence Education---- 61 2.4 Summary ------------------------------ 69 2.5 Models of Distance Education---------- 72 2.6 A Model of Transformation of Correspon- dence Education to Distance Education 96 -CHAPTER THREE: Review of'Literature ~--------- 101 3.1 Introduction ------------------------- 101 3.2 The origins of Correspondence Education 101 3.2.1 The Nigerian Origins ---------- 1181- 3.3 The Significance of the University of London Innovation --------------- 124 3.4 Trends in the De~elopment of Correspondence Education Methods 141 3.5 Media Transformation and the Bridging of Distance --------------- 156 3.6 Two-way Communication and other Patterns of Interaction --------------------- 179 3.7 Issues of Quality in Distance Education 184 3.8 Summary ------------------------------ 193 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xiii PAGE CHAPTER FOUR: METHODOLOGY -------------------- 197 4.1 Introduction ------------------------ 197 4.2 Sources of Data --------------------- 200 4.3 Data Gathering Tools ---------------- 202 4.4 Analysis of Data ----------~--------- 208 CHAPTER FIVE THE ERA OF FOREIGN CORRESPONDENCE COLLEGES IN NIGERIA ~----------- 209 5.1 Introduction ------------------------ 209 5.1.1 Before 1927 : An Emerging Innovation Through External Examinations ------------------ 210 5.1.2 The Nature of Entry and the Category of Clientele -------- 216 5.1.3 Methods of Instruction ------- 218 5.1.4 The Media of Instruction ----- 220 5.1.5 Nature of S~pport Services --- 222 5.1.6 Pattern of Two-way Interaction 223 5. 1 .7 Issues of Quality and Quantity 223 5.1.8 Summary 226 5.2 1927-1947: Entrance of the Alumni and the Continuation of External Examin- ations ---------------------------- 228 5.2.1 The Coming of the Alumni ------ 229 5.2.2 Growth of Media of Instruction 231 5.2.3 Nature of Support Services----- 234 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xiv PAGE 5.2.4 Issues of Quality and Quantity 235 5.2.5 Pattern of Two-way Communication 238 5.2.6 Summary ---------------------- 239 5.3 1948-1959: Pre-Independence Develop- ments ----------------------------- 241 5.3.1 The Founding of the University College, Ibadan -------------- 241/ 5.3.2 The Emergence of Television--- 253 5.3.3. Trends in the Growth of Methods and Media -------------------- 260 5.3.4 Issues of Quality and Quantity 261 5.3.5 Summary ---------------------- 263 CHAPTER SIX : POST INDEPENDENCE DEVELOPMENTS--- 267 6.1 1960-1973: The Growth of Local Correspondence Colleges ----------- 267 6.1.1 The Corningof Exam Success Correspondence College ------- 268 6.1.2 Ahmadu Bello University's Involvement in Correspondence Education -------------------- 281 6.1.3 Further Developments in Methods and Media -------------------- 283 6.1.4 Developments in the Nature of Support Services ---------- 287 6.1.5 Summary ---------------------- 296 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xv PAGE 6.2 1974-1987: The Transformation in Embryo --------------------------- 299 '6.2.1 The Emergence of the Corres- pondence and Open Studies Institute (COSIT) ----------- 299 6.2.2 The Coming of the National Teachers' Institute --------- 310 6.2.3 The Nigerian Educational Tech~ nology Centre (NETC) -------- 318 6.2.4 The Entry and Exit of the National Open University ---- 322 6.2.5 New Perspectives on the Develop- ment of Media and Methods---- 334 6.2.6 Issues of Quality and Quantity 337 6.2.7 Summary --------------------- 346 6.3 Post-1987 Developments: Projections of Pattern of Transformation------ 348 6.3.1 The Re-emergence of the University of Ibadan's External -/ Studies Programme------------ 348 6.3.2 The Coming of the Commonwealth of Learning (COL)------------ 363 6.3.3 Return to Abuja : New Wine in an Old Bottle --------------- 373 6.3.4 Satellite Systems and the Computer Influx ------------- 379 6.3.5 Projections of the Transform- ation ----------------------- 389 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xv PAGE 6.2 1974-1987: The Transformation in Embryo --------------------------- 299 '6.2.1 The Emergence of the Corres- pondence and Open Studies Institute (COSIT) ----------- 299 6.2.2 The Coming of the National Teachers' Institute --------- 310 6.2.3 The Nigerian Educational Tech~ nology Centre (NETC) -------- 318 6.2.4 The Entry and Exit of the National Open University ---- 322 6.2.5 New Perspectives on the Develop- ment of Media and Methods---- 334 6.2.6 Issues of Quality and Quantity 337 6.2.7 Summary --------------------- 346 6.3 Post-1987 Developments: Projections of Pattern of Transformation------ 348 6.3.1 The Re-emergence of the University of Ibadan's External ~ Studies Programme------------ 348 6.3.2 The Coming of the Commonwealth of Learning (COL)-~---------- 363 6.3.3 Return to Abuja : New Wine in an Old Bottle --------------- 373 6.3.4 Satellite Systems and the Computer Influx ------------- 379 6.3.5 Projections of the Transform- ation ----------------------- 389 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xvi PAGE CHAPTER SEVEN SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS -------------- 394 7.1 Introduction ----------------------- 394 7.2 Summary of Findings ---------------- 394 7.3 Conclusion ------------------------- 406 7.4 Recommendations -----~-------------- 409 7.4.1 Recommendation for Further Research -------------------- 419 BIBLIOGRAPHY --------------------------------- 422 APPENDICES -------------------------------~--- 433 1. Transformation of Correspondence Education to Distance Education Tracer Study Questionnaire ---------------- 433 2. Interview Guide I (Alumnae of Foreign Correspondence Education Institutions Interview) ------------------------- 435 3. Interview Guide II (Students of Cor- respondence Education Institutions Interview) ------------------------- 442 4. Interview Guide III (Administrators and Directors of ;Correspondence Education Institutions Interview)--- 444 5. Interview with the Assistant Director of Education, Bilateral Agreement, Commonwealth and African Affairs, Federal Ministry of Education, Victoria Island, Lagos ---------------------- 446 6. Names, Status, Addresses of Inter- viewees and Places of Interview----- 449 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xvii PAGE 7 . Cover page of Chemistry Course text of the Rapid Results'College, London 454 8 . .Cover page of Government Course text of the Exam Success Correspondence College ---------------------------- 455 9 . Title page of Biology Course text of the Correspondence and Open Studies Institute of the University of Lagos 456 10. Title page of the Course text ADE 309 (Field Work in Adult Education) of the University of Ibadan External Studies Programme ------------------ 457 1 1 ~ Letter of admission of Fatumise Lawrence of P.o. Box 283, Epe, Lagos into the University of Abuja's Centre for Distance Learning and Continuing Education (9th March 1992) 458 12. COSIT Newsletter of March 1992------ 460 13. University of Ibadan's ESP News of April 1992 ------------------------- 466 14. Blank copy of the Certificate of S Studentship of the Exam Success Correspondence College, Ikorodu Road, Lagos-------------------~------------ 475 15. COSU Paper for the Ad-Hoc Committee on the Reorganisation of the Corresp- ondence and Open Studies Unit, 8th November, 1982---------------------- 476 16. Educational Correspondence Colleges (Registration, etc.) Decree 1977---- 491 17. Educational Correspondence Colleges Accreditation Decree 1987 ---------- 497 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xviii LIST OF TABLES PAGE ~ABLE TITLE A Comparison of Correspondence Educ- ation and Distance Education---------- 59 2 Enrolment at Formal Educational Institutions in Nigeria, 1926-1966---- 120 3 Performance of Nigerian Students at the December 1937 School Certificate Examinations ------------------------- 237 4 First Set of University of Ibadan's External Studies Programme Students--- 356 5. University of Ibadan's External Studies Programme Registered Students 357 6. University of Ibadan External Studies Programme Study Centres and their Coordinators ------------------------- 360 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xix PAGE LIST OF FIGURES FIGURE TITLE 1 The Correspondence School Model ---- 64 2 The Consultation Model~-------~----- 78 3 A Distance Teaching University Model 83 4 A Model of Transformation of Corres- pondence Education to Distance Education --------------------------- 98 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xx LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS BBC British Broadcasting Corporation C~ Commonwealth of Learning COSIT Correspondence and Open Studies Institute DLS Distance Learning System DSE Schriftenreihe der Dentschen Stiftung fur internationale Entwicklung (German Foundation for International Development) ETV Educational Television FRCN Federal Radio Corporation of Nigeria ICCE International Council for Correspondence Education ICDE International Co~ncjl for Distance Education ICS International Correspondence Schools IUC Inter.University Council NBS Nigerian Broadcasting Service NERDC Nigerian Educational Research and D~velopment Council NHSC National Home Study Council NTA Nigerian Television Authority NTI National Teachers' Institute ~C National Universities Commission MC Rapid Results College UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY xxi TISEP Teacher-In-Service Programme UCC University Correspondence College ZIFF Zentrales Institut Fur Fernstudien- forschung UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1.1 BACKGROUND TO THE STUDY The emergence of the correspondence system of education in the early part of the 18th Century marked a turning point in the provision of educational opportunities for millions of people allover the world. It signified a major departure from the traditional face-to-face approach to teaching and learning, by making it possible for teachers and learners to be separated in time and space,'for what Moore des- cribed as "both the preactive and the interactive phases of teaching".1 While the growth of this novel approach and its consequent diffusion from Europe, Australia and America to other parts of the world w~s made possible by the various educational, geographical and socio-economic circumstances of the innovation-accepting countries, the development of new communication systems had greatly influenced its easy application. For example, the H. C. MJore, cit.edin ,Borge HolnbeDg", 1 . Status and Trends ill Dlstance Bducatii.o.n London Kogan Page. 1981, p. ". For a C11seus"Stroln the extensive use of the system to educate large nurrberof citizens all aver the «orl.d, see M3.ckenzieand E.L. Christensen, 'TheChanging W:>rld of Correspcndertce·Study. University Park: 'ThePennsylvania State University Press. 1971i and, Katia Siqueira de Freitas et. al. "Nm-Traditicnal Study Proqram: An overvaew" ICDE Bulletin. Vol. 12 Sept. 1986. pp. 38-40. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 2 coming of the mail delivery system, whose art the University of Paris had perfected since the 13th cen- tury, 1 the emergence of the radio in 1902 and its f~rther development in 1906 by one Fessenden of 2 the University of Pittsburg in the U.S.A. ; and the earlier invention in 1875 of the telephone 3 had provided some background for the avenues which the modalities for transmitting instructions would later take. The coming of improved transportation system as typified by the invention of the internal combustion engine towards the end of the 19th Century had made it possible for man and goods to be transported at a speed of 140 kilometres an hour. 4 By 1945, it was reported that the jet aircraft was already doing ten times the , , 1. The Encyclo~ia Amelficana (International Edition) NewYork: Americana COrPQration.,9bI. p.428. Genrany, Italy, England and the United States later had their postal systems begun in the 15th, 16th, and the 17th Centuries with England establishing a public post in 1635 while "Arrerican Post Proper" was started in 1691. ' 2. Fessenden had succeeded in pioneering 'the "first broadcast in history" VJhenhe "used wireless waves to carry the hunan voice over a distance of rrore than ore kilorretre". See Olu Ladel e , V •O. Adefela and o. Iasekan, History of bhe Nigerian Broad:::asting Corporation, Ibadan: Ibadan University Press. 19/9. p. 2. 3. The invention of the t.eIephone had preceeded that of the radio by about twenty-six years. One interesting observation has been the progressive reduction of distance over the years, between each invention and its app.li.cat.Lon, For phJto:::::opy,it was 112 years; telephone, 56 years; for radio, 35 years and for television, it was 12 years. 4 . Edgar Faure, (Ed.) Learning to be. Faris: Unesco. 1972, p. 89. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 3 original speed of the improved wheel. Indeed, by the 1960's, astronauts who travelled to the moon, were on. their landing, seen simultaneously on earth by hundreds of millions of people, millions of miles away.1 These breakthroughs in the growth of communication were not the only events that helped in reducing the distance between man and his fellow men in time and space. The coming of the industrial revolution itself as a major harbinger of the communication breakthroughs madeit possib: e for di.st.ance to be bridged. First, it brought'a boost to the growth in technology and reduced the physical separatedness of nations and the various nationalities. Second, it brought with it a rapid increase in the spirit of merchantilism and free enterprise. Third, it ensured tha t a, multiplier effect was given to g,oods production which then took on the mass edq'e to it. Any commodity, 1. .This developnent in hunan space travel pimeered by the Soviet Unionwith the landing of Sp.rtnik in 1957has had tremenCbus imp:tct en the develc:pnetn of educational and other distance- reducing te:::hnologies. See Learning at a Distance and the NEW 'I'e:::hnologyV, anccuver: Educational Research Instib.lte of British Colunbia. 1982, pp. 31-39. Also, the recent widespread sale of mcoi Ie and cellular rhenes and the successful orgmisatim of S3.tellite Cmferences by AIrericanand Jap3.lleseexecutives whowere afraid of travelling during the re:::ently ccncluded Gllf W:trhostilities are fall-cuts fran space technology research. (The researcher was in the United States of AIrericabetweenFebruary and M:lrch1991and listened to manyreport.s en the Cable NewsNetwork(CNNw) hich discussed this phencmencnextensively) . UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 4 services or materials could be mass produced, using an extended division of labour and stressing co- op~ration, team spirit and a growing sense of specia- lty. These issues later provided a basis for Otto peter's theory in correspondence education as we shall see. The attendant effect of all these developments on the various existing educational provisions, including correspondence education was extensive. While for instance the medium of instruction in correspondence education gradually gave way from an initial heavy reliance on print to other media, a significant shift was marked in the changes that were to inform the pattern of growth in the field. Consequently, new terms began to emerge in the literature in the field to further bring home these new dimensions of growth. Terms like "telekolleqg", "teleconferencinq", and "distance education" began to find various levels of usage. At another level of the spectrum, the relationship between the obvious appeal to the mass audience of post industrial revolution found some theoretical level of linkage with corres- pondence education. If industrial revolution signified UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 5 the coming 'of the division of labour; of the need to have areas of specialisation; of the need to mass produce to satisfy the clientele, then correspondence education, which shares these characteristics may have been the most industrialized form of education. 1 The general growth in the pattern of sophisti- cation of the society; of the coming of the new nations as a result of the withdrawal of Colonial Governments; and of the growing demands on the purse of many a govern- ment to continue to finance fully the education of its citizens, led to the errergertCeof a new kind of clientele for correspondence educatiqn institutions. These changes and others were not without their effects on the general pattern of growth and development of correspondence educa tion. In some ways, the programmes of correspondence education had to change to reflect the changes in the environment. At other times, the 1 • This is a najor posbllaticnand ccntributim to distance education theory which O. Peters has made. See for example his works: "TheoreticalAspects of Correspondenceinstructim" in O. M:ickenzieand E.L. Olristalsen (eds), The Olan<{ingYbrld of Correspc:ndenceStudy. UniversityPan: Pamsylvam.a State University Press 1971, pp.223-8 and "Distanceteachingand industrialproduction:a Comparativeinterpretatim in cutline". In D. Sewart, D. Keegan andB. Holrrberg(eds.) Distance Education Intematimal F. ~ECtives, Lmdm: Croan Helm pp. 95 - 113. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 6 methods of'instruction had to change to reflect the more robust technology that the environment could offer, or relate to the liberal attitude which the new clientele demanded. Still at other times, the changes in approach to correspondence education activities were so subtle, so profoundly transient that they could not be easily treaceable to any known factor. Where this was the case, ,changes are sometimes found to have resulted from an intrinsically woven factor in the entire process of correspondence education itself. However, in ascertaining the nature of change and the factors that promote this, one major theme appears to have stood out more clearly than the others. Around this cauldron of the explanation of change in the growth of this novel approach to teaching and learning is the one arising from an attempt to con- sider the term correspondence education as not being capable of now fully carrying the weight of the totality of experience that actually operates in the field1 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 • u.e change in name of the body, InternaticnalCamcil for CorrespcndenceEducatim (ICCE).to InternationalCamcil for Distance Educatim (ICDE) en June 14, 1982 was a clirraxin the series of attempts to reflect a paradigmatic shift in the transfc atim fran "Correspcndenceeducation" to distance educaticn". Apart fran the new term catering for the grc:JN'idnigverse nanberst moefdtihuem boofdpyr,initt wahliscohdwea-sentphheashiasLelsmtahrek eoxfttrheenesryesltieamnocfe ¥in1stth:eJ:u.c;tl of Corresp::::ndenecdeucation in view of the new technolog~eswuch adorn the field. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY I I either at the level of practice or at the more f oundationa 1 level of theory. It is the somehow simple explanation of its transformation from the generally accepted name, or perhaps culture of correspondence education to distance education. Going purely by the book, the term distance education is variously seen as properly locating the focus of the activities which correspondence education practices of old depict, or should depict at the present time. The element of tim~ here is seen as a factor of the aggregate of the growth of communication and its related technology, and the tendency to want to explain correspondence education activities in the light of new ideas and actual happenings. Thus a transformation here, signi- fying change in the correspondence education of old, can only be in the direction of the latest term "distance education. " 1 The attempt at this point is not to plot a graph of correspondence education along a path that sees the term growing and one day becoming distance education. The point however is that wherev.er correspondence education had found some level of usage in theory and in practice, it may as well be logical to expect that InternationalCamcil for DistanceFducatim, 1982 Conference Reportand Handbcx::k, pp. 28 - 30. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 8 there has been a growth and development in correspondence education, with such growth being in the direction of~creating new sets of descriptions for happenings in the field, based on changes in the media and methods used. Thus, in examining the transformation, of cor- respondence education, we are examining the extent to wh i ch it has transformed into what could easily be referred to as distance education. The essence of this patterning thus automatically shifts from just the terms to the wider issue of determining how the changes have gone especially based on certain expectations. In Nigeria, as in many developing nations, the transformation of correspondence education to distance education may well be an acknowledgement of the extent to which some specific methods and media have been significantly changed as to make the practice to be seen in terms of distance education. In view of the relative growth of the system and its new demands, it becomes necessary to historically place in appropriate perspectives what the nature of change has been. This change situates the medium of correspondence education within the context of its capacity for UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 9 bridging the distance between the learner and the institutional provider on the one hand, and between the learner and ac t.ua L learning outcomes on the other. Between the greater epochs spanning the sixty-year period -of the study, the pattern and trends of the transformation of the system will be examined along a historical dimension. ED far an examination of the development of the system of correspondence education in many parts of the world, especially in places where the idea originally diffused to Nigeria reveals that there has been a transformation from correspondence education to distance education. Such a transformation can only be best described as partial in the case of Nigeria. This description is not only' contrary to the ideal when one considers the length of time the practice has been on in Nigeria, it is -also dysfunctional and is a great indictment on the promotion of an educational innovation whose ben~fits, past, present and potential for the development of the nation's educational, social and economic and technological systems are tremendous. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 1 0 Where there is a proper growth of the system of correspondence education in Nigeria~ issues of con- tinuous heavy reliance on the medium of print should not only have been reduced, other media, especially the modern ones should have emerged 1 in the field. A foray into the history of the system will explain thi s point more. The use of the print medium to relay educational messages to the clientele of correspondence education in Nigeria in the early beginnings of the use bf the novel teaching approach may have been in line with the level of development at the time. About 1887 when the London Univer?ity first op~ned its doors to Nigerians to benefit from the opportunities of obtaining 1. This was the issue which Anthony W. Bates was raising which he referred to Soren Nipper's assertion that. there is already a t.h Lr d generation distance education, where a greater facility for two-way communication and more access to communication between student and teacher is provided. See A.W. Bates, "Third Generation Distance Education: The Challenge of New Technology," in Research in Distance Education. Vol. 3 No.2, April, 1991. p.11 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 11 a degree at a distance,1 the level of development of the general communication systems was very low. In-Britain, from which Nigeria, like most other Colonies had had the first contact with the use of radio through the "Empire Broadcasting", 2 up till 1929, attempts were still being made to ensure the launching 1. Michael Qrolewa, "Historical Antecedents of Distance Educatirn in Nigeria 1887-1960". Adult Education of Nigeria, Vol. 7 Dec. 1982. p. 7. The Unlversity 'of Londonhad-in fact been established in 1836 and was a rrajor innovatirn in opening university educatirn provisirns v.Drldwide. Its 1858 Olart.er not rnly dispensed with the requi.rerrent. of at.t.endance at ell approved examinatirn, citizens' fran the ,"Elnpire" (later "CcrrmcnweLath") cc:uld register for external degree examinations. Lcndcn University I s examinatic;n-board" role thus created the tuiticn-support g'lp which rnly correspcndence educaticnal provisions ccoLd fill. See LEonard Valore and Grover E. Diehl, "The Effectiveness and Acceptance of Hone Study" National HarreStudy Cc:uncil M:nograph. April, 1987. p. 15. 2. The first regular prograrrrnes fran . the British Brred:::::asting Coq:oratirn were brcadca st. to Australia, Canada, India, Sourh Africa & West Africa on 19th Dec., 1932. The narre of the service eventually became the External. Service of the BBCin 1948. See. Asa Bri<,Bs, History of the Brredcasting in the United Kingdan, Lcndrn: Oxford Universi ty Press 1965, Vol. II, p. 38. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 12 of the scheme 1 not to talk of its possible educational or other uses, apart from neWs and entertainment. The ~ame story is true of the use of the television and other electronic means for entertainment purposes and later, instructional use. However, there have been a lot of changes in the communication systems available for en t.e r t a Lr.me.nt. or other office uses in Nigeria2 since these early beginnings but the same cannot be said of the field of correspondence education which has continued to rely on its same old medium of print, many years after it was introduced into the ~,t: ' •.,. country. Unlike its counterparts in other parts of the world, it has continued to wear a totally conventional I print gown. I 1. A wired brm.d:::asting service kncwn as the Rldio Dis- tributicn Service was finally corrmissimed in Lagos on Decerrber 1, 1935 with BBCprograrrme being relayed fran 11.30 a.m. to 1.00 p.m. and fran 5.00 p.m. to 11.00 p.m. da.ily. Olu Ladele, V.o. Adefela, O. Lasekan, History of the Nigerian Brcad::::asting Corppratim, op , cit. p. 8. 2. This grc:wth is noticeable in all the areas of carrnunication, including transportaticn, rredia develcprent and the general grc:wth of mass media hc:uses. In the TIB.SS rredia grc:wth, anolewa reports that 31 newspapers and 31 elec:trcnic rredia Stations and televisim statims were available in 1985. See M. OnolewaI "&l.rvey of Current Cut; of School and Adult Education Programre and Resc:urces" in Nigerian Educatimal Research Cc:uncil (NEK:) later (NERDC, )Research Studies on POfUlatim Educatim in Nigeria. Laoos , 1985 pp. 171-177. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 13 At another level of discourse, one of the major .jpractices of correspondence education institutions '~. in the country has been the use of a method that relies on the production of course texts, prepared as course units, and sent to learners, .wh o on receiving them read up the mo~ules, answer the questions raised and return same to the institutional providers for the tutor's comments. 1 This two-way communication, in the view of the original protagonists of the system, is germane to a healthy educational rapport between learner and teacher, and thus ensures a proper bridging of the physical distance between them. It may be necessary to ask in what direction this trend has grown in terms of transforming the system from its oldest practices to now, when the entire spectrum of knowledge has now expanded, and access to information by the learners is expected to be greater. Preliminary investi- gations do reveal however that rather than 'qrow positively in the direction of having an improvement upon earlier activities, sharp commercial practices, the penchant 1 . This practicewas comroc:inn the heydays of Corresp:::ndence education in Nigeria when the Fapid Results College,the wlsey Hall were patrcnisedby many Nigerians. Scripts were pranptly returnedwith correctionsin submissions made by the students._.- UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 1 4 ') to rush things, and the relative growth in the number 0 f c lien te Le now undergoing corxespondence education programmes, may have reduced the element of two-way communication in the field, thus reducing the method to a one-way traffiG flow. 1 This negative development appears to be true of correspondence education at the secondary school or tertiary levels of activities in respect of what institutional providers do or .do not do. A possible resultant effect of the above is the issue of quality of instruction.2 This is perhaps related to what organisations have over the years, especially within the period of this study, joined the queue in order to promote correspondence education. What are the exact motives for their coming and how prepared are they to deliberately make learning easier 1. A tendency tcwards a one-way traffic flON in Comnunicatim is antithetical to the views expressed by Baath, Holmberg and other writers on Distance Educatim. For Example, see J. A. Baath, Correspcndence Educatim in the light of a number of Cmtemp?rary Teaching MXlels. M3.lroo: Liber Hermcxls, 1979. 2. The issue of quality beca:res important here when one cmsiders the grONingnurrber of clientele being served. At the Natimal Teachers' Institute, more than 31 ,000 learners are being served while the University of Thadan EXternal Studi.es Progranme has over 2,500 learners. Marking assignments and scripts of these learners thus becares probIernat.i.c. For more details of figures of those being served, see M.O. Akintayo, "Jnvestrnent; in Educatim in Nigeria. The Relevance of Distance Education". The Canrrcnweatlh of Learning Study FellONships Prcx:rranme1990. pp. 77 78. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 15 rather than just be another route to a Certificate or Degree for an estranged individual struggling to read and work at the same time? Investigations have indeed shown that it is one thing to talk about accred- itation to ensure quality at official quarters (e.g. University Senates; Ministry of Education, or other agencies) but it is another thing to ensure the main tenance of ~stanOards at another level and succeed in the bridging of distance. The nature of structures and organisations that daily emerge to carry out delegated responsibilities for correspondence education provision or to serve as the main institutional providers depends on a number of factors. Where individuals run correspondence education institutions as proprietors, street sense sometimes predicts the possibly expected static nature of activities and a lack of willingness to improve on the method and media of education because of the higher costs. Where Universities engage in correspondence UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 16 education activities in the country, the fact that they start such on their own and outside of the bud~et 1 statutorily allocated by the National Univer- sities Commission sort of put them into a straight jacket of failing to develop the necessary method and media infractures that showl a possible glide towards distance education. In Nigeria, the only two major instances to show a possible development of the genre towards the expect- ations of distance education, are premised on: i. the statutory, and sp~cial nature of the founding of the National Teacher's Institute in Nigeria, and that of the Centre for Distance Learning of the University of Abuja, both of which show government's readi- ness to go the whole hog and develop these Centres along the most. modern lines,in con- sonance with related development worldwide; 1. The Nat.i.c!nUaniversitiesCmmission (NUC)had throgh a letterdated February 16, 1987,advised Universities wishing to, or already nmning external studi.esprograrnrres to do so and that it (theN U C) was not respcnsible for financingsuch. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 17 ii. the corning of the Commonwealth of Learning (COL) 1 which is a multi-nation, multi-dollar and multi-media involvement in the field of correspondence education in Nigeria. The latter point above, much as it signifies some sort of hope in the possible direction of growth of correspondence education, is not definitive enough, as to now it would be involved in 'all the correspondence education programmes springing up by their dozen in Nigeria. Also in the examination of the changes over the years, the nature of the support services available to students is germane to the discussion. While the initial problem of the clientele of correspondence educa tion ranged from physica 1 separa tedne ss to sometimes total isolation from their providers, they had the added problem of struggling with the problem of social distance as the subjects they studied were sometimes ·1, '!heCamnmwealth of Learning was establishedby the Carmmwealth Heads of Government in Septercber 1988. Arocng its rnaojr activities are the pranotim and coordinatirn of the sharing of distance tooching rraterials;giving support, to distance teaching institutirnsthrough staff training, programmesof evaluatim and research, and helping distance':' teaching institutims to provide better services to students. See Research in Distance Educatim, April 1989, ~l. 1, No.1. p. 20. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 18 far removed from the cultural and social realities of their environment1. As independence came, and learners later had the opportunity of battling with the bridging of distance at home, the need for support services, and problems of a different nature emerged. For example, the realities of the geographically vast national environment unmatched by appropriate technology now stares the systems in the face. One expects that letterswould travel faster to serve counselling and guidance purposes for correspondence education students of today, while library facilities in formal institutions, even those institutions carrying out the programmes through the External Studies, units v.ouldbe available for clientele use. Also, learners would b~ uble to ~~~~~st ~ftd ~~I~ive information on lhe dates t".r: exami.na1 ions or fior the collection of course materials '. Are the providers of correspondence 1. Onolewa's identificatic:onf this prcblem is ext.enis.vIey treated in his work, "OxfordUniversityDelegacyof Lccal Examinat.i.cn s and SeccridayzEducatim in Nigeria, 1929-1937" in Journal of Educatimal Administratim and History. Universityof Lee~s. Vol. X, No.2y July 1978. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 19 education ready to use newsletters or other information outlets to make appropriate information available to learners to ease the other strains they undergo? 1~2 Statement of the Problem Against the background to the study just examined, the problem of this study can be stated thus; 1. the tendency on the part of correspondence education institutions t,O insist on the same methods and media of instruction while a transformation of correspondence education to distance education would have dictated a more progressive pattern of growth; ii. the inability of correspondence education institut~ns to have an appropriate environ- ment for growth in the direction stated above; iii. the apparent lack of maximum utilization by the possibilities the environment offers to redul the problems of distance that correspondence UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 20 education learners undergo; iv. the absence of appropriate support services for distant learners to further help remove the various forms of distance they undergo; v. the growth in quantity of practice in the field without a corresponding growth in the quality of samei vi. the lack of a Co-ordinated System of ensuring the transformation of the correspondence system of education in Nigeria along the path of a full f Ledqe d distance education system.; vii. the inability of the medium of correspondence education to grow beyond its print level on the one hand, and on the other, the apparently widening varieties of distance now being created when the gap should have been shortened; viii. the lack of appropriate replacement for the absent technological base which is best suited for bridging the distance. Thus,the problem of partial transformation of the genre has the related sub-sets of inappropriate UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 21 growth of the medium of instruction; inappropriate utilisation of available media in the country by the system; lack of growth in two-way communication; extreme reliance on manually operated support service system; lack of proper management of a rise in student number; the trends in the promotion of the qenre for the wrong reasons; lack of proper co-ordin~tion of activLties and related management of quality; and the wide gap between the assumptions underlying the theoretical and practical use of the term "distance educa tion". All these emphasize the existence of a possible partial transformation of the genre. 1 .3 OBJECT IVES OF THE 'iUDY The objectives of t.h' is Study we;,--e to: i. examine the methods, media and scope of correspondence education in Nigeria, prior to and around 1927;' ii. trace the changes that have taken place in the methods, media, and scope of correspondence education within a span of sixty years; UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 22 iii. highlight the nature of these changes along the dimension of bridging 'the distance in distance education; iv. examine transformation in the light of quality of instruction, establishment of support services and the enhancement of the needed two-way communication; v. evaluate the extent to which changes have been positively directed for the promotion of the field of d.ist.ariceveduca t i.on. vi. identify the major problems that may h~ve stiffled the transformation of the ~ystem in the direction of distance education; vii. locate the pattern of change within specific periods and over the entire period under study; viii. make recommendations that would aid the future growth of distance education in Nigeria both at policy making levels and I, I I at the level of instftI utional providers of distance education. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 23 1.4 RESEARCH QUESTIONS Some of the research questions that would thus inform the nature and outcome of this inquiry are: i. What was the nature of the provision of correspondence education in terms of the methods, media, delivery strategies, support services and clientele in each identified period in the study? ii. What structures and agencies were available for running the programmes? iii. What specific problems emerged as a result of the methods and media that were used in bridging distance? iv. At what point specified, did a need for change emerge in the general practice of the field in respect of bridging the distance? UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 24 v , What exactly has been the ,nature of change in the system in line with the expectations of distance education? vi In what ways has the environment stiffled a transformation towards distance education? vii At what levels of the educational programmes which Correspondence education promotes has transformation been noticeable? viii To what extent has there really been a transformation of Correspondence education to distance education? Has it been total, partial or insignificant? ix. How do existing correspondence education institutions maintain the growth of change in the system - in terms of search for co-operation or foreign support; enhancement of quality of instruction? x. In what specific ways should transformation be chane lied? xi. What has been the gr~atest limitation to I the process of transformation? UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 25 1.5 SCOPE OF THE STUDY This study covers the entire sixty- year span from 1927 to 1987. The period chosen, including the starting year of the study are signifi- cant in a number of ways. First, the year 1927 marked the entry of the first Nigerian alumnus of degree by correspondence when Mr. E. O. Ajayi passed the B.A. Degre~ examination in Philosophy at home. 1 Such a tertiary level achievement in those days was celebrated with much funfare, and, considering the fact that the London University which awarded the degree from such a distance did not even provide the back-up tuition, it was a notable achievement worth using as a starting point for such a major study as this. Other significant events within this period include the organisation of other foreign examinations in the country. The Oxford University Delegacy of Local Examinations had operated in Nigeria between 1929 and 1937,2 creating 1. M. Qnolewa,"HistoricalAntecedentsof DistanceEducaticn in Nigeria, 1887-1960" Ope cit. p.15. 2. , "OxfordUniversityDeIeqacyof Local EKaminaticns and SeccndaryEducationin Nigeria, 1929-1937" Ope cit. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 26 a significant interest in Nigerians for the use of the correspondence system of education to achieve the goal of passing the examinations. Also, up till 1951, when the West African Examinations Council (WAEC) was created, 1 the London University had continued to pursue its external examinations work which it started with a lot of vigour, and the WAEC had in fact gone on to promote the General Certificate of Examinations (GCE) of London University up till 1977. While these examinations continued, foreign corre spondence colleges con t.Lrrued to provide the tui tion necessary for the Ni~erj,answ i shi.nq to write the examinations. Part of the scope of this study is therefore the examination of media and methods of correspondence education at this period, and the pattern of transformation of the system over time. The year 1987 which marks the end of the study is also significant. While it was the year-of the reviewed accreditation decree of the Federal Government, ten years after the first one had been issued, it was also the year 1. M. Qnolewa,"The Promotionof Londm UniversityExaminations in Nigeria,1887-1951". 'IheInternatimal Jmmal of African HistoricalStudies,vol. 3, No.4, 1980. p. 652. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 27 of the folmcation for the estGlishn'ienotf the Conm::n~th of learn: (eOL) before it \leS forrrerlysetup in 1988. Representing a multi dollar, multi media, and multi-nation inter- ven tion in distance educa tion in Nigeria, it marked _ a modality shift in the fortunes of the novel approach to teaching and learning in the country. While it may have been some kind of anti climax to the develop- ment o~ the genre in Nigeria, it nevertheless represents a significant pause, aimed at a re-direction of the growth of the system, going by its tall ambitions. In between these years, 1927-1987, a categorisation of correspondence educa tion institutions to be examined thus include: i. foreign-based correspondence colleges; ii. local correspondence colleges engaged in the preparation of students for post primary and other professional examinations; iii. correspondence, external, open or distance learning centres or units of various univer- sities or colleges; iv. statutory bodies set up by government to conduct examinations and run djstanc~ lear~ing programmes. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 28 1.6 SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY Among other things, the study is capable of i. providing an account of the development of Correspondence education in Nigeria within a sixty-year period I since the first Nigerian was awarded a degree through the same system; ii. providing an account of the nature of changes that have taken place in correspondence education in Nigeria over a sixty-year span; iii. equ ipp i.n q adult educators with the information on the chdnges in the field with the aim of assisting policy making; iv. equipping institutionali providers of corres- pondence education, with detailed,knowledge of their field in theory and in practice; v. helping to improve t~e quality of instruction and general practice in the field; vi. providing accounts of the activities of corres- pondence education institutions in the country and the programmes they run; UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 29 vii reducing the problems correspondence education clientele face like isolation and lack of support services by highlighting these i viii. promoting government's greater involvement in terms of increased financial and material support for correspondence education institutioniii; ix. providing new insights into the development of relevant local media of distance education to reduce learner Lso Lat Lon , x. indirectly promoting the development of the formal educational system, especially its technological growth 1 .7 ,"LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY The limitations to this study were the absence of a related study in the past; the relative newness of the activities of tertiary institutions providing distance education at the university level and the near extinction of the activities of foreign Correspondence UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 30 Colleges in Nigeria. The research was also affected by the spate of ethnic, religious and economic riots that took place in the country in 1992 as well as the costs of extensive travelling around the country for interviews of personnel and on~the-spot assessment of distance education institutions. Some of these limitations were however reduced through the upe of interviews of some of the students of the institutions scattered across the country. Also, an extensive use was made of Omolewa's scholarly foray into the field, while the records of the National Archives in Ibadan, and those of institutions running the programme were studied. 1.8 DEFINITION OF TERMS A number of terms are defined in this study to remove ambiguities in meaning and thus place the concepts properly within the context of the research. These terms are: UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 31 1. Correspondence Education The term is used to describe an educational programme in which the teacher and the learner are separatl in time and in place such that the teaching and learning process is carried out through the medium of print. This definition, which shows the system's adherence to the medium of print rather than other media, is the interpretation this study will adopt, except where otherwise explained. 2. Distance Education This is related to the above but with a ,subtle difference. This term as used by Holmberg, covers the various forms of study in which the students are not in direct physical contact with their teachers, but v.hichnevertheless, benefits from the servicesof a tutorial organisation. 'Thecmtent of instruction,between the learnerand th: UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 32 tutor is thus sent through the medium of print, audio, or any other electronic means, or a combination of these. This interpretation is adhered to in this study, and it thus shows the extent to which "distance educa tion" is a development on the practice of "Correspondence education". 3 . Media in the study refers to materials and equipment used in communicatin.g didactic information between the teacher and the learner in Correspondence or distance education. Whi le ·they may serve supplementary purposes, they lie at the core of I distance bridging in correspon~ence or distance education. coupled with the method of teaclh i.nq , media here make this innovative process of teadhing and learning possib Le. It is however these Isame media, as reflec ted in the study which se1rve entertainmen t purposes in the societal contexts in which distance education takes place. At the appropriate points, needed differentiation will be made between media which aid teachers and those wh.ich replace r.h ern , 4. Me)i-:;)dref er s h., the way and m.s nner of giving I instruction to the learner, and having a feedback UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 33 from such, or vice versa, in correspondence and distance education. Examples here include ways of packaging the teaching content in such a way that the objectives, media, content and evaluation of learning are incorporated. It refers to, on the one hand, a description of what happens, when the face-to-face approach of teaching and learning is removed, while at the level of exceptions to the rule, the face~to-face method becomes supplemental to the process. A method here is also expected to leave room for a two~way interaction between the teacher and the learner. Method here also refers to the process of preparing the instructional material as such process represents the simulation of the teaching and learning situation. S. Clientele The "clientele" of distance education are the students or learners in the system. 6 . Transformation This term means change. In this study, it is used to describe the changes ~hat have taken place in correspondence education prac~ices, such as are reflective of a trend towards distance education. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 34 7 . Independent St'U~y In this study, the researcher shares the view of "independent study" taken by Charles Weddemeyer, who sees it as encompassing "several teaching~learning arrangements in which teachers and learners carry out their essential tasks and responsibilities apart from one another, communicating in a variety of ways". 1 This definition thus emphasizes the freedom of the learner from the conventional educational demands o f tl.me, space, an d' prescrlp t'lons. 2 Correspondence and distance education programmes are thus in theory, some form of independent study. 7. Open Learning The term "open learning" refers to a context of learning, or a teaching-learning philosophy that gives more freedom to the learners such that learning" is not enclosed or encumbered by barriers, not confined or concealed, but accessible and available,,3 1. Charles Wedderreyer, "Independent;Study". In L. D2ighton (ed.) Encyclopefu of Education Vol. 4, ~w York: M3.crni11:mand Free Press, 1971. 2. G.T. Gleason, "Technical DeveloprrentsRelated to Independent; Learning" in G.T. Gleason (ed.) The 'Theory and Nature .of J Independent Learning. Scranton Pennsylvania: InternationalTextbook, 1967. p.v. 3. C. Wedderneyer, "Tndependent;Study," in A.S. Knowles (ed,) The International Enc 10 :L:t of Higher Education. San Francisco. Jossey Bass. , Vol. . p. 2115 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 35 This term is used in this study as an emerging philosophical ideal yet to find its true level of usage. This is because institutions that share elements of the ideal, at least in some extreme, still have their various levels of closeness or closure.1 8. Teleconferencing The term'tel~conferencing is used to describe the electronic communication between two or more people at a distance, and this may involve the use of the audio, video or interactive computer .. It also refers to the combined use of any of the types identified here. 1 • An example here is the British Open University whose openness in terms of admission criteria is unmatched anywhere in the world, but which nevertheless has its areas of "closure". See D. Harris, Qpenness and Closure in Distance Education. London: The Palmer Press. 1987. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY CHAPTER TWO CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK 2.1 INTRODUCTION In this Chapter, we shall examine the concepts of "transformation", "correspondence education" and "distance education". Transformation will be discussed within the framework of educational change although the social, economic and technological dimensions of such change will be considered. while 'correspondence education'is taken to represent the earliest description of educational provisions organised at a distance, distance education'represents the most modern des- cription of the phenomenon, taking into perspectives the new technologies, media and methods that the system utilises. A conceptualisation of the transformation of correspondence education to distance education thus implies a paradigm shift reflected in trends in the various change processes, practices and significant epochs in the provision of education at a distance. In it are expected to be identified a set of criteria, principles and theoretical postulations emerging from UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 37 literature which have implications for practice and which specifically describe change. In the process, models of correspondence education and distance education will be given, while a model of the transformation process itself will be .proferred for the Study. 2.2 ANALYSIS OF THE CONCEPTS OF TRANSFORMATION, CORRESPONDENCE EDUCATION AND DISTANCE EDUCATION Transf orma tion: The concept of transformation refers to an instance of change, whether in the appearance, shape, quality or nature of a situation, process, object or a phenomenon. It is therefore in this sense normal to talk about economic, social, political or educational transformation when a change is observed over any of the processes identified. In the view of Lippitt,1 The very nature of change implies there is some perceptible difference - in a situation, a circumstance, a person, a group, or an organisation - between some original time and some later time. 1. CordonL. Lippitt,yisualizingChange: Model Building and the Chan<£ Process" Virginia: NIL Resc:urcesCorporationI 1973,p.38. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 38 I suppose hardly anything is measured that will not display s'orne difference between two successive points in time, if the time interval is long enough. In specifically locating the concept of trans- formation within the general purview of change, Lippitt identifies and categorises social change within the sub-divisions of change through transmission and change through transformat~on. In transmission, he observes that change is evolutionary here, occurs without conscious direction and could just be described as changes that "just happeri !", 1 Of change by trans- formation, he sees this occur~ing when individuals, groups or organizations change themselves or others through conscious actions or decisions.2 Such change by transformation can be seen as reactive change on the one hand, or inventive or planned change on the other hand. When the change is reactive, it is seen as "a response to some specific triggering" thus making it automatic and instinctive. When it is planned, its major feature is that it moves the organisation or individual in a new direction. The change presupposes 1. ibid. 2. G.L. Lippitt, Ope cit. p.28 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 39 that the organism or phenomenon involv8d must be so out of balance as to require an entirely new organization structure or mechanism. There is however a sense in which the lines may sometimes be blurred in between change by transmission and change by transformation. For example, changes in culture, life patterns and other behavioural patterns of individuals may be appropriately seen as some form of transformation which is a reflection of the new directions which tech- nological and other innovations may have brought about. Educational processes, methods and media can also be affected by change in such a way as to imply a transformation of the educational phenomenon. Transformation in education may occur as a result of political changes, technological growth, change in government policies, economic growth or an upsurge in social demand for it, or the meeting of such a demand. It may also be a reflection of the improvement or growth in the activities of the mass media and communication systems, or more succinctly put, the application of the communication systems to educational activities. As Schram notes, UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 40 Instructional television comes out of the same box that provides family enter- tainment and professional' football i instructional radio, from the same sound system that offers news bulletins; talk shows, from the same photographic process that makes and projects theatres and home movies. The computers used for computer-assisted instruction are the same kind that set our type, keep our bank statements and plot the paths of our ships. 1 Thus, when these communication systems change, either in terms of a wider scope of activities, a wider range or a greater thrust, education benefits from an entirely new culture of practice and a transformation of the educational system is observed. The transformation process in education takes into consideration a lot of elements. Considering the human element, learners and teachers in educational systems tend to be transformed in time and in place. In time, teachers and learners may, after a period of time, be no longer satisfied with the practices of old, based on the new demands which the dynamics of society place on them. Their new ideals and characteristics, their pree ~ft9 desires and want do call for change over a period of time. 1. WilburSchramm, Big Media Little Media. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications. 1977,p.13. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 4 1 While it may have been appropriate to be taught using the eye-ball_to-eye-ball Plato practices of old, over time, new dimensions of curriculum orientation, of available time for instructional purposes; and of the greater number of clientele to attend to, may thus lead to the transformation of the educational activities. In terms of space, the numan element does not operate in a vacuum. The geographical, political or social setting in which change is taking place also affects the pattern of transformation. For example, the building of roads, the rail system or the air transportation system normally affects the balance of relationships between men, including such relationships as may be operational in educational settings. Any detailed study of institutions that run conventional and evening programmes shows an entirely different set of attitudes operating between learners and tutors in such a school, in its evening and morning programmes. The degree of transformation of a particular phenomenon may be desGribed as being low or partial, average, high or extremely high based on the extent to UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 42 which specific ideal expectations are matched. In the field of correspondence education, the theme of transformation has been identified by various writers along different dimensions of thought. Two of these dimensions address the issues of terminology and technology. The third relates to a general appraisal of the reactions to the development of the genre. Weddemeyer's exploration of the changing nature of the nomenc lature shows "correspondence study" giving way to the adoption of "independen t study" in the U.S.A. by the mid 1960's. While "independent study" represents a more generic term, both terms have their roots in the British tutorial and extension movements of the 19th and early 20th centuries.1 In Europe, distance education later became adopted as an omnibus term, which according to Weddemeyer, "represents essentially a difference in terminology, not in method.2 This reservation is debatable. However, when the .International Council for Correspondence Education later changed its name to the International Council for Distance 1. CharlesW2ddemeyer, "IndependentStudy" op. cit. p. 2115 2. ibid.,p.2121. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 43 Education, it became clear to all th~t the climax of the need for a change in name, representative of a transformation of the genre, had .been reached. Through the titles of books, the trend in the change in nomenclature became apparent .. Thus, Borje HolmbArg's correspondence Education published in 1967, was revised and re-issued under a new title, Distance Education in 1975. Mackenzie and Christen~en's edited book, The Changing World of Correspondence Study, also reflected a pattern of changes in the field.1 Soren Nipper's classification of the three generations of distance education also reveals the trends in the transformation process. The generations he identified are: 2 1st Correspondenc~ teaching/single media 2nd Multi-media distance education 3rd Tele-education and "third genera tion" distance educa tion. Of the first generation, he observes that this was characterised by little or no production of materials 1. O. Mackenzie and E.L. Christensen, The Changing World of Correspondence Study, University Park: The Pennsylvania State Univ. Press. 1971. 2 . Cited in A. W . Bates, "Third Generation Distance Education: The Challenge of New Technology" Research in Distance Education. pp. 10-11 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 44 or the students' attention being called to a reading list, but based on a set of simple questions and a two-way communication system. The second generation saw the coming of the British 'Open University where the media range became expanded with emphasis on print but the use of other media, including sometimes, face-to-face sessions. Of the third generation, he identifies the use of what he calls third gene- ration technologies, such as telecommunications and computers, computer conferencing or networking, audio and video-conferencing. The issues raised by Nipper borde-r extensively on the transformation of the Correspondence System of education, to distance ,education. Apart from presupposing a change in name of the system, it also specifically shows the change in technologies of the system and the possibility of the provision of more and faster access to cornmuni.ca tion by the students. There is also expected to be a greater facility for two-way communication. From Nipper's views, the extent to which communication becomes faster between the teacher and the learner is reflective of the slight change in method which UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 45 albeit is based on medium change. To say then that the method has not been affected, as 'Weddemeyer is wont to add, is to treat as an oversight the capabilities of the third generation phenomenon. Two other views, differently treated but related to the concept of transformation are also noted here. Levinson perceives the corning of the new media into distance. education, especially the integration of such, as a call for the transformation of the system. He notes: The moral for the introduction of new media into educational settings is that the new medium will almost al~ays transform the educational setting. The second point raised by Pelton in his "Technology , 2 and Education: Friend or Foe" also has implications for the transforma tion process in correspondence education" which bO rlerson globa 1 homogeneity, the global mudball , view of society and the search for humanity's survival. 1. Paul Levinson, "Media Relations: Integrating Computer Telecommunicatirlgwith Educational Media" in R. Mason and A. Kaye (ed.) Mindweave. Oxford: Pergamon Press. 1989, p. 42. 2. Joseph N. Pelton, "Technology and Education: Friend or Foe" in Research in DistanceEdtncationApril 1991, Vol.3 Number 2, pp. 2-3. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 46 While the issue of global homogeneity brings man close to a oneness of purpose, that of mudball is a rehash of McLuhan's view of the possibility of the spontaneity of our interactivity at any given moment because of the tremendous potential of the new media. The so called divisionof the world into mesh blocks, via satellite is itself a transformation which Pelton's Vl.e.w lS repea t'lng. 1 The caveat about humanity's survival is representative of the view that with human beings brought close and distance diminished through new technologies, there may be a loss of jobs and positions by individuals, as machines take over people's jobs. The relevance of this is that there maY,be the other side to the transformation process, btit the point is maintained that correspondence education has witnessed some transformation. Finally, the view expressed by Mavis E. Kelly in a review of Harris' 2~nness and Closure in Distance Education, and Hodgson, et al's Beyond Distance Teaching: Towards Open Learning further raises the existence of the trend in transformation. As he notes: 1. See for example, J.N. Pelton, oPe cit. p.2 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 47 within the past few years, our attention has been drawn to distance education in a new and interesting way that could foresh~dow a transformation, not only of distance education, but of education in general. 1 From these discussions, it therefore becomes normal that when there is transformation in correspondence education, more clientele are served; information travels faster while the distance between the learner and the teacher is reduced. CORRESPONDENCE EDUCATION: 'I'h e concept of corre spondence educa tion is a composite one in which the term "correspondence" describes the type of education which the composite concept represents or signifies. In.a sense, Correspondence presupposes the exchange of information and ideas, which mayor may not have the didactic element attached to it. Since the education here automatically implies the process or product of the activities of a teacher and learner in a dynamic relationship 1 . Mavis E. Kelly, "Book Review" in Peter Jarvis & J. E. Thomas (ed) International Journal of Lifelong Education, Vol. 7 No. 3. July-September, 1988. p. 228. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 48 with the teaching content to be learnt, the nature of correspondence here should presuppose a sort of didactic two-way communication taking place. Thus in correspondence education, knowledge, skills and other didactic information are expected to change hands between learner and tutor with possibly an organisation directing the process of such exchange and following the activities progressivelY until the objectives or goals of learning are eventually achieved. Making a recourse to historical links, the concept of "correspondence education" has been in existence for more than two hundred and sixty years, at least in theory. The activities of Caleb Phillipps, so conspicuousLy advertise~ in the Boston Gazette of 1728 did not specifically mention the concept but did hint at it. 1 In the same vein, Pitman's 1840 efforts in Britain, though then described as "postal tuition" perhaps only found some conv~n~ence in nomenclature by emphasizing the "postal" aspect of the correspondence education business while de-emphasizing the actual 1. Cited in Leonard Valore and G.E. Diehl, The Effective- ness and Acceptance of Home Study. A monograPh of the National Home Study Council. April, 1987, p.1 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 49 method of promoting the learner-tutor interaction which the term correspondence appears best suited for, and eventually did. Based on this initial foray, many writers have attempted to define the concept of correspondence education along three dimensions of theory and practice. These are: i. definitions or explanations that emphasize the image of the actual process and innovative method and are thus descriptive; ii. descriptions that include terminologies which portray other pictures of the system and are thus normative; iii. definitions that attach other conditions, ,especially of a new experience in the field, and thus make the concept incapable of carrying the full weight of the new experience attached to it; 'or ~ sr , <, definitions that pretend the concept is all in all and can describe all situations in the field. We shall briefly examine all these as they occur in the literature and make spec ific commen ts on them. On the first category of definitions, the following are identified: a. correspondence study can be described as organised provision of inst1ruction andeducation through the post. 1. W.J.A. Harris, "Education by Post" Adult Education \)01. 39, No.5. 1967, p.269. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY so b. correspondence teaching is a method of teaching in which the teacher bears the responsi- bility of imparting knowledge and skill to a student who does not receive instruction orally, but who studies in a place and at a time determined by his individual c t rcurnst.ance sv l c. correspondence study is a systematic method of training in which an exchange of materials and examinations, usually by mail is the main means of interaction between the student and the source of instruction.2 The thrust of the three definitions above, by Harris, Erdos, and Salinger respectively satisfy the first dimension already identified which is one that explains the actual process. Terminologies which portray other pictures of the correspondence system are .home study, independent study, postal tuition, correspondence instruction, correspondence study, correspondence teaching, or correspondence learning. While "postal tuition" emphasizes the delivery aspect of the correspondence education process, correspondence instruction or 1 . R. F. Erdos, Teaching by Correspond§nce. Paris: Unesco. 1967, p.10. 2. Ruth D. Salinger, "Correspondence Study" in R.L. Craig (ed.) Training and Development Handbook. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1976, p. 38-1. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 51 correspondence teaching emphasizes the aspect of the teacher's activity in the process,in the same way that correspondence study or correspondence learning errphais.zes the learner's aspect of the process. The term" independent study" however goes beyond emphasizing the learner's autonomy or possible freedom to include the possibility of the absence of even a tutorial organisation or teacher on the one hand, or the possibility of having other means of bringing about mediated communication apart from the use of a correspondence text or material. In the same manner, "home study" a lso a llows for these Lnt erpret.ation s although a greater percentage of the activities of the National Home Study Council (NHSC) in the U.S.A. established in 1926,1 or Eliot Ticknor's Society to Encourage Stu{tlieast Home 2 estab lished in 1873 (though extince adopt the correspondence education mode in their programmes. 1 . 'I'ehNa_tional Home Study Council (NHSC) was started in 1926 by one John Noffsinger and many leaders of the more reputableproprietarycorrespondencecollegeswith a view to alteviating,with the supportof the Federal Trace Ccmnissicn,the abuses of the fraudulentschools. See D.C. M:3.thiesonC,orreSfODd- ence Study: A SumrraryReview of the Iesearchand Develop:11Ent Literature. W3.shingtonN,HSC. 1971, p.13 2. ElizabethC. Agassiz, "Sccietyto EnccurageStudiesat Hare" in O. M:l.ckenziaend E.L. Christensen,op. cit. p.27. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 52 Weddemeyer's explana tion in this regard is appropriate. He observes, The term correspondence study still clings to certain processes employed in nearly all forms of independent study, in part because it was the name given to the first alternative to conventional schooling for external learners, but a variety of names has been adopted ... horne study, tele-tuition, postal tuition, correspondence instruction, and correspond- ence educa tion. 1 The second categorisation seen above has helped to broaden the scope of terminologies while the first categorisation concentrates on correspondence study. A list of definitions that gives correspondence study the extra burden will now be given. They are: a. The teacher in Correspondence study provides instruction on the basis of materials (usually written, but sometimes dispatched by other methods) submitted by the students. This is the heart of the correspondence study process.2 b. The correspondence process is essentially personal tutoring carried on by mail (or other forms of communication) with the teacher aiding the learner in the three basic learning processes: acquiring information, transmitting information into ideas an~ applications, and evaluating progress. 1- c. Weddemeyer, "Independent Study" op , cit. p.2116. 2. ibid, p.2117 3. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 53 c. (A review of Skinner's behaviour control model, Rothkopf's model of written instruction, Ausubel's advance organizer model, Egan's Structural Communication Model, Bruner's discovery learning and Gagne's general teaching model as applied to correspondence education by Baath,1 go beyond the written text in identifying the medium of correspondence education One major feature of the last set of explanations is that in addition to the written word or text used as a form of communication between the learner and the tutor, the use of electronic and other means of communication have crept into the process of corres- pondence education. I~ is significant to note that one major reason for the change in terminology from "correspondence education" to "distance education' has been the need to acknowledge the coming of these other media into the activities of correspondence education.2 In therefore defining the concept of correspondence education, we shall use the following criteria: 1. J.A. Baath, Correspondence Education in the Light of a Number of Contemporary Teaching Models. Malmo: Liber Hermods. 1979 , 2. The International Council for Distance Education (ICDE) indeed pre-empted its change in name from the Inter- national Council for Correspondence Education (ICCE) when it titled its ninth proceedings; that of 1972. Current Issues and Approaches in Distance Education See C. Weddemeyer, Independent Study", op. cit, p.2121. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 54 1. • that it must be an edu ca t.Loria I pro qrairrne in whic~ t~e tea~her and the learner exchange instructional materials and· assignmp.nts purposely for the aim of satisfying some identifiable educational goals ii. there must be an organisation coordinating such an exchange iii. the medium of communication is print; iv. the use of additional face-to-face inter- actions to supplement the teaching and learning carr ied ou t, as an exception,not the rule v. a process of evaluation must be built in to assess progress vi. the method must be sound as to ensure effective teaching and learning and this includes the presence of two-way communication vii. there must be a system of accreditation to ensure that quality is maintained. DISTANCE EDUCATION: An explanation of the concept of distance education may have to take an initial historical dimension to the picture of the promotion of educational programmes at a distance in spite of its seemingly obvious explication of itself. As Weddemeyer reports: Distance education as an aiternative to correspondence study first appeared in South Africa, where the term tele tuition (distance teaching) has been used by the University of South Africa for many UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 55 years. In the Federal Republic of Germany the term Fernunterricht (distance teachin~)has also been used for some time in place of correspondence instruction, and the new Open University at Hagen is called the FernUniversitat (distance University) . In France the term tele-enseignement (distance teaching) is used to describe instruction that is intended for learners at a distance from the regular schools. 1 It is significant to know that the International Council for Correspondence Education, established in 1938 had had two proposals for name change in its 1972 and 1975 Conferences, held in the U.S.A. and United Kingdom respectively. Finally in Canada in 1982, the name changed to the International Council for Distance Educa tion (ICDE). The main reason for this, as earlier stat.ed in this work, w.as the need to have a term tha t ha s some room for .the appropriation of the new technologies like radio, televisi0n, telephone ..and computers that ;i{(~.rebecoH:-'<'Li;njc rca si nq Ly used in the fieldy and thus de-emphasize the reference to the medium of print which the ter~ correspondence education tends to suggest. A few definitions will 1. Charles Weddemeyer, Ope cit. p. 2121 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 56 clearly show this trend. Distance education is seen as a. an omnibus term to include correspondence study, open learning, instruction by radio and television - in short, all learning~teaching arrange- ments that are not face-to-face. 1 b. a generic term that includes the range of teaching/learning strategies referred to as 'correspondence education/study' at higher education level in the United States, 'external studies' at all levels in Australia and 'distance teaching' or teaching at a distance 'by the Open University of the United Kingdom,.2 c. . covering +he various forms of study at all levels which are not under the continuous, immediate supervision of tutors present with their students in 1ecture rooms or on the same oremises but which, nevertheless, benefit from the planning, quidaric e and tuition of a tutorial organisation.3 1. C. Weddemeyer, Ope cit. p. 2115 2. Desmond Keegan, Foundations of Distance Education London: Routledge, 1990. p.29. 3. Borje Holmberg, "The feasibility of a Theory of Teaching for Distance Education and a Proposed Theory." ZIFF PAPIERE 60. Hagen: ZIFF, October 1985. p. 7 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 57 d. distance teaching .. the family of instructional methods in which the teaching behaviours are performed apart from the learning behaviours including those that in contiguous situation would be performed in the learners presence, so that learning must be facilitated by print, electronic, mechanical and other devices.1 The conclusions to be drawn from the definitions of distance education here show- the following: i. that it presupposes the existenceof some distancemostly geographical but possibIy also sociaL, which lies between the learner and the tutor or institutional provider of education; ii. that in bridging this distance, various media, like print, electronic, radio, ~elevision, computer, video discs, telephone, electronic mail are used with the sole aim of transmitting instructional information; iii. that there is room for two-way communi- cation in Buch'a way that both the learner and the tutor can initiate or respond to the information which the other has passed. iv. that an institutional provider of the education plans, guides and monitors the entire process of education; v. that face-to-face teaching and learning may feature in this educational process not necessarily as a rule~ but as convenient exceptions to methods used; 1 . Michael G. Moore, "On a theory of Independent study" Hagen: FernUniver;sitat (ZIIT) 1977. p.8. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 58 Having exanined the concepts of corres~onaence education and distance education, it is necessary to draw some lines of major differences wh i.choccur both as a result of need for 'conceptual clarification, and as a result of evolutionary development of the terms. These will be done in Table 1 using as major variables: i. Historical reference ii. !1eaning iii. Related tern iv. Method v. Medium of interaction vi. Clientele vii. Support Services UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY Table 1: 59 A Comparison of Correspondence Education and Distance Education Variables Correspondence Education Distance Education 1. Historical Has its origins in Caleb Phillipps First used as a term in Scuth Africa in the early reference 1728 activities in the US/\ and 60 's to describe education organised Pitman's in the 1840's in which at a distance. Mc>reFormal acceptance both sent instructions by mail to of the term recorded in the Interna tiona.l teach their srndent.s shorthand. Council for Correspondence Education's lIcx:E) change of sarre to the Io)E in . 198a".to reflect a najor change in norrenclature, me+bods and media used in Correspondence education. 2. Meaning A systematic method of inparting A systematic method of Impart.Lnq knowledge and skills, usually by kna,yleEqe and sk i.Ll.s, by a variety of nail, to a Learner , who is . available rredia, including print, ot separa ted fran the tu tor or electronic or others wi.th the possible -addition} _ orgmisation pronoting and planning' face-to-face contact, s UC[\ that the distance - the education, in v.,hich the medi.um between the Learner and the organisation of print is the rrea.ns of the t'M)- providing learning is bridged, and a way crnmunicatim. two-vay Ccrmunicat.icnSys'tern is emphasi.zed. 3. Related Correspondence Study: Corre spend- It is an umbrella term for all term ence teaching or learning; postal educational programmes organised at blitim, education by post. a distance including Correspondence Study , independent study , home study, external sbldies, open university etc. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 60 Variables Correspondence Educatia\ Distance Educatien 4. Method 'Iwo-vayCarrnunication between tutor Sameas in Correspondence deducation, and learner which includes the but with the two-wayCarmunicatien sending of ccurse naterials, faster and with greater accessibility assignments and other inforrration for interaction based en new technologies. to the learner while the Learner studies, dces the assignment and returns to the institutiona.l provider of education 5. M3diwnof Print-based such that the All forms of Camtunication, including Interaction inforrra.tion can be r'ead by both the print rredi.um, electrrnic media like the learner and the tutor. TIle radio, televisirn, video and video di scs , face-to-face sessions are an satelitte ysystems, Ccmp.rte.retc. Face- exception rather than the rule. to-face sessirns nay fea~ure here. 6. Clientele r-bstly adults fran all vaIks of Sameas in Correspcndence education, but life who require vocational, with the t.rerrendo.is growth in tertiary liberal, professional, or school. level involvement, and a general increase or College based educational in the variety and volurre of clientele programmeseither as an addition being served, to other educationa 1 progranmes they currently receive, or as the rrain educational programre tht~y are uundertaking, whether as workers or not. Children form a censiderable part of the clientele. 7. 8.Jpport These .incIude little or no provisien This includes extensive provisms of Services of guidance and counse.lI iriq services glidance counselling services; tutorials, tutorials, administrative suppor+, administrative suppor-t.link with libraries link with libraries or study grcups or study grcups. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 61 2.3 Models of Correspondence Education According to Lippitt, a model is a symbolic r~presentation of the various aspects of a complex event or situation, and their inter-relationships it is an ab~traction of reality that can be used for analytical purposes. 1 As the author further notes, it is a representation of a phenomenon which d~splays the identifiable structural elments of that phenomenon, the relation- ships amon3g those elements, and the processesinvolved. When applied to correspondence education, a model must identify the basic issues in the correspondence education process as to fully show the elements involved such that this can be used for analytical purposes. In this research, a model of correspondence education must not only show the processes of teaching and learning includlng the methods, media, evaluation procedures as they inter- relate, it must also show the possibilities of rooms for change and development of the system, and possibly 1 . G.L . Lipp itt , op. c it., p. 2 2. ibid, p.73 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 62 its transformation. In doing this we shall examine a number of submis sion s. The first is by William Rainey Harper, the "father" of Correspondence instruct- ion in the United States of America. Harper's explanation of 'the process of correspondence education is thus presented: 1 1. An instruction sheet is mailed to the student each week. The sheet - (a) assigns the tasks to be performed; (b) indicates the order of work to be followed; (c) offers suggestions on points in the lesson which are liable to be misunderstood; (d) furnishes special assistance where necessary; (e) marks out a specified amount of review work; (f) includes an examination paper which the student later wrote out. 2. The examination paper is constructed on the basis of the hitherto well prepared lesson. 3. A recitation paper is submitted to the instructor which includes the students'response to the examination paper and additional questions which the students may wish to ask. The recitatiOn paper is then returned quickly to the student, with all the errors corrected and the questions answered. Special suggestions for each learner may be added by the tutor. Each lesson of the course is thus given and studied in this manner until the end of the course is reached. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 63 To achieve quality performance, Harper suggests that the correspondence teacher must be painstaking, patient, sympathetic and alive, while the learner must be "earnest, ambitious, appreciative and like- wise alive". Valore and Diehl's explanation of the "Home Study .Process "2 which appears to represent the method in most programmes of the NHSC follows this pattern: 1. Enrolment application completed at home, then submitted by mail. 2. Acceptance of enrolment at school. 3. Lesson materials sent to enrolees. 4 . Studen t comp Le t.e.s lessons at own pace, according to directions provided. 5. Student receives individual assistance whenever necessary via contact with school, and additional instructional materials are sent to student as required. 1. Willoi.am Rainey Harper, "The System of Correspondence"in Mackenzie and E.L. Christensen, op. cit. pp. 8-9 2. Leonard Valore and Grover E. Diehl, op. cit. p.9 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 64 6. Examinations or projects are completed at home and mailed to school. 7. Exams graded and recorded at school. 8. Grades and examinations returned to student. 9. Student receives credit for work completed; progress reports are given. 10. Upon completion, student receives a diploma or certificate of completion under authority of state department of education, or qualifying credit to enter resident, "hands on" training sessions. A third model is Keegan's correspondence school model which is diagrammatically shown below: 1 Figure 1: The CorresoondenceSchool Mcx:el r-t- INSTITUTION STUDEnJT develops: LEARNING MATERIALS purchases: LEARNING ASSIGNMENTS LEARNING MATERIALS CORRECTED ASSIGNMENTS 1. Desmond Keegan, "On the Nature of Distance Education", ZIFF PAPIERE 33, Hagen: ZIFF Nov. 1980. p.3 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 65 Here the correspondence school sends learning materials to the student by post. The student in t~rn studies the materials and posts them back. Comments are given on the assignments and posted back to the student. The student reads the comments and writes out the next assignment until the course is completed. An Analysis We shall briefly examine the three submissions just given. Harper's explications specifically identify the following features: i. the instruction that is sent to the learner ii. an order of work iii. clarifications by the tutor iv. examination' v. recitation paper which is the student's response to the institution's assignments or examination vi. further clarification by the institutional provider of education While the above gives a picture'of the teaching learning process in which the use of the print-medium is emphasized, it fails to suggest other ways by which support could be given to the learner in reducing UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 66 isolation, apart from the clarifications offered by the teacher in the course of exchanges with the learner. Valore and Diehl's account go a bit further by adding to Harper's views: i. the administrative procedure followed at the initial level of contact; ii. the air of relative independence and autonomy enjoyed by the learner who studies at his own pace; iii. the possibility of a student receiving a diploma or certificate at the end of the programme. Ho~ver, _Yiillgre and Diehl's position tends to suggest that there is absolute trust, and that all the examinations done by the learner can be sent in my mail with awards of diploma· f oLl.ow i nq . There appears to be no room for sit-in examinations or specially arranged ways to ensure that others do not write the examinations for them. Also, the area of higher education, or the possible award of degrees .", :' not mentioned at all. This seern s to have limited correspondence education to the provision of education below the tertiary level wh i.ch is not true. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 67 The third submission by Keegan brings in two added elements: i. institutional providers of correspondence education may indeed develop their own materials, referred to by Baath as self-contained materials, or purchase same in the open market. ii. while two-way communication is basic to the interaction between the learner and the institution, the institution's position rather than the tutor's is empha- sized. In properly harnessing the points raised above, and in proposing a model of correspondence education here, it may be necessary to examine Baath's short description of correspondence education. 1 Quoting Nilsen, he sees it as a variety of distance educa tion which, is distinguished by "two- way distant communication between teacher and learner by means of stored information".2 A special teaching material which is intended for self studies is used. This may consist of a textbook with a study-guide containing directions, encouraging comments, explanation, exercises, problems and solutions.'11 On the other hand, 1 • J. A. Baa th , op. cit. , 2. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 68 a self-contained material could be developed which is also called the course text which thus contains the needed detailed knowledge to be imparted. 1 While the teaching material is thus divided into study Units, with summaries and assignments added at the end of each study unit, solutions to such assignments are sent in to a corresponde~ce tutor who gives his comments and a grade. This is an opport- unity for the student to pass his own comments and this ensures what Baath calls a "postal two-way communication". Thus the student can really be said to have two teachers - one the course writer (supported by the editor) and the other the tutor. Where there are face-to-face sessions, the tutor or oral teacher may come in. Counselling may be carried out through the handbooks provided by the Institutional provider, or through the activities of designated counsellors. Baath's findings from a ,detailed study of some Correspondence education models finally led him to 1. The University of Ibadan External Studies Programme has perfected this art of developing self- contained course texts. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 69 identify two major lines of discourse here.1 These are: 1. the design of teaching material 2. the two-way communication Noticeably, the design of the teaching material takes into consideration the method of teaching, while the two-way communication takes into consideration the medium used. It must be noted however that these two issues lie at the core of the major expositions that can be made on either correspondence education or distance education. 2.4 Summary In summary, the major issues that should be considered in any correspondence education model or approach are those related to the clientele, course material, the two-way communication process between learner and tutor and the permissiveness of such a system to possible growth and transformation. While the clientele may be reLa t i ve Iy homogenous or heterogenous both in terms of theirgeneral professional 1. See J.A. Baath, Correspondence Education in the Light of a Number of Contemporary Teaching Models. Malmo: LiberHermods, 1979. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 70 background and other features that may distinguish them, there is a sense in which their overall goals determine the nature of a correspondence text, or the choice of an approproate set of courses for them. Their past experience may also inform the structure and content of the course to be written. Sometimes, they have preferred learning styles which may also, especially in a state of openness or demand for freedomy determine whether the content or the method of learning should be controlled. This also has implications for additional media input into the correspondence education process, which thus makes its transformation possible. The design of course'materials may be based on some of the issues already raised. However, this is usually a self-contained course, or one that com- orises a set of identified reference materials plus an accompanying guide to study, which contains a lot of information for the learner, including assignments to be submitted or self-test ones. The combined text plus the guide may be more applicable, either to some subject areas like Literature and English, or to higher cognitive levels of education where self-contained UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 71 materials may not be able to 'supply all the needed information, or allowed for higher levels of cognitive content and demands upon the learner. At some other level, the choice of the alternative may be based on the premise of having a more "open" correspondence education system that allows for a lot of learner initiative. The levels of complexity of the course text either in terms of choice of diction or the gramatical structures are also important. The basis for any approach here should be the reduction of learner isolation and the facilitation and transfer of learning. Texts are also expected to reach a high level of comprehensiveness. Two-way communication is central to the corres- pondence education process. To a great extent, both the learner and the tutor must be able to initiate this through the medium of print available in correspondence education. While assignments for suh mission should be an integral part of the communication, self-test exercises with model answers should help, especially where correspondence education programmes UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 72 appear handicapped, although a removal of this handicap within the organisation should be a major goal. Noticeably, the medium of communication is print while the postal system promotes the communication process. However, rooms are made for the transformation of the correspondence education in such a way that face-toface contacts, telephone tutoring and computer assisted instruction may find various levels of supplemental usage. with additional media, the road to d{stance education thus appears to have being begun. 2.5 Models of Distance Education A number of models of distance education have been identified by various scholars and theorists in the field. These are: 1 1. the Correspondence school model 2. the consultation model 3. the integrated model 4. the distance teaching or open University model. 1. Desmond Keegan, Foundations of Distance Education. London: Routledge. 1990, pp. 124-133. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 73 The aim in this unit is to examine these models and show their implications for the use of methods arid media in distance education. A detailed examination of the design of the teaching process here and the possible two-way communication process which ;)1::-'0 covers a wider areaI :i..,,"'ctlhuedexsami.nat.Loefn the use of electronic means to facilitate two-way communication, as well as possible face-to-face sessions to reduce learning isola tion. The second point re Lates to the emphasis, perhaps as a result of historical factors, of the theorists on tt~ ~dministrative structures of the models, more than is the case with the correspondence education models earlier examined. Finally, the recently mentioned issue of reducing learners' isola tion, through possible face -to-face contacts appears antithetical to the issue of learner autonomy, and attempts to destroy one of the laudable objectives of independent study which distance education also promotes. This may however be an issue of the end justifying the means, but this will be discussed more later. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 74 The Correspondence School Model This model is similar to ·the one, by the same name already examined under correspondence education (Fig. ) . The major difference is that in distance education, the model does not rely only on the medium of print. Other media like the telephone, audio and video tapes are used either solely, or supplementarily to facilitate pedagogical or social interaction. Another major feature here is the clientele. As most of the schools that use the model are usually proprietary, the clientele are mostly those who strive to pass either the secondary school eX<1.minat:i.ens or some other professional examinations. It is uncommon to have university based programmes here although in more developed settings, proprietary schools take on th e tertl.ary f unctl.o1n. The process of sending instruction to learners here is similar to those indentified by Harper, Valore and Diehl, as earlier seen in Section 2.3. The maintenance of a two-way communication channel 1. The Exam Success Correspondence College in Nigeria is an example of a proprietary college here. In the U.S.A. some schools operating under the aegis of the NHSC offer tertiary level academic programme s. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 75 may however follow the pattern suggested by Rothkopf. This is that the aspect of submitting assignments for correction constitutes a major part of the two-way communication process. Also, there wmay be the need for face-to-face contacts, especially at the beginning of the programme to serve orientation purposes, as well as during the programme to reduce isolation and allow for evaluation. In the early days of correspondence education in Nigeria, two-way communication between the institu- tional provider of correspondence education and the learner was limited to the use of print through the submission of assignments and the collection of materials by post. While· there was no room for immediacy of feedback thro~gh electronic systems, learner isolation was further hampered by the absence of face-to-face sessions. This was one of the reasons why in March 1, 1919, the following petition was sent by some workers in Lagos to the Director of. Education , asking that he "may be pleased to arrange for the inauguration of a continuation class at the King's UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 76 College"· The petition further reads: Our several vocations in life do not permit us to join the regular courses of the College and we hope as external students to be able to if the concession is made to us, to compensate a long felt want and the institution of such a class will, we feel convinced, meet the appro- bation of the community. 1 The Consultation Model In the consultation model, Keegan, adapting Schwarz and Mohle's models, notes that the model has the element of correspondence education reduced while emphasis is placed on compulsory fortnightly attendance and seminars. These are called consultations. After the study materials have been sent to the students, the system relies on the private study which the students undertake. A further clarification on this is then made at the seminars. A major point in this model is that distance education need not be totally removed from conventional face-to-face teaching. A historical foray into the users of this model shows that the type of 1. Michael Omolewa, "Historical Antecedents of Distance Education in Nigeria, 1887-1960" in Adult Education in Nigeria Dec. 1982, Vol. 7, p. 11. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 77 population envisaged for the programme and the level of relatedness of the courses being run are quite high. Of a fact, this idea is commonly practised in the eastern bloc countries like the former German Democratic Republic, the i.lnl.:'.'::" S"V.L2t U1-; •• I, '_"(~ Poland. The history of these settings, the general national control of the educational processes, and the strong link distance education has with work and formal educcttional pro~rammes make the approach more suitable. A purely correspondence system of education would not have been able to take up the expected crowd and wide range of courses needed here. The diagramatic reoresent at Lon on pac:re78 (Fig. 2) further shows the nature of the activities 'involved here. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 78 Figure 2: The Consultation Model A IW\ vi. eoll.{C~11'()v\' r----t..-C\--;-'~I, tm1,,\j"'5 Te~chi",ql"lotr' ~s 1-U",diol'\o./ re.[crhoY\~ in t\1e. Pyocessi",sty•.c•.tlo ns Y of o{is.to.V\~ iYlstylA.c:KoV\. ::'Thcl y" Y\'j , Prom{yhoy\ I cf stuciie!!.lre,~------------------, ':'- \ t Self - checkJ" i" st\..\o(ie~ 'I' ,II Al\o.i'lS.l s, ofr- r-,----1 YeS-I-( Its C\ ",J, -V errOys '-----1[ Con su.\k-ho\,\ lr------II'--f---t-J 1(\ I' Source: Cesrrond Keegin, Foundat.Ions of Distance Education NewYork. Rrutledge. 1990. p. 136. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 79 The Integrated Model 1 In this model, there is th~ basic assumption that the distance teaching programme of a university or school is an extension of an already existing internal teaching programme. Thus here, the internal and external teaching activities are integra ted. In addition to the fact that the same staff teach and assess both sets of students in the conventional and distance teaching systems, the courses, examinations, awarded diplomas and degrees in the programme are the same. It is thus common to have an External Studies Department of a University or College taking care of the administrative acti- vities here. Usually, srich a Department carries out no teaching functions but undertakes the administrative work in the programme. The Qniversity of Ibadan has something very close to this.2 1- 'Thismodel has been regarded as Australia I s major contributic:n to distance educatic:nand takes care of the usual problem of accreditatic:n faced by autonorrousdistance teaching systems just starting out. See cesmond Keegan, op. cit. p. 137. 2. 'TheExternal Studies Prograrrrre(ESP) of the University of Ibadan is academically coordinated by the Depa.rtrnent.Aodfult Educatic:nwhile a lot of the administrative details is left with the ESP unit. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 80 Unlike the consultation model, the historical link with this system, traceable to Austratia at th~ beginning, is not based on the need to address large audiences. The audiences were generally small compared with what the open universities eventually handle, but they were geographically scattered. Thus, the system grew out of the need to ensure that existing formal institutions practised the integrated mode for the scattered clientele, thus finally achieving the goal of meeting larger audience's needs, and maximising the potential of the conventional universities, in the same way extra-mural programmes were carried out from their hey-days up till now. The Distance Teaching or Open University Model Another name for this model by which Keegan refers to it is the multi-media system model. As early as 1965, otto Peters had hinted that the only distance teaching universities existing were in South Africa and the U.S.S.R. 1 Keegan, 25 years later, observes this dramatic growth of the phenornerion , hinting at 1 . Cited in Desmond Keegan, op. c it. p. 116 and 127. UNIVERSITY F IBADAN LIBRARY 81 its "fairly-tale like transformation,,1. The characteristics of the distance teaching universities is that they do not have students in residence. In the same sense, there are no "full-time day time students, nor "part-time night-:t"imE:s't-lld('"i,""'. 1.':<<.1 mp l e s of this are the Open University of the United Kingdom, Everyman University of Israel, or the suspended National Open University at Abuja in Nigeria. The use of the multi-media system to describe the activities here is based on the nature of, or indeed, lack of provisions of the usual resident university facilities, which gap now has to be filled by the media. Of this phenomenon, Keegan notes of the British Open University: One looks in vain for students as one walks around the campus at Milton Keynes. Many of the other universities are off-pu~ting, factory-like buildings and there is little or nothing for students to do at them. Gone too is the concept of the university library with places for undergraduate and post-graduate research, gone are the lecture rooms, tutorial rooms, seminars rooms, laboratories for student research, and facilities for the 1 . ibid, p. 1 28 • UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 82 student communl. ty. 1 The distance-teaching university is an innov- ation in terms of its exclusiveness and autonomy and in terms of media layout which the correspondence schools cannot match in scacure -and clientele volume. It is indeed the climax of the transformation process in distance education, of which Nigeria had only a stint in 1984 before t~e suspension of the National Open University. A look at the diagrammatic representation of the model (Fiq. 3) shows the e~tent of media input: 1 • Desmond Keegan, op. cit. p. 129 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 83 Figure 3: A Distance Teaching University Model I I I I I \ I \ I \ I ~ {- INSTITUTION ••<•<-C.=-M_A...:..S~ --"T.:.;.M~sA ST U DEN T leo.n'li"'~ mo:le.r;cds Leal" 1'\\)\5 \ \ \ 06li3o.-L-cyy Source: DesEmdouncdatKieoeng.an, LFoonudnodnaiioRnosutloefdgeD.istan1c9e90, p. 129. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 84 The examination of the models so far reveals a number of features, which have implications for classifying the distance education programmes along the lines of a typology. While the correspondence school model and the distance teaching models show the autonomous nature of the institutions operating here, the consultation and the integration models are examples of mixed institutions. The autonomy referred to above according to Nei11 relates to issues of finance, examination and accreditation, curriculum and materials, delivery and student support systems. Thus the mixed institutions share the control and authority over the four areas already listed above. In view of the riat.ure of this research, there is the need to fully examine the implications of the models shown for teaching and learning, and the mode of the two-way communication system central to them. These issues border on the methods and the media profferred by the models and the nature of the support system in distance education. 1 • D. Keegan, op. cit. p. 119. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 8S In discussing the teaching material in models of distance education, the term didactic structure will be used occasionally. This is because the teaching material, or the process of preparing it in distance education is more elaborate than what operates in just pure correspondence teaching. This is based on the addition of such elements like occasional face to face tutoring, the use of other media apart from print, and the involvement of other personalities in the course writing process, apart from the original single-course writ~r; a situation common in the correspondence school model. The options thus open in the preparation of course materials in distance education are: i. the contracting of course materials out to writers (common -in both the correspond- ence school models and other autonomous distance teaching institutions) ; ii. the identification of tutors to conduct face-to-face components of teaching: iii. the identification of editors and other members of the cour~e production team e.g. I layout artists, etc~I; UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 86 iv. the merging of the content of instruction with the medium. The nature of the content and the general goals which an institutional provider of distance education pursues in a course of study, may determine the nature of the medium to be used. Where the content is print- oriented, the activities of the course writer, the editor and the layout artists are of paramount importance. When the materials are audio-based or video-based, the issue of production techniques take the scope of activities away from the course writer to, in addition to the writer's early activities, the instructional designers or technologists and programme producers. The production techniques to adopt then become as crucial as the writing style to emphasize. The distance teaching universities such as the Open University appear best suited to undertake this style of using the course team approach in the preparation of their instructional" materials. Usually, the content of the course material prepared may never be the same as originally written by the course writer. A way of reducing the possible differences UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 87 created in content here is for the academics themselves to undergo training in instructi?nal technology. T0ey are then adequately equipped to co-ordinate their thoughts in a manner that considers the use of additional technology. At the level of distance education systems which are of an integrated mode, a course material benefits extensively from the experience of the course writer who already teaches the internal students. The structure of the course content is thus a replica of what the internal students have, including the assessment practices. Course teams are also used here and they somehow show a marked difference between the original course writer's teaching and his new distance education course text or course content. In addit~on i. the distance teaching universities have as clientele adults whose goals is further education at the university level; ii. there is a move towards i more extensive use of non-print educational media; iii. a more didactic link is made between the learning materials and learning. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 88 In the consultation model, the use of face-to- face sessions is a major component of the system. The ratio of the face-to-face consultations to indi- vidual study is usually shown in the structure of the programme. There are also elements of the interaction between work and study as students who are sponsored by firms have the chance of being promoted after graduation. This practice is common in the former U.S.S.R. and other eastern countries. The student in this approach usually starts with a seminar (residential) that is held on campus, followed by home study, which is itself broken by regular consultations. Correspondence is seen to play very little role in the whole process. There are cases where students are allocated to a consultation centre at an institution close to their home and work. Other systems have the enrolment and the consultation centre within the same university. This practice is not yet operating in Nigeria. The closest to it is an example of the special arrangements the National Teachers Institute, the University of Ibadan External Studies Programme or the Correspondence UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 89 and Open Studies Institute of the University of Lagos make with higher institutions in locations away from them where their clientele reside. With such arrangements, tutors are found for the face-to-face components of their distance teaching programmes, while teaching practice activities are arranged. The .~,~esl to this in the colonial days was the University of London examinations and other foreign examinations which Nigerians sat for here with the administrative support of the Colonial Education Department. Two-way Communication The promotion of twq-way communication in distance education is done through a variety of media. Some of these had earlier been identified. Additional media that may be added here are the computer mediated communication and the element of face-to-face teaching which is sometimes brought in to reduce student isolation and increase learner effectiveness. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 90 The nature of two-way communication in the correspondence school model is such that developed or purchased learning materials are sent to the students by post or any other means of communication. The student then studies the materials and sends his assignments back to the tutor. The assignment is commented upon and returned to him. Sometimes, these assignments can be in form of the prepared audio tapes or even video cassette~ depending on the nature of the course being taught and the amount of money the learner is investing. Usually, most proprietary schools that fall within this category emphasize the medium of print. In developing nations, print is overtly emphasized. Face to face sessions are very rare here but the telephone is also used to facilitate the social or ~ven pedagogical aspects of the learning process. In the distance teaching university model, a look at the diagram origina lly shown (see Fig. 3) shows that a number of differences are seen especially in the use of media, the level of provision and the link between learning materials and potential learning. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 91 The nature of interaction and two-way communication iB the integrated model is such that the printed course or oth~r course materials are prepared by the course writers who are full-time lecturers in the Conventional University. This is done through a combination of face-to-face teachings and the supply of inuependent study materials. 1 Assessment of students is then done through the assignments given and formal examinations. The learning materials thus developed are upgraded and reviewed from time to time, based on different needs and growth in knowledge. While the process of two-way interaction identified above exists in the various models, an extra attempt is made to reduce learner isolation which the physical separatedness of the learners and the writers cause. Some of these troubles expressed by distance education students, as identified by Ana Krari jo includethe fact that:2 1. D. Keegan, op. cit.p. 138. 2. Ana Kranjc, Social Isolation and Learning Effectiveness in Distance education. ZIFF PAPIERE 71, Hagen: ZIFF. June, 1988. p , 14. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 92 1. they do not understand certain parts of the subject matter. 2. the explanations are missing in course texts. 3. the rhythm set by the educational model is too fast. 4. time for preparatlon for examinations is not enough; 5. the written material is not sufficient; 6. opportunities for attending short face-to-face seminars are not available; 7. there are difficulties in adjusting to the general organisational structure (examination terms, frequency of units, days for consultations); 8. loneliness and social isolation (nobody to talk to, very few of their acquaintances study) exists. In view of the troubles listed, distance education thus requires additional face·-to-face elements in the following manner: 1 contacts wi.th other students contacts with individual tutors group consultations attendance at short seminars Possibility to discuss personal learning problems with others 1. Kranjc had in fact measured the frequency of student isolation by the absence of hese same suggestions. See Ana Kranj~, Ope cit. p.S. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 93 The various issues already raised by Baath especially concerning the need to stimulate the interest of the students at the beginning of the course; help them to understand freely the basis of the structure of their programme;and,make room for tutorial aspects of the programme are issues the face-to-face com- ponents of a distance education programme can con- veniently take up. While Baath had observed the possible use of the telephone, the computer mediated communication system and audio or video cassettes to stioolate and promote needed contacts here, the problems faced in developing nations stemming from the lack of appropriate financial ability of both the institutional provider and the distant learner, make such technological input problematic. Thus, in reducing isolation and promoting other counselling and motivational services, the element of face-to-face contact hours, which the consultation model supports, and which many distance education systems use, becomes a necessary addition to the system. While this appears to run contradictory to the meaning of correspondence education as a method in distance education, or to UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 94 distance education itself, as a wider area in this unique arrangement, the emphasis on distance bridging can not but benefit from this exception. In summary, the models of distance education subscribe significantly to most-of the issues raised in the models of correspondence education. Indeed, the earlier examined correspondence education models had pre-empted the emergence of distance education by the various suggestions of media use that tend to address the motivating effects telephones and the new technologies generally could have when applied in a distance education si t.u.a t.Lon . Distance education only goes a step further by fully maximising the use of these technologies, in addition to print, and allowing for the added face-to-face elements. This inclusion of the exception appears to be based on the need to appropriately react to the complexities of the field both in terms of additional variety of clientele, the increasing level of operations in the field, and the nature of the subject matter which has become increased over the.years. Yet one other dimension of the allowance for the face-to-face com- ponent is the humanistic expectations of a distance UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 95 learning philosophy, that while asking for indivi- dualised learning, still attempts to remove isolation; w~ile promoting the growth of idependent and home study, still strives for group and teacher/learner interaction; while promoting the extensive use of print to bridge the distance in learning, still has to react to new technological developments and thus apply faster means of communicating with the learner; and, which while appearing to create an innovation in a non-conventional educational system, appears to be bridging the distance between the conventional education and the mainstream. With developments like these, the transformation from correspondence education to distance education thus appears in the main, to be: i. the development of new methods in the correspondence education system which; in addition to its reliance on print allows for other media to appeal to learners' various stimuli and promote better learning; ii. the promotion of better interaction between the learner and the correspondence education course writer through the addition of either face-toface components or/and mediated UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 96 interactions that speed up the feedback process; iii. the reduction of social isolation through print, electronic or other media; iv. the introduction of support services that take additional care of learner needs through all of the media available in the system; v. the maximisation of existing media components in the environment to get all these done; vi. the possible move towards the bridging of distance education and the mainstream in all ramifications, such that distande education becomes a positive factor in the growth of teaching and learning in the conventional system of education. vii. the capacity to cater for larger auJiences in remote areas. 2.6 A Model of Transformation of Correspondence Education to Distance Education I There is the need to evolve and describe a model of transformation of correspondence education to distance education. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 97 This will among others: i. help to summarise the various views expressed so far and thus allow for easy understand- ing of the nature of the research itself. ii. create a frame of reference for the'later discussions to follow and the method to be adopted in this research. I iii. allow for the ideal transformation ~f correspondence education to distance education in Nigeria, in spite of an obvious low technological environment and t~us promote a maximal use of existing structures. The model will be described in two parts; the graphical illustration and the follow- up dis~iussion. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 98 Fig. 4: A Model of Transformation of Correspondence Education to Distance Education. -F'oIiOLD ---7 +0 h-o.Y\s~yW\ ~eSj~RVy\. AcC:~ete.J f'OVYl f-t ,'!G\Yy 'Pe-v-rOtton/ lrie.. Role oF-IIT0eoYY and generalisation in the practice ofldistance education. Hagen: Z,IFF, October 198 Y. (Cover UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 99 The diagrammatic illustration in Fig. 4 is adapted from an earlier one by Hilary Perra ton in which he attempted to simply identify ways of reducing cost per student in distance education. Following any of the arrows shown in Figure 4 reflects ~n a simple manner a pattern of transformation of correspondence education to distance education. In Hilary Perraton's original diagrammatic presentation, the arrows followed variables which reflectedla reduction in the cost of a distance education programme. A transformation of correspondence educatiion to distance education presupposes a number of lthings already shown in the diagram. These are: i. an increase in the number and variety of clientele; ii. an increase in both the variety and number of courses; iii. an increase in the geographical areas covered in the programme; UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 100 iv. a move from less sophisticated media (e.g. print) to more sophisticated ones (e.g. print, computer, telephone, satellite systems etc.) • v. a movement from less learner/tutor interaction to 0reQter learner/tutor interaction. vi. a movement from slower two-way communication to faster two-way communication making possible greater learner access to interaction. Where there is a transformation of the corres- pondence system of education to distance education, the six issues raised above are major areas thqt must be addressed by such transformation. However, the I • I nature of transformation may not sometimes: reflect all the indices shown especially in micro-studies of specific correspondence education insti~ui tions. A macro study of this nature shou~d therefore adequately I reflect the pattern of transformation envisaged. ! UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY CHAPTER THREE REVIEW OF LITERATURE 3.1 INTRODUCTION This Chapter reviews the literature on the transformation of correspondence education to distance education through the examination of i. the origins of correspondence education including its Nigerian origins; , ii. the significance of the University of London Innovation and the External Degree; iii. the trends in the transformation of methods of correspondence instruction; iv. media development and the bridging of distance; v. the emergence of distance education; vi. patterns of interaction and two-way communication; vii. issues of quality ih distance education. 3.2 THE ORIGINS OF CORRESPONDENCE EDUCATION Attempts to situate the emergence of the corres- pondence system of instruction in time have led to the views that the epistles sent by Plato in the UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 102 Classical times to D,ionysius and the one from Elder Piny to the younger Piny may have been the first traces of the system in use. 1 Related to this is the citing of the Biblical records of Paul's letters to the 'Romans, Corinthians, the Galatians, among others which had their didactic components. 2 Some scholars indeed suggest that the early man may have used some form of correspondence education, even in his extensively oral traditional society to get messages across to his kith and kin.3 1. This classical view is proffered by Rene F. Erdos in 'E.,eachingby Correspondence'. Paris: Unesco, 1967 P.2. 2. The didactic nature of Paul's letters seemnot to be in doubt at all. H'is introductory notes in these letters, the use of the first person "I" and the direct reference to pec::pleor individuals to whomthe letters are addressed point to not only their pedagogic content, but to their Correspondence education relevance. See for exanple the introductic:n in Rorrans1 : 1-8; the direct address to the second persc:n (Plural) "you" in Galatians 3 : 1-4 and his extensive use of "I" in all the books . Part of the transformation process here is noticeable in the use of tracts, cassette and video tapes to reach wider audiences. 3 . The drum 'Wasa very camron rred.iumof ,rressage tr~sfer in rrany traditional Afriaan societ i.es , Ayo O::]unrant;ipaints a vivid exanple of this in his mimeograph, "Educational Technology, please step in". June 1984, l' .58 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 103 Yet, a more African interpretation sees the practices of Yorubas of old in sending messages across distance through some peculiar means as representing a pattern of the genre in historical reminiscence. 1 While these early assert~ons and explanations may have some basis as being accepted in such (e.g. paul's letters were indeed didactic, detailed, methodical and effective. Attempts to create ~ more scholarly acceptable historical base for the emergence of this novel genre appear to have shifted the focus to the practice's 18th century origins.2 3 Freitas et ai's account, while citing Katz see the correspondence system of instruction as emerging in 1. In the ccurse of this research, a colleague had talked about tile Yoruba sys+em of using "Aroko" to syrrboliseinforrratim sent to another. In another vein, others, especially travellers used "kannako" (literarily t.rarial.a.,teddistance reducer) to bridge the physical distance When travelling to lmg distances. 2. This assertim is also support.edby Valore and Diehl, cp. cit. in their account;in the NHSC ,M::nograph(see 2 .2).' 3. H.H. Katz, "A State of the Art Study of an Independent Private School Industry in the state of Illinois." Advisory Counci.L m Vocational Education, pp. 6-7. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 104 1728 when an advertisement appeared in the Boston Gazette in the State of Massachuse.tts in the U.S.A. Gachuchi and Matiru give an account of the advertise- ment thus: Any person who wishes t.o study shorthand may have several lessons sent him weekly and he would be as perfectly instructed as the person in Boston. 1 The wording c:ifthis advert i.semerit;appears to \' v !i,' I have been linguistically altered, perhaps to suit the gramma tica I acceptance of the' day. This is because Valore and Diehl's account of this beginning which had a photocopy of the March 20, 1728 announcement shown in their work has the following fuller details as the original advertisement: Caleb Philipps, Teacher of the New Method of Short Hand, is remov'd opposite to the north door of the Town House in King-street. As this way of Joyning 3, 4, 5 and C words in one in every Sentence by the Moods, Tenses, Persons, and Verb, ~o's not in the ,least spo i I the Long Hand., so it is not anything like the Marks for sentences in the printed Character Books being all w~ote according to the Le~ter, and a few Plain and Easy Rules. 1. D. Gachuchi and B. Matiru (eds.l Handbook for Designing and Writing Distance Ed~cation Materials. Bonn: DSE. 1989, p.12. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 105 N.B. Any persons in the Country desirous to learn this Art, may by having the several Lessons sent Weekly to them, be as perfectly instructed as those that live in Boston.1 In Britain, the origins of the innovation is trace- able to the 1840 ex~eriment of one Isaac Pitman of the Shorthand fame who sent instructions to his students by postcard. 2 Wellman ha$ observed of pitman's interactions with his students thus: .... the students wrote passages from the Bible in Shorthand and mailed them to Pitman for grading and comment. 3 1. Leonard Valore and Grover E. Diehl, op. cit. p.l. 2. This 1840 experiment by Pitrran has been the nost cited in terms of tracing the origins of correspondence study, until the Caleb Philipp's advertiserrent in the Boston Gazette of 1728 was unearthed. See Henry Q. Wellrran, The Teenager and Hare Sb.ldy NEWYork: Richards Rossen Press, Inc. 1970, P . 15. 3. It is significant to note the increasing relevance of both the shorthand as a Correspondence education subject, and the biblical link at the early days of correspondence t.eachinq. Caleb Phi.Li.pp' s attenpt in BostOn was to teach shor thand too. William :RaineyHarper's corresp::ndence education activities were with the American Institute of Sacred Literature which he fc::unded. See M:l.UreenA. Fay, "Harper, William Rainey (1856-1906)" in J.E. ThCIlBsand B. Elsey (eds.) International Biografhy of Adult Education. Department of Adult Education, University of Nottingham, 1985, p. 240. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 106 While this marked the start of the system in Britain, more modern beginnings were recorded wh·en between the 1880' s and the 1890' s, other correspondence schools soon emerged. These were the Skerry's (started in 1890) , the Foulk s Lynch (beqim in 1884) and the Wolsey Hall (started in 1894). There were also the University Correspondence College, the Chamber's and the Clough's which, in addition to the earlier listed ones, were some of the better known cOlleges at the time.1 Most of them haq also been known to have begum with the coaching of only a few pupils. Significantly too, Skerry's was started by a retired Civil Servant who indeed did the coaching; Foulks Lynch by a solicitor, while a Schoolmaster started Wolsey Hall. 2 The Colleges were all concerned 1. W.J.A. Harris, "Educatim by Post" ap. cit. p.270. It is interesting to note that the Colleges listed later became the pimeers of corr-e spondence education in Nigeria. 2. Wolsey Hall was started by me Joseph William Kn i..pei,n 1894, based in his successful experiment at.preparing himself to J?3.ssthe then Certificate Teachers' Examinatim. Through an advertisement of his in The schoolnB.ster,he errro.l.Led six students and thus began an experiment in Corresp::.ndenceducatim. See R. F. Erdos, Teaching by CorresjX)ndence,op. cit. p.3 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 107 with a single subject but a growth in the number of students later suggested corrunercialpossibilities. As Harris notes, Many of these very ear;y Colleges still survive today as the Stalwarts of the postal tuition World.1 In Germany, in 1856, one Charles Touissant,a French man teaching French in Berlin,and another Gustav Langenscheidt, a member of the Society of Modern Languages in Berlin had co-founded a School for teaching languages by correspondence. 2 Later in 1873, another Anna Eliot Ticknor, the daughter of a Univ- ersity of Harvard Professor started the Society to 1 . W.J.A. Harris, op. cit. p.270 2. Touissant and Langenscheidt's experiment may have arisen out of the need to address urgent socio-cultural and linguistic need. R.F. Erdos, op. cit. p.3 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 108 Encourage Stud.i.esat Hone in the U.S.A. 1 In the same country, another J. Forster, an editor and pro- prietor of a Newspaper in Pennsylvania, U.S.A. had been moved by the alarming rate at which miners were meeting their deaths in the mines. He then pursued his humanitarian aim by directing' the writing of a course of instruction on mine accidents, initially using a column in his paper the Shenandoah. This humanitarian gesture marked the beginning of the International Correspondence Schools (ICS) of Scranton, Petinsylvania, U.S.A.2 There are also the records of William Rainey Harper,whose activities in the area of correspondence education left an indelible mark on the growth of the system. As it 1. Ticknor relied extensively on the use of letters to get instructions across to her stndent.s, was motivated by the need to prcnotewanen educatdon, and.had as her least concern the lure of lucre. See Elizabeth GaryAgassiz, "Scciety to Encmrage Studies at Hare" in O. M3.ckenzie and E.L.Christensen (eds.) .'llie.O'langingworld of Correstonderice Study,.op, ci t. P,27 . 2. 'lliorrasJ.' Forster, mo fcnnded the ICShad been movedby the alanuing rate at v.hich miners met their death, and thus begm an experirrent v.hichhas led to the foonding of the ICS, mich still thrives success- fully today. See HenryQ. Wellrran, Opecit. p.15. See also W.J.A. Harris, Opecit. p.300. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 109 was once ~emdrked o~ this father of Correspondence instruction in the U.S.A., wherever he went, he took the sistem along with him.1 To a very great extent, the 'same humanitarian gestures that had informed the activities of Ticknor and Forster may have played a.great part in the Harper story. But his involvement in the growth of the system also has the biblical edge to it. By 1881, Harper was reported to have just completed a religion seminar at the Baptist Theological Seminary in Illinois when his enthusiastic students asked if they could continue to receive his lectures. This he agreed to do by mail and thus began a major experiment in correspon dence educatlo'n. 2 1. O. M:1ckenzie,E. L. Christensen and P. H. Rigby, Corresp:ndence Instruction in the United States. New York: M:::Graw-Hill Bock Ccmpany , p.28 2. As 'ThomasW. Goodspeed reports of him, "The first lessen v..as sent cut February 14, 1881" and "the next year, the lesson slips were printed ... and aHur.inq c'i.rcul.arw-esre sent broadca st. over the land, inviting the study or restudy of the language of the Old Testanent ... " T. W. Goodspeed, William Rainey Harper. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1928. p.53 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 110 Later as a Professor of Semitic Languages at the Yale Divinity School in 1886, he tried·the system again, arrd was to later start a Division of Correspondence Study when he became the President of the University of Chicago in 1892.1 AS Erdos reports, the last half of the 19th century in the U.S.A. witnessed a flurry of activities 8n the part of the Universities in the U.S.A. to start extension divisions. By 14 Ju ly, 1891, the Regents of the University of Wisconsin had approved a Faculty resolution for the development of the University extension Correspondence Study Courses. 2 1. Harper's initial planS to evolve a unique University of Chicago at its opening in 1892 led him to start five divisions for it, the university extension division being a veritable part. Wh}.le his attempts to make the extension divisions independent ran into some hitches, the Department of Correspondence Study was one of those that stayed, and which Harper qualitatively saw to fruition. See Maureen A. Fay, op. cit. p. 244 2 . R. F. Erdos, op. cit, p. 2. See also Katia de Freitas, P. D. Lynch, and R. Sweitzer, "Non-traditional Study Program: An Overvi'ew" ICDE Bulletin Sept. 1986, Vol. 12, - 3:9. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 1 1 1 It is thus seen how individuallv initiated humanitarian gestures, and the need to break the barriers of communication and distance have led to the beginning of the correspondence system of instruction in many parts of the world. While the activities of the stalwarts of the system in Britain had borrowed extensively from commercial possibilities observed in an innovation, there were the added factors of the coming of the "penny post" in England, and the growth of professional associations which further promoted the development of the system. In other places, the need to br idge the terrains of geographica 1 distance between learners and tutors, and thus maximise on the gains already made in the successful trials of the system elsewhere and also promote egal~tarianism, further fuelled the system's growth. Sweden, Australia, and some countries in the eastern bloc have ex~riences which appear to support this assertion. In Sweden in the 1890's, one Hans Hermod was reported to be "Conducting an ordinary school in Malmo" teaching languages and commercial subjects. The movement of one of his students to a place some twelve miles from the school setting coupled with Hermod's interest UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 1 1 2 to continue teaching him led Hermod to start writing instructional letters to him., By 1898, he had, based on this initial experiment, published his first correspondence course on Book-Keeping. 1 Some scholars have suggested that Hermod may have known about Langenscheidt's work in Germany. 2 The experience of Hermod may have been replicated elsewhere. The 1914 story of the beginning of the correspondence system of instruction in Australia has a similar pattern to Hermod's successful attempts and Harper's yielding to his ~eligious students pleas in Illinois. This time though, the innovation had shifted slightly from experimenting individuals to an innovation-seeking bureaucracy. As reported by Erdos: in 1914, a pioneer farmer moving into an isolated area wrote to the Director of Education to ask what provision could be made to educate his two Sons. This letter was referred to the Vice- Principal of the Teachers' College, who asked the students if any would be interested 1. R. F. Erdos, op. c it., Pi.2. 2. R. F. Erdos, I\.) i:j. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 113 in the experiment of teaching the boy by letter. Five volunteers under- took the task .1 After the volunteers started supplying the lessons to the children by post, other requests followed. By 1916, the volume of requests was high enough to justify the training of teachers for this all- important assignment. By 1922, virtually every state in the Federation, led by New South Wales, had evolved one form of correspondence education or the other. 2 The beginnings of correspondence education in Canada may have had its origin in the 1919 initiation of correspondence education at the elementary school level in British Columbia:3 At the first International 1. R.F. Erdos, Some Developments in Distance Education in Australia. ZIFF PAPIERE 61, Hagen: ZIFF, January, 1986.p -. 2 2. It is significant to note that unlike most other countries, "the regular use of correspondence tuition began at the ele;mentary school in Australia" See A. G. Maclaine, "Education 'by Correspondence (Australia)" in o. Mackenzie and E.L. Christensen (eds.l The Changing World World of Correspondence Study, op. c it. p.273 . 3. Report of the First Int~rnational Conference on Correspondence Educatio~. Victoria, 1938, p.92. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 114 Conference on Correspondence education held in Victoria, a passage from the conference report had noted: In an attempt to develop the primary industries of the Province, such as fishing, trapping, mining, lumbering and ranching, many small and widely-scattered settlements were started, some of which lasted only for a short time. Isolated families found their way into the more remote parts of the Province and were, of course, completely cut off from organised schOols of any kind. Up until 1919 no attempt was made to provide educational facilities for such families. In the 'spring of that year, a lighthouse keeper, living in one of the small islands of the west coast, made a request for assistance in teaching his small children since they were quite out of reach of an organized school. It was the belief that a plan could be made to work whereby Ies-son outlines and text material would be s~pplied to families anywhere who were out of reach of schools. The attempt was made and before the year was out, 122 pupils were studying under the direction of teachers appointed by the Provincial Department of Education, and the first Elementary Correspondence School in America was under way. This later developed to include the seco~dary school level in 1929 while University involvement, starting with the University Iof British, Columbia was begun in 1949. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 1 15 A survey of the subjects taught and the courses pursued through Correspondence StUdy reveals a wide array of choices available. In Britain, the sUbjects originally served in the early days of the system fell under five major headings. These were: 1 i. professional courses which included account- ancy, banking, surveying and engineering; ii. University and School subjects; iii. Technical subjects; iv. Civil Service and local government related subjects; and v. general and recreational subjects. Most of the colleges had areas of specialisation while they yet offered many other courses. For example, the Metropolitican and Foulks Lynch were noted for professional qualifications; the British Institute of Techpology for industrial and engineering subjects, the University Correspondence College and 1. W.J.A. Harris, cpo cit. ~.272. One Dr G. Millerson,in his The QJalifyingAssociationshad Linked the Spread of Correspondenceeducationclosely to the rise of the professionalassociationsin CommerceAdministrationand private practice,and their adoptionof qualifyingexaminationsin the late nineteenthcentury. G. Millerson,The QJalifying Associations: A Study in Professic:nalization.London: Root.Ledoeand Kegan Paul, 1964, Chapter s. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 116 Wolsey Hall for University qualifications while Clough's, Wolsey Hall and the Rapid Results College were noted for Teacher Training and the General Certificate of Examination Subjects. The Skerry's and the School of Careers spe:::ialised in Civil Service 'I'z a i...n Ln q , 1 In the United States of America, the Correspond- ence Education Research Report2 published in 1968; the Bulletin of the National Home Study Counci13 and the Macmillan Guide to Correspondence 4 Study 1. Harris further notes that "a multiple of smaLl.er forms taught subjects as piano playing and sketching, judo and body building, Pelrrani.sm(rnerorytraining) and Pap.i.d Reading. II W.J.A. Harris, op. cit. p.272. 2. o. M3.ckenzie,E. L. Christensen and P .H. Rigby, Correspcndence Instruction in the United States New York: M::Graw-HillBook Ccmpany , 1968. 3. 1990/91 Bulletin of the Natic:nalHorreStudy Ccuncil. Washington: NHSC, 1990. 4. The M3.cmillanGuide to Corresp:ondenceStudy. NEW York M3.cmillanPub. Company, 1988. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY -- -- -~ -------------, 117 list a wide array of course choices available at vocational, Secondary School, Univ~rsity, religious, and armed forces levels for the clientele of correspondence 2ducation. Every phase of educational life that is covered in the conventional education system has been served by correspondence education. The use in Canada, the U.S.A., Soviet Union, Australia and Norway of the corresponderce education system in the primary and secondary school educational system further confirms the extensive coverage of Syllabi which the system undertakes. In addition, areas that have usually not been covered by formal school systems, like the professional and qualifying examinations are easi ly handled by corre'spondence educa tion. The growth of the system, in terms of the number of clientele served, of new media processes used and of more interactive methods of organising teaching and learning, has been a major feature in the system's transformation to distance education. In the process, some of the colleges have folded while others have re-emerged under new names, while yet others have adjusted to the transformation and have continued to serve the teeming populace. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 118 The on-going discussion has, thus revealed that while the correspondence system of educa t.Lon emerged as experiments in innovation, ~hey later became systematised and more organised. Many started with a few clientele but have grown as a result of the strong commercial possibilities they offered and the growth in population of an adult audience ready to use their system. Many of the systems which survive till today may have been generally examination- oriented. Apart from individuals accepting the system, government departrrerres and other statutory bodies have found the need to utilise this 'novel approach to teaching and learning. 3.2.1 TheNig'erianOrigins 'I'heissue of identifying the origins of correspondence education in Nigeria has been well documented in the works of Omolewa.1 He observes that just after the world war, the European trend of correspondence 1. Michael Omolewa, "Correspondence Education in Nigeria, 1915-75" in Adult Education and Development No.72, 1978: "Historical Antecedents of Distance Education in Nigeria, 1887-1960"~. Adult Education in Nigeria, Vol. 7, Dec. 1982. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 1 1 9 education, which had found some berth in Britain in 1840, and in France and Germany at about 18561 finally became the turning point for Nigerians, when, as he noted: Nigerian Secondary Schools could no longer cope with the intake from primary schools and very few Nigerians could 2 afford to go overseas for higher education. Related to these points was the fact that the nature of educational activities available in Nigeria was very low at this time and this trend continued without any major solution in sight. A great demand however arose after the cessation of World War II hostilities, and even, existing evening schools had problems of providing the adequate personnel and qualified staff to teach the skills which were increasingly growing daily.3 Thus as far back as 1915, a number of English journals had started circulating their advertisements 1. R. F. Erdos, op. cit., p.2 2. M. Omolewa, "Corre spondence Education in Nigeria, 1915-75." op. cit., p. 157. 3. ibid, p. 158. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 120 in Nigeria, of leading British Colleges, among them the Wolsey Hall, the University Correspondence College, the Rapid Results College, the Foulks and Lynch and the others. 1 Many students who n~rmally would not have. found places in either the Secondary schools, or have the opportunity of getting a University to attend, moved en masse to try the correspondence education option. Table 2· Enrolnent at Fornal Educational Institutions in Nigeria Year University Primary School Secondary University Session Enrolment SchoolEnrolment Enrolment t 1926 + 518 - 1937 238,879 3,851 - 1947 626,000 9,908 - 1952 1952/53 1,039,659 + 368 1954 1954/55 1 ,275,003 21,185 476 1956 1956/57 2,036,613 39 ,017 563 1958 1958/59 2,544,512 41 ,391 1 ,005 1960 1968/61 2,912,619 55,235 1 ,256 1962 1962/63 2,834,010 :195,499 3,606 1964 1964/65 2,849,488 205,012 6,707 1966 1966/67 3,025,023 :211,305 9,170 SaJrce: Michael Onolewa., "Correspcndence Education in Nig2ria, 1915-1975" in Adult Education and Devel.oprent., No.72 June 1978, p.158 + Figure not available 1. W.J.A. Harris, op. cit. in O. :M3.ckenzie and E.L. Christensen, op. cit. p. 270. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 121 These early colleges helped Nigerians to pass .the examinations set by the University of London, the College of Preceptors and those of Oxford and Cambridge UniveEsities. Sometimes, some of the students had to repeat the examinations many times before passing. It was therefore not uncommon to have students of the St. Andrews College Oyo in Nigeria go on holidays anytime any of their teachers passe d any 0f these examl.n.atlons. 1 This was how E. ,0. Ajayi became Lne first Nigerian to bag a degree of the University of London in 1927, relying exclusively on Correspondence education. Others soon followedsuit. Aivan Lk oku , whose name and picture adorns Nigeria's ten naira note got his B.A. degree in Philosophy in 1929, the same field as Ajayi's. In 1933 Samuel Ayodele Banjo, the father of the former Vice-chancellor of the University of Ibadan also got his B.A. degree in Philosophy. 2 1. M. Omolewa, J.T. Okedara, A. Okediran and G. Adekanmbi (eds.). J. S. Ogunlesi,! 1902-1981, p. 11 2. M. Omolewa, "Historical Antecedents If r- op. ci t. p. 15. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 122 By 1943, Nigerians had started making some attempts to found their own Cprrespondence Colleges. The City Correspondence College that was set up in 1943 did not last long. 1 After independence in 1960, new proprietors had an in-road into the scene. One of them, Mr. Okudolo, who himself had been an alumnus of the Wolsey Hall, founded the continually growing Examination Success Correspondence College in Lagos in 1967.2 Others soon followed suit. Coincidentally, the year 1967 also marked the first incursion of Universities in Nigeria into correspondence work, with the Ahmadu Bello University in Zaria starting the Teacher-In-Service Educatiion Programme (TISEP).3 This' was actually TISEP's second coming, having been first instituted by the Northern Nigeria Ministry of Education in the late '50's but had to 1. M. Crro.l.eva , "Correspondence Education in Nigeria, 1915-75", op. cit. p. 160. 2. Interview with Mrs. V.A. Ckudolo, wife of the fcunder of the College (also, Corporate Affairs M3nager) en 5th April, 1990 at 2088 Ikorcx1uRoad, Palm Grove, Yaba, IathDy. Ireland,"Gelpi'sView of Life-long Edncat.Lo,n Unlversltyof M3nchester,MJnografh. 1979 p. 20 2. Kirpal, cited in T:irrothDv, Ireland,ibid, p. 24. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 145 and learners. While the teacher sends his instructions, the learner engages in horne study, which is why the term is sometimes used to describe the process. Post cards were the f Lrsti. course texts sent by Pitman in his days1 while in 1870 Forster in the United States began his courses on mine safety through the column created in his newspaper called the Shenandoah Herald which was a.weekly paper. At the Society to Encourage Studies at Horne started by Anna Eliot Ticknor in 1873 it was the use of ~onthly letters between teacher and student which was the original method adopted. While she shied away from advertising her programme, saying "If it is really needed, it will soon make itself known", others, including Caleb Phillips of the 1728 Boston Gazette advert fame did publici~ their activities. The fact that most of these early correspondence study schools began with just a few individuals as clientele, and their subjects mostly single subjects, 1. Wo..J .A. Harris, "Education by Post (England)" inMackenzie and E.L. Christensen (eds.), op. cit. p.300 2. o. ~~ckenzie and E.L. Christensen, ibid. p.31 3. E.C.o.Agassiz," Soeiety to Encourage Studies at Horne"in Mackenzie and E.L. Christensen (eds.) p.28. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 146 the use of this method of instruction appeared appropriate for them. Most w~re also examination-centred, and concerned with the technical, professional and vocational fields. However, and perhaps as a result of growth in the system, both of clientele and subject areas served, the programmes began being supplemented by occasional lectures and classes, tutorial sessions and residential courses. In Britain, Harris notes that some of the schools later combined teaching by correspondence with classroom lecture instruction. For. the greater majority however, the work was conduc-ted almost entirely from a group of offices and such a centre of operations demanded convenient postal services and an address which would not detract from its attractiveness for intending postal students.1 It was therefore not unc,?mmon, based on a growing volume of work, and a related growing number of part-time tutorial staff, to have the colleges operating from "a pool of school or college staffs". This was a process of transformation for the colleges as they appeared to be promoting the development of study centres, where learners could meet in groups 1. W.J.A. Harris, "Education by Post" Adult Education Vol. 39, No.5 1967. p.270. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 147 and discuss related problems, apart from meeting some part-time tutors. But this was still more of an exception than the rule. The incidence of drop-out amongst those studying by correspondence was reported by Jones to be very high. It was thus with a view to finding solutions to this that: 1 1. the Rapid Results College sought the cooperation of technical colleges in Britain; 2. the National Extension College evolved a number of schemes to introduce a measure of ora L tuition; 3. since 1965, the South West .London College had been. running a number of linked oral-postal tuition courses. Of the South West London College, Jones further notes that after tutors had satisfied the correspond- ence two-way communication system with the learners, they are also on duty in the evening in order to see visiting registered students who may require some guidance on specific points they found difficult. The scheme thus ensured contact with tutors, contact 1. Lyndon H. Jones, "Directed Private Study" Adult Education Vol. 44, No. 6~ March 1972, p. 37-6--- UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 148 with other students and contact with the practical side of the work to be done. Yet, this was an exception. Perhaps a detailedexamination of the two stories that fo.Ll.ow will show the extent to which a great many colleges, especially proprietary ones, continued to rely on a method which emphasized the medium of print. The first story is that of the' International Correspond- ence School s,1 After successfully founding the Shenandoah Herald in 1870, and having begun the weekly articles on mine safety, Forster turned the Herald into a daily in 1875, and by 1879, had changed the name to the Z.linin(iH~e·rald. Luckily, a law was passed in pennsylvania in 1885, making it illegal for anyone to be a mine inspector without obtaining a Certificate of Competency. Forster qu LckLy souqht, - que.stions from the miners, got college trained engineers to' work out the solutions and published both guestions and answers in the MJ~nning Herald. These en-gineerswere his'" 1• O. Mackenzie and E.L. Christensen, liThe Workingman's School II in edited book by the same authors, OPe cit. p. 31. Cited as extract from liThe ICS story" in International Correspondence Schools, Scranton, Penn~ylvania. (N.d., N.p.). UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 149 course writers. Next he gathered "all available state examination that had been given in recent years and publ ished answers to these also". One success led to another, and soon, the initially back page column occupied front-page position, filling out the entire front-page of his Herald. A careful analysis of the questions submitted by his clientele, led Foster to introduce, in addition to subjects like arithmetic, mensuration, formulas, such other areas as training in elementary subjects (e.g; calculations), in the laws of Gravity, flow of liquids and gases and others. Soon pamphlets emerged on the subjects, and this was the beginning of the issuing of course texts. Soon his clientele demanded application of the principles learnt. Foster quickly "interspersed ,the reading matter of his pamphlets with numerous problems whose solution demanded the application of the principles contained in the pamphlets." In addition to this opportunity for practice, Foster added a comprehensive examination covering the text. He then looked for qualified persons "to check, correct and grade the answers UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 150 to the examination questions". Thus, he brought in the concept of the course tut6r. Having changed the name of the Herald to 'The Colliery Engineer, what Foster had just started thus became the Correspondence Education Department of the company. Soon, Foster asked his course writers to publish a short course on mining. The course, which was advertised in 1891" finally laid the foundation for the International Correspondence Schools of scranton. In quick succession, courses on steam engineering, electri.c ity , architecture, plumbing, sheet metal pattern drafting,. civil engineering, heating, book-keeping, stenography and English followed. By 1968, ICS had passed the 8,000,000 mark in terms o~ students .it had trained. 1 An examination of I.C.S. 's present methods of teaching now, as reported in a 1990 study shows the following characteristics:2 1. "The Workingman's School" in o. Mackenzie and E. L. Christensen, op. cit. (eds.) pp. 31 - 34. 2. F. Doerfert, R. Schl/emer & C. Tomachewski, Short, Descriptions bf Selected Distance Education lrtstitutions. Hagen: ZIFF 1989. p_360·; UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 151 i . a course team approach which combines the subject specialist, media specialist and the students of the subject; ii. the existence and use of local study centres; iii. allowance for curriculum flexibility depending on the type of diploma offered; iv. use of various media for teaching, from written course texts to personal computers; v. distance teaching with a few face-to-face components; vi. existence of two-way communication through correcting of assignments Commenting on assignments Answering of learner's queries, requests etc. telephone interaction. vii. existence of measures to reduce non-starter or drop-out rates, such as: mailing of standardized letters of encourage- ment or reminders, mailing of individualized letters. The study above is a trend in the transformation of co-respondence education to distance education, as UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 152 seen from the development in the method of in~truction on a proprietary school setting. The second example is based on a'review of the transformation of the methods:of teaching and learning, and ensuring two-way interaction in university-based correspondence education programmes. Available literature on the development of the system in Britain and the United States shows the usual pattern of the clientele depending on the course texts prepared by the course writers. At the earlier stages, these were indeed not self-contained texts as they were guides which contained a lot of references, and questions that learners eventually studied, and later sat for examinations. The coming of the self contained course texts appeared to have been a development on this earlier system. However, in the case of correspondence colleges which I complemented the;circuitous entry of the University of London to Correspondence education, through its degree~by-examination aptivities, UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 153 they had to study the university's syllabus and use it to prepare their own courses. 1 The method of university-type correspondence education is further shown in. the detailed report given by one Smithson, at a National Universities Association Conference held in 1925 in the State of Virginia, U.S.A. The pattern, for the teaching of English by correspondence then by the University of california follows thus: Step 1: Students are sent a set of instructions, guides to study, reference materials to use, and accompanying assignments. The academic Senate expects fifteen assignments to be the equivalent of one unit of work. Step 2: The student 90es on to'do the first assignment and returns this to.the tutor for his comments, corrections and advice, which later turns out to be the real teaching of the student. As Smithson observes, The assignments of a correspondence course in English are not depended on to teach themselves. The main part of the teaching "comes from" the instructor's reactions to the papers sub- mitted by the student. 1. Michael Orrolewa,"ThePronotionof LondonUniversity's Examinationsin Nigeria, 1887-1951" cp, cit. p. 654. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 154 step 3: The instructor, on receiving the student's assignment and correcting him, adds additional instructions, emphasizing and supplementing particular points and furnishing special exercises to correct faults. Series of activities which the student maybe asked to perform may not be part of the regular assignment. Step 4: Sometimes supplementary lessons are put in form of personal letters or accompanied by personal letters to convince the student that the instructor is interested in him. The process then continues until a final examination is written and the student awarded a degree. It is however not uncommon, later, for some university correspondence programmes to offer tutorial type instruction and discussion with study groups. Wedemeyer notes that even students who are resident in campus, combine correspondence study with resident class study. He attributes this variation in method to the inherent flexibility of the correspondence method and its "ready adaptation or combination with other learning methods. ,,1 A list of his predictions about university correspondence study further shows the possible changes in method over the years. These 1. Charles Weddemeyer, Ope cit., p. 212 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 155 are, among others: i. correspondence instruction methodology will employ all appropriate media and will develop new techniques of adaptation to individual' differences through the use of interchangeable study units employed by instructors in a way not unlike the' branching techniques employed in some programmed learning: courses. ii. correspondence instruction will be remade in structure, form and methodology as to fit the needs', technology, and aspirations of the new age. iii. the correspondence study system, the pen and ink system, the postal tuition or tutorial system may give way to cross-media learning or some other term implying modern- ization of the old, simple pen and ink. A look at the distance education practices of the Open University of GreatiBritain reveals that some of these projections have come true. They are indeed indications of the transformation of the method UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 156 of instruction especially when issues like computer marked assignments, computer mediated communication and the use of telephone tutoring are considered alongside the use of the printed text. 3.5 MEDIA TRANSFORMATION AND THE BRIDGING OF DISTANCE A discussion on the dev~lopment of the media in distance education cannot be totally removed from the related issue of the growth of either educational media or technology, or the general development of communication systems. The term "media" itself has been simply described as channels of communication which increase the number of and speed'of messages sent, and as such are seen as message multipliers. However, media need not be mostly inanimate as the oral medium of sending message by man had been in existence since creation. This presupposes that even the individua 1 is a medium of communication, u.sing the various verbal and non-verbal cues he sends as signals for various purposes. The consideration of the medium of communication has always been a major issue in education since the UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 157 days of Socrates. This is because in his activities as a teacher, (even though he claims he qpes not know) the person-to-person medium had been his main method of teaching. This oral medium which had been supplemented with the invention of writing, later got a boost when the coming of the Gutenberg press revolutionised education. With the coming of print, large volumes of written material could be reduced to portable materials, and its copies multi- plied. When correspondence education later emerged, both the written and the printed word became the main medium of instruction, as such instruction could easily be sent through letters written,or printed words sent over a distance which the early courier systems could cover, or the distance that the later mail delivery system could bridge. Print itself underwent. D.ransformation , as its qualities and unique characteristics began to show. Of these qualities, Gordon notes, print is permanent, finite and flexible. 1 What print really does is act on behalf of people or machines in such a way as to facilitate efforts to replicate t~eir 1. IX:naldR. Gordm, "Printas a'visual rredfurni'n'Asheim and Fenwick (eda.}, Differentiatingthe M=dia. Ol.icago:The Universityof Chicago Press. 1975, p.34. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 158 sensory-cerebral experiences. In doing this, print thus possesses shape, size, colour, intensity and pnnctuation devices which, when juxtaposed, can be orchestrated with very broad parameters. This began to be used in correspondence education. In addition, it was also found that print can use the following to advantages, especially when conveying educational infor~tion:1 i. as a separate and distinct language in itself, it consists of a vocabulary, a way of using it which any expression in print format can maximise; ii. it is neither oral nor aural and as such there is a difference between Print~English and Print-French; iii. its shape and form when orchest~ated can persuade people to read it slowly or rapidly; iv. its texture, and colour can show mood, credibility, acceptability and a degree of seriousness. In finally comparing print with the other media that can be applied to education, Gordon notes that its characteristics as a primary visual medium, and its inability to cover sounds, smells, tastes and touches at first hand need not be a problem, considering 1. D. R. Gordon, op. cit. p. 38. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 159 its identified qualities. This is because it has a way of helping to filter, mute, and translate " . ttte information received into visual "approximations. And he expressed his fears thvs: Our sensory-cerebral systems would probably pop like fire-crackers if exposed to the full array of sounds, 1 smells, tastes, touches . The printed word has thu~ been extensively used in correspondence education, even in educational systems in the world that have developed, extensively, the later media that emerged. This is because of its relative cheapness and amiability to individualized instruction which the correspondence system of education promotes. In a study carried out by Schuemer in 1988 , 176 schools and unLversi,ties promoting distance education, of the 200 schools studied, gave informa tion on" the media" used in promoting two-way communication. 145 of them stated that they use written cornrnunication.2 In another study carried out 1 . ibid. p. 37 2. F. Dcerfert, R. Schuerrer& C. Taraschewski, op ci r. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 160 by the UNESCORegional Office for Education, and published in 19841 all the di~tance education s~stems use the medium of print in addition t6 others. Omolewa and Adekanmbi' s "The heoerronv of the Print Media in Distance Education Delivery" also discussed the issue extensively2 while Freitas et al con f Lrrn this assertion.3 In the British Open University where the name "University of the Air" had been initially proposed to veer the system towards only , the electronic media realm, the print medium has been dominant a s "65% of students' time is devoted to the use of the printed word".4 These devel.oprentxhave hCM'evenrot stalled the transformation of Correspcndenceeducaticn. 1. ResourceM:l.terialsUsed in Distance Teaching by Higher Education Institutions. Bangkc:k: Unesco, 1984. 2. MJ.chaelOnolewaand GboJagadeAdekanrrbi,"Thehegerrony.of the Print M2diain Distance Education Delivery". Innovation in Distance Education. Harare: African Asscciatim for Distance Educatim. ., 3. Katia de Freitas et aI, Opecit. p. 41 4. Learning at a Distance and the NewTechnolcgy. Vancouve.re Educatimal Research Institute of British Colunbia. 1982, Of other categories: televisien and radio course broad:::asts carry 10%,tutoring and ca.rnselling en an individual and groop basis, 15%;assignments and assessments, 10%;ibirl. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 161 While the printed word W'as the only medium available to most distance education institutions at the beginning, Hertz's proving of .the existence of £adio waves in the 1880s and the transmitting or radio signals less than tw~nty years later, added a new dimension of medium use in distance education.1 The transformation process had begun. Farrant considers three broadcast types possible, with radio. These are the stimulative, enrichment and the core broadcast. 2 The stimulation purpose is achieved when radio is psed to motivate learners in a kind of informal way. The second type, enrichment is like a documentary which provides a background to the learners' experience. The core broadcast is the one involving the broadcast of the core lectures. It is the direct teaching broadcast. 1. ibid, p. 8 2. M. onol.eva and G. Adekanmbi -"The HeCj~mony of the PrintMedia in Distance Education .-De Li.very" op. ci t. p. 171. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 162 Radio has the capacity for extending learning at a distance and is useful in reaching isolated rOral audiences, especially where the mail delivery system may not easily reach or not reach at all. It also complements the printed word and this has been the use mostly in literacy programmes in developing countries that, in addition to the texts prepared, are complemented thus. It is also relatively cheaper than the other electronic media, and this may have warranted its categorisation in Schram's Big Media, Lit'tle Media as part of the little media. 1 The invention of the transistor,2 a smaller version of the radio in 1948 indeed made its application become more widespread and more highly cost effective. Examples of the use of the radio for running distance education programmes abound allover the world. The school of the Air programmes in Australia; the Ryerson Open College in Ontario, Canada; the University of the Air in Japan and even the aborted National Open University of Nigeria are examples of such systems. 1. Wilbur Schramm, Big Media, Little Media, op. cit. p.16. 2. Learning ata Distance and the New Technology, op. cit. p. 8. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 163 At some other levels, the Federal Radio Corporation of Nigeria (FRCN) has a number of School educational b~oadcasts, which though are not distance education programmes in a sense, still have the potentials for being used for that purpose ..I In K' enya, Tanzania and Ghana, the extensive use of the radio for distance edcuation has been reportea.1 Elsewhere, there have b~en other records of radio use for distance education in Brazil, Mex Lc o , Nicaragua and India. The World Bank two-volume work published in 1977 and titled Radio for Education and Development: Case Studie's in this regard. 2 The programme titled "Hedurezia" in Brazil which was cited by Dsoro in his research reported by Freitas et al,3 the work of the Institute of Radio and Bradcasting of Bahia in Brazil and others reported by Hoore 4 in the U: St.A. are 'examples!of distance education programmes, by radio specia~ly designed for the elementary and secondary grades, including those 1. Learningat a Distanceand the New Technolcgy,op , cit. p.8 2. Katia de .Freitas,et.aI.., cp.cit, p.41. 3. ibid. 4. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 164 to promote literacy and contihuing education. Still in the U.S.A., the Purdue University was by 1969 olfering 14 various radio broadcast Study programmes while in 1980, a complete Bachelor's degree programmes was carried out through the use of the radio by the West Virginia Wesleyan University. 1 It is also important to take note of the signi- ficant contribution of the British Broadcasting Corporation in this area. This is because as early as 1926, in what was an internal BBC memorandum, . a proposal had been put to the then head of the Corporation, John Reith, to set up a 'wireless University,2 Although Perry reports that there was no formalisation at that stage, earlier moves were said to have been made in 1924 when the Adult Education Committee of the Board of Education, the BBC and the British Institution of Adult Education, all in U.K. , had agreed to hold a series of regular talks, with 20,000 copies of the printed syllabus of 1. Katia de Freitas et. al. ,Ope cit., p. 41 2. Walter Perry, Open University. Milton Keynes: Open University Press. 1976, p.S UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 165 same circulated.1 In 1927 th~ BBC went ahead 'to set up its own adult education section. Thus, a.systematic teaching of language, with the additional support of specially written text book and gramophone recor ds emerge d as a programme;. 2 These early thrusts, and the ~ventual series of working agreements between the BBC staff and the Commi ttee working on the development of British University of the Air, Later served as the precursor of the Open University itself. vJhile mos.t radio broadcasts have been found to be restricted by broadcast time schedules, thus creating a peculiar problem for the distant learner, the corning of the audio cassette whose development followed o.n the heels of Thomas Edison's ac oust.Lc recording systems of 1877 and· the electronic recordings of the 1920s,. La-tier paved the .w.ay for the needed flexibility in radio broadcasts and was thus another saep in the tzansfornat.Lcn process. 3 Tape recorders 1 • ibid. 2. Walter Perry, op, cit. p.5 3. Learningat a Distanceand the New'Technology,Ope cit., p.9. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 166 became available from the 1950s, the open-reel recorders carne in the 1960s a'.nd the manufacture. of the Cassette tape in 1963 by 'Philips later made . 1 recorders a common place phenomenon. Describing the use of the audio tape for' distance education purposes, Leslie of the University of Waterloo writes:2 The actual way that professors prepare one of our taped correspondence courses is that they sit down at a desk with a tape recorder, the formal visual material and a pad of paper. The.professor talks into the tape recorder, and can ~~efer the student to various aspects of the formal vi·sual material. The professors can do examples or present written notes, using the pad of paper just as they would use a blackboard in ~ classroom. The corning of up-to-date communication systems, and the existence of many broadcast organisations has reduced the work of the professor here and thus allow models to speak into the tapes in place of the professors who probably teach these courses in conventional education programmes~ However, where 1. Learning at a Distance and the New Technology, op. cit. p.9 . 2. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 167 professors "teach" their courses through the tapes, facilities are available at the.course production stage to refine them for eventual use by the clientele. The amount of information that goes into the recorded tape is based on the institut~onal provider of distance education's calculation of the ratio of the printed word to that of the audio pre$entation. Like the radio whose original use was for the sending of information across distances, the corning of the television in the early 1880's and its public demonstration in 1926 .by one John Baird, 1 were pioneer moves in the system's development for educational purposes. By the early 1930s and the end of the 1940s, television broadcasts had begun in the United Kingdom and the U.S.A. respectiv,ely.2 The production of such programmes as "Sesame Street" or "The Ascent of Man" influenced the initial use of the system for educational purposes by educators. 3 1. Learning at a Distance and the New Technologies, Ope clEo p. 10. ' ! '------- 2. ibid. 3. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 168 Research has shown that it has been-used in Senegal to teach English as a second language while the Catholic University of Peru and the West German Konrad Adnamer Foundation have used it.1 In the 1950's, it was reported that 114 tolleges afid Univer- sities in the U.S.A. teamed up with television stations to present college lectures.2 This practice has been replicated in Japan. where national television networks have co-operated with correspondence schools to bring instruction to the homes of their clientele.3 The improvement of the quality of instruction in broadcast types in such co-operative ventures thus appears to be based on the improvement of the network itself. 4 1. Katia de Freitas, et. al. op. cit. p.42 2. ·Katia de Freitas et al; ~p. cit. p. 43. 3. Henry Q. Wellman, "Educational Technology: The Advantage and the Prob lems." in O. Mackenzie and E. L. Christensen, op. cit. p. 178. 4. Peter H. Rossi and Bruce J. Biddle (eds.), The N"ew Media and Education. Garden City: Doub leday & Company Inc. 1967, p. 58. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 169 The initial nature of television use for distance education can thus be categorised under Farrant's earlier identification of the stimulative, enrichment and the core broadcast uses. 1 While the television thus affords the teacher the opportunity of reaching a greater number of his pupils, it shares the additional advantage of added motion pictures which can faithfully create a sense of reality and of movements in life. It is also used to teach laboratory- based sciences or historical events which may have been recorded 'before hand. When it does this, it combines the effect of the film element or that of the video. However, Bates notes that the use of broadcast television, espe'Cially over nationally networks can be very.expensive. This problem and the need to have repeated viewing of the same programme which the broadcast type may not be able to give may have warranted the coming of the Video Cassettes. The advantages of the video-cassettes over broadcast television are listed by Bates thus: 1. J. S. Farrant, Ope cit. p. 171. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 170 1 . independence of transmission times as students study material when they find such suitable; 2. lower production cost; 3. with video, you only pay for what you use, especially if production is commissioned externa lly; 4. the video cassette is more effective instructionally than production for broadcasting. The designing and production of video cassettes should therefore take the following into consideration, as raised by Bates and surnrnarisedbelow: 1. Only aspects that require televisional presentation should be properly segmented, with such segments ~arying in length; 2. Students should be given clear clues as to when to stop as they may watch the video continuously; 3. Selection of meaningful activities with the segments is necessary; 4. Segments need to be clearly indexed with a number on the screen so that students can easily search them out when nee,ded; 5. The possibility of students frequently switching from vide0 to audio cassette or to print should be reduced; 6. Clear directions should be given. A programme of video cassette loan such as the one administered by the Open.University of U.K. could be used. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 171 The Cable T.V. is another variation of tbe television. The difference here is that specially pre-paid for programmes can be aired'on the national television network based on the individual's payment of the established fees. In developed countries, it is possible to pick more than sixty television stations, for entertainment and various purposes depending on how much and for what interest areas one has paid to the Cable Television organisations. The coming of the cable television, tele courses, 'slow scan television or the tele- conferencing are modern developments in this regard. Thus, while the telephone is linked with fue television in the slow scan television, tele-conferencing may include the use of additional media, which combine audio, video or text signals for the purpose of engaging in interactions in groups. On the other hand, there may be distinct types of tele-conferencing namely; audio tele-conferencing, video tele-conferencing and also computer tele~conferencing. Historically, Pye and W~lliams note that the German post office operated teleconferencing between UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 172 1935 and 1958 while the Bank of America and the British Post Office used it respectively in 1958 and si'"'I1ce1934.1 Of i~ definition, Parker says: Teleconferencing is'electronic commun i.ca t.Lon between two or more 'people at a distance.2 Thus audio conferencing is actually telephone conferencing because it is the telephone technology that allows the network that connect conferences together. Among its advantages are: its use of familiar technology - the telephone its wide accessibility (in developed countries) its possibility of being set up at shortnotice its comparatively \Inexpensive nature (in developed countries) Among the options available here are the dedicated conference network such as the one used by the University of Wisconsin; the dial-up networks 1. Learning at a Distance and the New Technology, op. cit. p. 12 . 2. Lorne H. Parker, "Tele-Conferencing in Education" in ERIC Digest Syracuse: ERIC n.d. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 173 which engages the services of a public switched telephone network where the operator can link all participants together; the meet-me conferencing which is the brain-child of private telephone conferencing companies where the quality of service is high; and the direct-dial conferencing which allows one caller "to set up a telephone conference with up to six additional participants by using a touch tone phone". Speaker phones have indeed been made to make the process of interacting eaSl.er. 1 In Video Conferencing, the audio and the visual media are combined such that interactive voice communication and television pictures occur at the same time. While the slow scan television and the compressed video systems are versions of this, the full motion video system is most useful as it transmits a full video picture and uses wideband channels. This is however very expensive .. 1 Lorne H. Parker, ibia. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 174 The aUdio-graphics tele-conferencing coffibines the characteristics of the video and audio conferencing and the term "audiographics" refers to "the transmission of print and graphic information over telephone lines to complement voice communication with visual inform- a t.L•o n • I 1I , This has been used extensively·in distance education.2 The latest development in the transformation of correspondence education to distance education in the area of media development is that of satellite systems and compu ter mediated communication. Satellite communication technology is as old as the Soviet Union's Sputnik.3 As Telesat Canada states, a satellite communication system is a microwave link consisting of a number of dish shaped antennas which transmit and receive microwave frequency signals to and from satellites statjoned in equatorial orbit. Ahese links allow, for all types of commun1cationto be : carried - telephone. conversations, radio and television programs, teleeype 4 messages and computer data transmission. 1. "Teleccnferencingin Education". SYracuse:ERIC DIGEST, 1990. 2. ibid. 3. Learningat a Distanceand the New Technology,cp. cit. p. 32. 4. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 175 en the development of computers, it was noted that the 1943 coming of the 'CoLosus" in 1943 in the' U:K., and that of ENAC in the U.S.A. ·in 1946 opened the way for the calculation of numerous computations, and keeping of records by Western Scientists, although at a high cost.1 The follow-up miniaturisation of such; which was as a result of the growth in aerospace technology thus led to the appearance on the market of cheap micro-computers for the home, offices and schools. A computer by definition is a deVice that accepts data, performs operations on that data in a sequence decided by a program and outputs the resul ts. 2 In distance education, micro computers have been used.in keeping data in students' records and providing students with such information quickly; it has been used for pedagogical purposes as in on-line education3 (e.g. electronic mail, computer Learning at a Distance and the New Technology, op. cit. p. 63 2. ibid., pp. 64-65. 3. Robin Mason and Anthony Kpaye, Mindweave. Milton Keynes: Open University Press. 4 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 176 Conferencing and as on-line data bases and information banks); for computer-mediated~communication (CMC); and for marking students' assignments (i.e., CMA's). Existing literature shows that most of these uses have been made more in the advanced countries than in developing ones. The reasons for non-use are the high costs involved, the lack of needed technological back-up and the inability on the part of the institutional providers of distance education to want to tryout the innovation. The advantages of the satelli~e system are a1ready being appropriated in distance education programmes. These have been tried successfully in Canada, U.S.A., India, Brazil and Indonesia. 1 There are 'various satellite organisations set up to coordinate and lease satellite space in orbit at both domestic and inter- nationa levels.2 Among these are the Telesat of Canada, Communication . Satellite. Corporation (Comsat) of the U.S.A.; the International Telecommunications Satellite Organisation (Intel~at) with headquarters in Washington D.C. U.S.A.; Soviet Unions Intersputnik; 1. Learning at a Distance, op. cit. p. 39. 2. ibid, pp. 34-35. NIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 177 the European Space Agency (ESA) and the International Telecommunications Union (ITU). Nigeria leases s§tellite capacity from Intelsat1 an~ is a member of the ITU. The ensurance of the clear and faster accessibility of information by distance education students over long distances appears to rest on the active develop- ment of satellite systems in various nations where the programmes are run. This is because the use of all other sophisticated media which signify a trend in the transfo~mation of correspondence education rest on the a~~ilability of satellite communication facilities. The gradual transformation of the -media of distance education can then be said to follow this pattern, based on the development of media systems available. i. the initial reliance on hand-written letters, post card notes and 'briefs on various subject area by the proprietors of the system; 1. ibid, p. 35. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 178 ii. the veering into printing of such message as a result of the development of printing, and an increase in clientele being served; iii. the use of the radio, as in the Benton Harbour plan to transmit messages, to learners; iv. the follow-up use of audio cassettes to relay information to learners; v. the use of video cassettes to teach; vi. the use of tele-conferencing as practised in some developed countries; vii. the use of satellite systems to relay messages over national television stations; viii. the application'of computers for both pedagogical and administrative use in distance education. Levinson and Nipper have in fact taken note of this trend in transformation. In Levinson's view: The dominant media in edu~ation, now and prior to the arrival of computer conferencing are (in descending order of importance): in-person classes, books and related printed documents, and audio-visual media (recorded and broadcast)' 1. Paul Levinson, op. cit. pp. 43-44. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 179 To Nipper, there have been three generations of distance learning. In the first arid second generations: communication with the learners has been marginal, and commun Lca t.Lon amongst the learners has been more or less non-existent. 1 But the third generation distance education which has embedded in it the new me'di.a has a great propensity for the facilitation of easier access to two-way communication. These two views further but.t reas the paint that correspondence education has undergone some transformation as it veers into distance education. 3.6 TWO-WAY COMMUNICATION AND OTHER PATTERNS OF INTERACTION ' The transf orma tion 0 f cox.respon dence education to distance education has brought with it a continuity of concern for the necessary existence of a two-way communication system in distance education. Beyond this, it has also placed a call for faster link and easier accessibility to the inst~tutional provider of distance education by the learner. More than 1. Soren, Nipper, op. cit. p. 63. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 180 the former situation of learners having to wait very long for the mail to bring them a response from the correspondence education supplier, the existence of faster means of communication then makes it necessary for tutors, course writers and counsellors to liaise with the learner faster than they used to do. In systems where these technological developments are still a luxury, there is a sense in which a recourse to additional face-to-face elements, apart from the usual prcmpred texts, may be fully required. The increasing number of learners who use the distance education system however show that the option for the use of more sophisticated technology will still hold sway especially when other issues like the administrative problems associated with such a large clientele is involved. Also, there is the possibility of a lower cost for some of the technological support systems that may be embarked upon. In locating the general pattern which the two-way interactionin distanceeducation has followed in recent UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 181 times, a survey of the processes some of the 200 correspondence colleges and universities studied by Schuemer for ZIFF engaged in (a) reducing the non-starter and drop-out rates: i. mailing of pr'e+produc ed (standa'rdized) letters of encouragement or reminders ii. visit to learners by people appointed by the institution iii. mailing of iridividualized lett~rs iv. phone calls to learners v. having an orientation program vi. having orientation workshops (voluntary) (b) ensuring two-way communication i. correcting of assignments ii. commenting on assignments iii. regular contacts between tutor and learner, mediated contact (by telephone) iv. answering of learner's queries, requests etc. v. mediated/direct face-to-face contact vi. contacts with learne+s initiated by the institution; vii. use of telephone viii. use of tapes ix. audio conferencing UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 182 (c) there is also expected a general improvement in the average turn-around-time for tutor's corrections and comments on assignments given to learners. As the demand for more interaction thus stares the transformed distance education system in the face, so is the nature of the demand which may also go a bit into the extreme. Nipper's criticism here, of distance education brings this to mind. §pecifically he sees it, even in its call for two-way communication as being old hag and not in tune with the ideals of a liberal system. He criticises the mode of getting messages across to learners as being i. authoritatian as it imposes text or broadcast material upon the learners; ii. non-interactive, since learners cannot react or stimulate a dialogue iii. isolative, as it is capable of isolating learners from one another. 1 1. Soren Nipper, op. cit. p. 65. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 183 He submits that neither the one-way nor the two-way technology is enough for the 1earner. Nipper's aI~uments may indeed be tenable, at least when one considers the'need for learners to be able to interact freely through such things as computer mediated communication systems. However, the argument smacks of specifically asking for a paradigm shift, such that the classroom situation is re-enacted in the distance education system. This is of course what will happen. when the issue of computer mediated communication is carried to its logical conclusions. While this represents an extreme view that may not be practised now, there is a sense in which our earlier discussed mud-ball view of the global setting is vindicated by a situation where everybody learns at home as Nipper seems to be working towards. Even where this~appens, the, goals of transformation which continues to bean on-go,ing one is further vindicated and satisfied. In view of the above, no correspondence education system can thus conveniently lay claim to growth if it cannot ensure a speedy form of at least the expected two-way communication. Where a one-way UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 184 communication is operating, it is even worse. At another level, it appears that the concept of t~o-way communication has indeed given way to a call for a multiple forms of communication. The example of the computer-mediated inte'raction'is only one of such possibilities. The use of teleconferencing, either video, audio and conference telephones also make possible communication possibilities that transcend the two-way approach. Considering the level' of technological development in developing countries, such multi-interactive modes may be difficult thus paving the way for other convenient models of the multi-communication ideal. 3.7 ISSUES OF QUALITY IN DISTANCE EDUCATION Discussions on the quality question in distance education, right·from the heYTday.s of· its pr~ctice and recognition as correspondence education have been common. The trends of such discussion appear to have shifted from an initial emphasis in fears of a possible achievement of parity of esteem between correspondence education provisions and conventional UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 185 educational activities. Usually, the more emphasized areas of discourse have centred on the quality of c~ndidates that enrol in corr~spondence education; the nature of the provisions, whether such match the seemingly qualitative paradigms assumed for conventional education, the fear that the quality of instruction through the novel methodology may not be good enough, and the general assumptions of the possible low quality of the clientele of correspondence education. Again, the reaction to the quality of the system is characterised by society's , acceptance of the worth of the certificates given to students of distance education, especially where tertiary level provisions are concerned. However, while there thus appearec, 't.o. have been sarreapathy at the early days of correspondence education, there has been a change over the years in the level of acceptance of the genre. The level of this change is significant enough to suggest that there has been a transformation of some sort as shown in the part of the review that follows. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 186 The initial reactions to the emergence of the correspondence!System of instruction, in spite of a-growing army of its clientele revolve around the perceived inadequacies considered inherent in the system while others revolve around the possible sharp practices of its prorietors and other institu- tional providers. William Rainey Harper, in one of his earliest essays on the use of correspondence education listed the following as disadvantages usually voiced by the antagonists of the system: 1 i. lack of the personal magnetism of the instructor in a face-to-face setting; ii. the lack of a certain'class spirit of emulation; iii. the missing hints a regular face-to-face teacher will drop; iv. the general irregularity in the mode of attendance plus the high drop- out rate; v. the possibility of dishonesty on the part of correspondence students; 1. William PaineyHarper, "The System of Correspcndence"in 'TheChangingWorld of Corresp?nci3ncSetudy Ope cit. pp. 9-11. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 187 In Britain, where such corr~spondence colleges as the Rapid Results College, .Pitman's Skerry's, Foulks Lyn(:::ht,he Wolsey Hall, the International Correspond- ence Schools and the University Correspondenc~ Colleges held sway as pioneer school~,:th~y were mostly at the initial stages, distanced as purely commercial concerns. 1 For a long time, they were not con.s Lde red worthy of government assistance. Committees later set up to examine the existing situations of such correspondence educational institutions came up with scathing remarks on the practices in the field. Some of these were the Carr-Sau~ders Committee (on education for commerce) , which disapproved of postal tuition; the Crowther Committee set up in 1959 which complained of the "lack of opportunity for the free and spontaneous interplay of mind on mind"2 while the Robb i.n s Committee cri t.Lc Lse d the system for its II lack of humanistic breadth ". Another individual commentator, Milerson, as reported by Glatter and 1. Ron Glatter and E.G. Wedell, Study by Correspondence London: Longman. 1971, p. 9: . 2. ibid, pp. 8 & 9. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 188 Wede 11 notes: the reliance of qualifying associations on postal tuition arid evening classes has created a second order 'in higher educa tion. 1 Meanwhile, and in spite of these criticisms, "the number of students taking a correspondence course (in Britain at the time) is likely to be about 5000,000,,2. The emergence of the Open University in Britain, a major revolution in non-traditional educational provisions at the tertiary level had no less an attack. Indeed, the criticisms took a new dimension. Harold Wilson, the then head of the Labour Party on September 8, 1963 showed his interests in pursuing the establishment of the University of the Air3, the general tune of: reactions to the idea was described by v7alter Perry! the fifst Vice-Chancellor, as being highly critical. As' the editorial of The Time§ Educational Supplement of 13 September 1963 wrote: 1. ibid, p. 26. 2. ibid, p. 3 3. 'Ihiswas the originalnarreproposed for the British open Universityuntil the initialplan of emphaai.zdnq its rredi.a ccroponentw;as altered. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 189 How far is it really true that people are hindered by lac~ of facilities? If the resources that were to be poured on Mr. Wilson's pipe dream were to be spent on improving the schools, then more people would come out resolved to continuing learning. When this was done and the demand still unsatiated, then, and' not till then, will be the time for Mr. Wilson's imaginative leaps.1 Critics were later to see the Advisory Committee set up on the University of the Air as a "flash in the pan" an idea that "would soon be dropped like a hot potato". The Times Educational Supplement of March 4, 1966, after observing the points raised in the first white paper on the project notes: Mr. Wilson's pipe Dream of a University of the Air now adumbrated in a ~fuite Paper, as vague as it is un- substantial, is just the sort of cosy scheme that shows the socialists at the,ir ~ost endearing but~ impractical worst.iC. To make matters worse, even individuals who had had a stint with pursuing degree programmes through unconventional means raised some dust. Margaret 1. Quoted in Walter Perry, The Open University. Milton Kaynes: Open University Press, 1976, p.10. 2. Quoted in Walter Perry, op. cit. p. 18. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 190 Thatcher, the erstwhile Prime Minister of Britain, who was some point in the development of the Open University idea the Opposition Spokesman on Education, had suggested to the officers of the University, rather sarcastically, that perhaps their first main activities would be to offer courses on hobbies1. Thatcher had obtained an external degree from the University of London. In Japan, it was a different kind of opposition. The attempts in Japan to initiate the country's University of the Air met stiff opposition from the All Japan Association of Private Universities Correspondence Education.2 Sakamoto and Fujita observe a number of criticisms raised some of which are that:3 i. there is a doubt whether a University of the Air (a University without a campus) could function adequately as a research and educational institution; ii. major differences in operation between 1. ibid, 2. Takashi Sakamoto, and Kenji Funta, "The Present State of the Un~versity of the Air Project in Japan". Overseas Universities. 1980. 27 September. p. 28. 3. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 191 the University of the Air and University Correspondence Education will result in impediments to the development of University education. The observations made by Omolewa' of aspedts of the non-recognition accorded the alumni of correspondence education is also worthy of note. As far back as 1943, and sixteen years after the first Nigerian had received a B.A. degree by'correspondence, and others had followed suit, the 'Elliot Commission on Higher Education which was set up in West Africa had all the three West African nominations on the Commission being products of formal educational institutions.1 Also, while the University of London had opened its gates wide to Nigerians as far back as 1887 for those who wished to sit for the University's External Degree Examinations, it was not until 1977, some 90 years later that an act, in form of a decree specifically spelling out the policy of government on correspondence education was published. Also, one 1. Michael Omolewa, "Historical Antecedents of Distance Education in Nigeria, 1887-1960" Adult Education in Nigeria, 1982, Vol.7 Decernber.-~7 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 192 of the major reasons adduced by government (apart from that of finance) for the closure of the National open University was the fear of quality of provisions. The Head of a new military administration then that had sounded the death knell, noted in his first budgetary speech: 1 In spite of the various criticisms, the distance education system has come to be respected by many, with governments now relying on its provisions to meet national needs and objectives in this regard. A number of factors have raised the shift in paradigm in respect of the issue of quality of provisions. Some of these are: i. the growing number of associations of correspondence or distance education institutions coming together to promote better practice; ii. the setting up of accrediting agencies in respect of practice, and iii. the emphasis on the'use of the integrated model of distance education provisions by 1. Daily Times, 19 May 1984. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 193 universities engaged in the system such that the Senate of universities monitor the provisions; iv. the increase in the number of research activities and conferences by international bodies ~nd the establishment of network among practitioners. 3.8 SUMMARY Attempts to situate the origins of correspondence education in the world have shown some links with the classical times and also possible biblical' links in this regard. A more formal explanation relates to the 1728 advertisement in Boston in the United States and the Isaac Pitman experiment of 1840 when he sent instructions to his students by postcard. The eme rqenc e of trie syst era Late{-'became reported in other parts of Europe and Asia including France, Germany, Australia and the former Soviet Union. The significance of the University of London innovation in non-traditional provisions of tertiary education is a pointer to the 1969 emergence of the UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 194 Open University in Britain and the development of the integrated mode of di st.aric e education pro- visions. It also shows the antecedents of some of the support services in distance education that are now a development in correspondence education practices of old. Again, the London innovation is significant for its indirect promotion of correspondence education at the tertiary level in Nigeria as far back as 1887. The methods of instruction in correspondence education have undergone some transformation, from the earliest reliance on the mailing of instructions by post card to the use of course texts and to the use of newer technologies' of communication. Also, the use of support systems such as study groups, computer-mediated interaction have emerged. Face- to-face instruction have corne to be added as integral parts of major distance education provisions,especi.aLIy where such high technology is costly and incapable of meeting the client's needs. Newspapers which had also operated through their columns as instructional package avenues have UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 195 grown into big time correspondence schools. Media transformation in distance education has been highly noticeable especially in the addition to improved course texts, such paraphernalia of instructional communication channels as the audio and video tapes; the radio, television, cable T.V.; teleconferencing" (whether video or audio-graphics) and the use of satellite systems to transmit information. Also there is the use of computers to store student information and carry out teaching and learning. The need to ensure two-way communication has been greatly enhanced through these media, and other ways of promoting interaction are already being experimented, even in the developing nations. On the issue of quality of instruction, the reaction to the emergence of correspondence education, by governments and other individuals, which had taken on a critical bent appears to'have undergone some transformation. The need to meet up with enormous educational plans by government; the awareness of the existing in~built mechanisms for monitoring quality UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 196 in the system; the recognition by individuals and governments that there is the need to build a learning society; and the recognition of the untapped potential of man's developed available technology of communication appear· to have led to a transformation in thinking along the line of accepting distance educa tion qua lity. • '1 ; i UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY CHAPTER FOUR HETHODOLOGY ,. 4.1 INTRODUCTION The adoption of the historical research method for this study has its parallels in related studies on distance education carried out in the past. The various works of Omolewa 1 which eventually became a model in Namie's doctoral study on the "University of London's Colonial Examinations in Mauritius, the Gold Coast and Ceylon from 1.9.00-1939" 2 are relevant examples. The Broady Lecture3 instituted by the International Council on Distance Education (ICDE) to honour Knute O. Broady and other works on develop- rrentsin the I:h."'ilndi.ts bulletins and reports, have benefitted tremendously from the use of the historical 1. Ornolewa's works are already variously cited in this research. 2. Yoshiko Namie, "University of London.'s Colonial Examinations in Mauritius, the Gold Coast and Ceylon from 1900-1939" Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis. Institute of Education, University of London, 1989. 3. The Broady Lecture ,was started by the ICDE to commemorate Knute O. Broady's contribution as a pioneer in the development of correspondence education in the United States, and a past president of the ICDE. Report of the Thirteenth World Conference of ICDE. 1985. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 198 research method. The Correspondence Education Research project (CERP)1 in the USAwhose work Correspondence Instruction in the United States was later published in 1971, and O. Mackenzie and E. L. Christensen' edited work The Changing World of Correspondence Study2 also provide an insight. So also are Walter Perry's Open University3! and Postgate et al's Open Learning Syst.erns " otto Peter' s4 maj or theoretical idea s in distance o~ducation have emerged from his historical examinations of the industrial revolution era, and the attendant parallel characteristics which distance education and the industrial revolution era share. Issues like specialisation, division of labour, and bureaucratic norms are examples. It is thus not surprising 1. The CERPwas spc:nsoredby the AmericanCc:uncil in Education (ACE) and the National Ccmuissien en Accrediting (NCAa)nd suppor+ed by the Carnegie Corporat.i.cnof NewYork to examinewhat the Study of corre spondenceeducation is in the United States, howit functions and v..hatits po+errt.ieL nay be. See o. Mackenzie, E.L. Christensen and P.R. Rigby, Corresp::mdenceInstructien in the United States. op. cit. 2. O. M3.ckenzieand E.L. Christensen, op. 'cit. 3. cpen University is an account of its early years by the University's first Vice-Chancellor. See W:l.lterPerry, op. cit. 4. otto Peters, "Theoretical AspeCtsof Correspmdence Instruction in O. M3.ckenzieand E.L. Christenren (eds,) op. cit. p.221-228. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 199 that the major thesis of Peters is that distance education is "the most industrialised form of education". The use of the historical research method in correspondence education has resulted in its having four identifiable functions. ' These are: i. the explanation of the events that'have led to the emergence of the correspondence education as an educational method; ii. the explanation of the development of the system and the factors that have aided and shaped this development; iii. the projection of development given the present circumstances and practices; iv. the identification of major epoch~ in the fie ld. The present research was aimed at realisingsorreof these goals just identified within :the purview of the demands of the methods of historical research and the stated objectives of this study itself. Correspondence education, and its most modern form, distance education, have benefitted from the provisions of geography, sociology, economics) psychology and other knowledge areas, in the same way that history UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 200 has had a great link with these fields. Specifically, issues bordering on the distance to be bridged in drstance education; of learners' social isolation; of the factors of cost and educational technology; of the demands upon the pedagogical structures in correspondence education programmes all have· Lmp Li.c a t.i.on s for these subject areas, and for an evolutionary analysis of what their passages in time have been. Even within the historical contexts of such a study. there are implications for quantitative analysis of growing population of clientele and related issues. In this chapter, we shall therefore examine the sources of data for the study on transformation: the instruments for gathering the data; the moae of data analysis and verification of dates, events and personalities; as the methods, media and support services of distance education in Nigeria are explored within a span of sixty years. 4.2 SOURCES OF DATA The main sources of data in this study were: UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 201 i . the records of the activities of correspond- ence colleges in Nigeria available in the National Archivos Ibadan; ii. records of notices, reports and results of external examinations undertaken by Nigerians before, and since 1927, present in the same Archives; iii. reports of meetings of foreign and local correspondence colleges, especially the activities of the National Universities Extension Association of the U.S.A. mostly located in the Stevenson Bird Library of the Syracuse University, U.S.A. iv. the study guides, and course texts of the correspondence colleges and the University based distance education institutions based in Nigeria and overseas; v. government gazettes and decrees; vi. government educational plans and major policies e.g. the National Policy on Education and the Ashby Report; UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 202 vii. records at the Federal Ministry of Education on Correspondence and Distance Education; viii. Other relevant manuscripts Lx . various relevant publications on distance education, including th~ Internatiori~l Council for Distance Education (ICDE) Bulletins; x. books and other publications on coirespondence education, including those specially published by the Fern Universitat & ZIFF based in Germany; xi. minutes of meetings of the National Association of Accredited Correspondence Colleges in Nigeria; xii. relevant documents and publications of the National Home Study Council (NHSC) in Washington D.C., U.S.A. xiii. reports of Seminars, workshops, Conferences on Distance Education; xiv. books and other materials on distance education. 4 .3 DATA· GATHERING TOOLS Information Required The data gathering tools for this study were a i.iueu at obtaining the information related to: UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 203 i. the methods of teaching and learning in correspondence education in Nigeria from 1927 to 1987; ii. the media of instruction of correspondence education from 1927 to 1987; iii the nature of support services in the system and the related growth of face-to~face instruction within the period; iv. the emergence of distance education in Nigeria as it relates to some specific changes in the system of correspondence education; v. the development of the technological environment of distance education; vi. the growth of media systems; vii. the development of postal services and other forms of postal communication, including electronic forms of communication; viii. the growth in the number of clientele being served in distance e~ucation as a reflection of the development of the system; UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 204 ix. the perception of the proprietors and directors of correspondence education of the mode of change in various aspects of the system. Instruments Used (A) Tracer Study Qu~stionnaire ('TSQ i: The Tracer Study Questionnaire (TSQ) was a simple four-item instrument designed to ask various Nigerians to identify individuals in Nigeria who are stiil alive, and who had in the past, used the foreign correspondence colleges in Nigeria to undertake either their first degrees, or to pursue any other qualifica- tions, The specific time of such use fell within 1927-1987, the period of the ~tudy. The use of the TSQ (see Appendix 1) became necessary because of the dearth of information on such individuals and because most of the affected colleges have mostly sto~ped their operations in Nigeria for variou~ reasons.Amongth~se reasons are: i. the growth of formal education ii. the growth of local correspondence colleges; iii. the inability of students to pay the colleges' fees in foreign currency; iv. the existence of other cheaper avenues at home, 5ueh as evening classes and local exami- nation-boards. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 205 The main information required in the questionnaire were: i the name of the respondent; ii. his/her address; iii. names and addresses of individuals he/she was aware had used the foreign correspondence colleges in the past; iv. any other comments the respondent wished to pass. The information obtained from this preliminary study thus provided the basis for the interviews conducted with the various users of the foreign correspondence education system. Thus, a number of interview guides were designed. (B) Interview Gu:idel(AFCEII) The Interview Guide, the Alumnae of Foreign Correspondence Education Institutions Interview was : ' " ., I . designed to solicit responses from the subjects identified from the Tracer Study Questionnaire. The main issues raised in the interview ~ere (see Appendix 2). i. Name and address of respondent; ii. How respondent learnt about the specific foreign correspondence cOllege used; UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 206 iii. The qualification and work of the respondent at the time of the decision to use the college; • iv. Qualification sought at the end of the completion of programme; v. Method and media of instruction; vi. Nature of two~way communication and i.nteraction; vii. Nature of support systems and quality of instruction; viii. Problems faced during the course of study (See Appendices 2 and 4 for the Interview Guide and those actually interviewed respectively.) (C) Interview Guide II (SCEII) A modified form of the first Interview Guide, Students of Correspondence ~ducation Institutions Interview (SCEII) was also designed and used for selected students undergoing the University of Ibadan External Studies Programme, the Correspondence and Open Studies Institute and the National Teachers Institute, (see Appendix 3). The same issues as in the Interview Guide I were raised excep t; that this was now done with the realisation that these were current students in the programmes identified. There were a few cases, as in the COSIT students identified where UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 207 a student had completed his course of study. It was easy to switch the tenses in the questions asked to reflect a past activity being examined. (D) Interview Guide III (ADCElI) A third Interview Guide, t.he Administrators and Directors of Correspondence Ed~cation Institutions Interview, (ADCEII) was also designed to solicit information on their institutions on the issues of programme of study, clientele, method and med~a of instruction, nature of two-way communication and support services. A list of those interviewed is shown in Appendix 4. (E) Other M~thods of Gathering Data In ~ddition to the formal interviews already discussed, there were a lot of on-the-spot interviews conducted with various individuals, distance education scholars and practitioners, government officials and personnel of correspondence education institutions whose names feature in the footnotes that adorn this study. There were also visits and direct observations made to verif y some of the issues already discussed by respondents in the various interviews. Various UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 208 newspapers such as The Guardian and the Daily Times were also used. 4.4 ANALYSIS OF DATA The data collected were analysed through a system of content analysis whibh benefits from both external and internal criticism. Facts and evidences collected were validated through a synthesis with supplementary sources such as the examination of records and documents. Quantitative evidence was also qualitatively analysed. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY CHAPTER FIVE 5.0 THE ERA OF FOREIGN CORRESPONDENCE COLLEGES IN NIGERIA This chapter examines the emergence of correspondence .education in Ni0eria,.R phenome- non championed by foreign Correspondence COlleges. In it, a review of the developments in correspondence education before the first alumnus of the system was recorded is done. The events discussed date back as early as 1887 when the University of London Opened its gates for the first time for Nigerian private candidates to write its examinations. Soon, the foreign corresporidence colleges started meeting the needs of a wider category of clientele including those studying for degrees aI.1d such secondary school certificate examinations as the General Certificate of Education. The hegemony of foreign correspondence colleges continued until the 60's, when, after independence, successful local correspondence colleges emerged. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 210 5.1.1 BEFORE 1927: AN EMERGING INNOVATION THROUGH EXTERNAL EXAMINATIONS The practice by Nigerians, of participating in external examinations conducted by bodies and other institutions outside Nigeria, preceeded theemergemce of correspondence education as a distinct method of receiving instruction. In another vein, the coming of external examinations made the determination of the choice of methods of instruction, the media of instruction, the issue of support services and pattern of two-way interaction between the earliest Nigerian students of correspo~dence education and their institutional provider~ of education a second- priority phenomenon. However, in spite of the British orientation of the external examinations, both in contextual and social relevance, the overall quality of correspondenc e educa t Lon provisions was , . ~: . I . . comparable to what operated in Britain. At another lev~l the factors of distance, manifested at the physical, social and pedagogical levels, affected the performance of Nigerian candidates in the external examinations at their inception. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 2 11 Among the major external examinations in Nigeria were those of London University, Cambridge University and those of the Oxford University Delegacy. First we shall examine the case of the University of London. with the University of London undertaking to extend its examination services overseas, the road was opened to many Nigerians to benefit from its provisions. The original title given to the Examinations was "Colonial examinations" but this was later changed to "Colonial and Indian Examinations" 1. The condition upon which such examinations could be held was that applications for such examinations must come through the Department of, Education in Nigeria or from any other person appointed for the purpose by the coLon i.a L government. According to Omolewa, the reason fqr this step was.i.t.poromot.etheva:j..ues and standards of the examin~tions. Also added was the proviso that the supervision of such examinations be done by the Director of Education or any other person so appointed by him. 1. M. Omolewa, "The Promotion of London University Examinations in Nigeria, 1887-1951". The International Journal of African Historical Studies, (IJAHS) 13, 4 (1980) p.653. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 212 The London University examinations were in three sections. The first v..us the matricula tion examinations which those preparing for its degree had to first pass. It W3.S in a way a kind of introductory examination. The examination was designed to "test the candidates' power of expression, thought and command of English. ,,1The paper on language included an essay, a passage which students have to paraphrase and general reading and knowledge of English. other subjects which students were supposed to choose from are:2 Group 2 Elementary Hathematics Group 3 Latin or Greek or Botany or Chemistry or Heat and Light and Sound Group 4 Latin, Greek, Italian, French, Spanish, Welsh, German, Russian, History, Geography, Logic, Chemistry. Once candidates have satisfied examiners in the matriculation examinations, they proceeded to do the intermediate examinations, the second in the 1. Omolewa, "London Un ive rsity I sEarl iest Examina tions in Nigeria" WAJE, p. 348 2. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 213 series of the London University examinations. Later students can move on to do the Ba~helor of Arts and Bachelor of Philosophy examinations. While, the London University examinations were geared towards the obtainancaof' university education by Nigerians, the introduction of the cambridge University Local Examinations promoted the development of secondary education. The initial goal of the Cambridge University's in promoting secondary school level examinations was to help develop schools for the middle classes in Britain. The various classes of examinations were the preliminary, junior and senior categories of students. As Omolewa reports: 1 'A' Forms were qistributed for Preliminary candidates under 14; 'B' Forms for Preliminary candidates over 14; 'c' Forms for Junior candidates under 16~ 'D' Forms for Junior candidates above 16; 'E' Forms for Senior candidates under 19; and 'F' forms for Senior candidates above 19. By December 1910, the G:ambridge Uni ver sity Syndicate for Local Examinations had conducted the 1. M. Omolewa, "The Cambridge University Local Examinations Syndicate and the Development of Secondary Education in Nigeria, 1910-1926" Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria, Vol. III, No.14, June 1977, p.113. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 214 first Preliminary Examination in Lagos where two candidates were tested in Religious Knowledge, English, History, Geography, Geometry and Algebra. These were all compulsory subjects. Of the Junior examination, seven candidates entered and they were examined in Religious Knowledge, English, History, Geography, Latin, French, Mathematics, Chemistry, Drawing and Music which were compulsory subjects. Among the schools which presented candidates for the examinations were King's College, C.M.S. Grammar School, Wesleyan Boys' High School, Eko Boys High School and St. Gregory's Grammar School, all in Lagos, and Abeokuta Grammar School and Hope Waddell Training Institute in Calabar.1 The third British-oriented examining body is the Oxford University Delegacy of Local Examinations which also promoted Secondary education in Nigeria from 1929 to 1937. Unlike the other bodies, its own activities in Nigeria started after 1927, but again unlike the others, it was the first of such examining 1. M. Omolewa, ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 215 bodies to be inaugurated in England. The passing of t.h e statue was done in 18 June 1857 while those of Cambridge had come on February 11, 1858 and that of London also in 1858.1 Many other countries such as South Africa, India, Jamaica, Mauritus, Natal, Penang, Singapore, Trinidad, Bengal and Barbados had enjoyed these facilities. with approval given to conduct the examinations in Nigeria, two centres were then approved by the Delegacy. They were King's College (for the July examinations) and a second one also in Lagos for the December examinations. The curriculum followed for the examinations did not depart from those of Cambridge and the Secondary school curriculum being operated in the country. The classification of the levels of~xaminations also followed pattern of Cambridge's with the Preliminary, Junior and Senidr Local Examinations conducted. 1. M. Omolewa, ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 216 5.1.2. THE NATURE OF ENTRY AND THE CATEGORIES OF CLIENTELE The nature of entry of external examinations as the first form of correspondence education provisions is quite significant. First, the examinations came through colonial providence. Second, the pattern of development of traditional universities and the new social responsibilities they were taking up in Britain, including the diffusion of such practices, made the emergence of this form of examinations to Nigeria possible. Third, the university exporters of the examinations were aware of the royal benefits derivable from the export- ation of the British academic tradition to the country's colonies and thus promoted it. Fourth, it was also a case study of t.h'e colonisation of the fragments of the emerging African curriculum in the educational process in Nigeria. Everything about the entry of the examinations, apart from the issues just raised pointed to the need on the part of Nigerians, and those at the helm of educational affairs to allow such provisions. In the case of the London University, the non-existence of available facilities for university education in UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 217 Nigeria at the time and the inability of the Fourah Bay College to satisfy the qualitative and quantitative aspects of the yearnings at this time made London University entrance a much needed succour. It was therefore not surprising to have Nigerians clamouring for the examinations and indeed writing same as early as 1887. The Oxford Delegacy and the Cambridge Syndicate examinations could not have come at a better time, considering the fact that no other body was responsible at the time to help assess the quality of the secondary educational provisions on the basis of comparability with the academic traditions elsewhere. Again, the apparen t prol ifera tion of examining bodie sat the time, which the coming of this trio engendered was to lay the foundation for the issue of ensuring standards, and al so promoting. some form.of -e.ga litarianism in the liberal traditions of all educational ventures meant to make democratisation of educational facili~ies, and indeed examination facilities possible. Secondary school education was thus promoted. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 218 The categories of clientele for the external examinations were representative. of, each of the two groups of examinations taken. For the London university examinations, these were those artisans, clerks and others who had had some level of education com- parable to secondary school qnd teacher training who needed some avenue to go to the university but who could not travel abroad. The London University thus provided the opportunity for them for this purpose. Also most of them were private candidates whose goal was to break off the shackles of lack of continuity in formal educational provisions. For the Oxford and Cambridge examinations, most were in secondary schools while some were private candidates in employment and those who had registered with the correspondence colleges. 5.1. 3. METHODS OF INSTRUCTION A comprehensive description of the methods of instruction during the period of external examinations is in a way, an examination of methods of instruction operatiDg in the formal school system at th9 time in I igeria. Although there are reports of a number of UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 219 non-formal provisions as the likes of continuing education classes set up by private initiatives and arnumbe r of scattered cases in Lagos, it is appropriate to 'ateyorise the earliest instructional patterns within the practices existing in formal educational provisions. This is because the only provisions initially available at this time was the use of the same conventional ',')~hooilnsthe even.irxfjor t.he purposesof orga;,s)ing continuingeduca- r.aon lasses ror workers, Correspondence.iriat.ruc t: ('1· 1;olM2vecrarrelater. Basic to the methods of instruction at this time was the use of the face-to-face approach to teaching and learning in which the teacher stayed in front of the pupils and taught his subjects. This approach followed an ideniifiable pattern: i. Teacher prepared his lesson notes. ii. Teacher presented the facts, knowledge skills in class. 1i.i. 'reacher allO\\edfor some dialogue with the students. iv. Teacher gave the students notes to write and assignments to do. v , These assicmme nt s were marked in the class while their corrections were done. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 220 vi. other assignments to take home were given. vii. The class meeting ended and pupils looked forward to the next meeting. viii. Before departure, references for further reading were given 5.1 .4 The Hedia of Instruction In an article on a return to resourcefulness in teaching, published as part of a National Symposium contribution on the 'Problems and Prospects of Educational Technology in Nigeria, Obanya, nostalgically reflects on the pre-independence media situation in prl.mary and secon dary sch001s at th'e tlme: 1 It was rare to see empty classroom in those days. Teachers in charge of standard four taught the Geography of Nigeria. Immediately a topic was treated, appropriate maps were up on the walls made by the class teacher who was proud to append his signature on them. By the end of the year, any visitor to the class could see at a glance that the class had learnt the physical features, the vegetation and rainfall belts, the main channels of communicatlon by land and water, the agricultural products and minerals of the country. The same was teue of the teacher of Geography of Africa in Standard five. The teacher of Hygiene and Nature Study would assist pupils to filter impure water .. 1. P2:LCoanya, "'Ibwardas Retum to Resoorcefulness1.1'] Teachi g" in A. O::Junra.'iti (ed) Prcblemsand Prospe::;ts of Educationtechnologyin Nigeria. Thaaan:Hemerrann. 1988, p. 16 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 221 The thinking of Obanya captured in the quotation best illustrates the nature of media input into the instructional delivery that aided students' success in the external examinations which they did. Media was seen ba sLcal ly in terms of supporting resources to aid learning and not as self-contained materials that was the instructional package itself. There were at the 'initial stage no'corresp- ondence text back-ups for the students, and even private candidates initially depended on the syllabuses of the various subjects and the books they bought in bookshops to aid further reading. As Omolewa reports, the firms of Macmillan, Longmans, Blackie/ Percy Young and Bell had 'started informing readers about books suitable for passing London university e xami,.na t'aon s , 1 The eatly 1900's however witnessed a change in this regard. By this peri6d, the University Correspondence College and Wolsey Hall Oxford had started operating in the country. Private candidates thus started registering for their course and this added another dimension to both the method and media 1 • M. Omolewa, I JAH S. 13, 4 (198 0) p . 6 54. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 222 of sitting for the external examinations. As Ezewu, now Professor and a former lecturer at the University or Ibadan's Faculty of Education notes, the Wolsey Hall sent materials to students and this was got early. 1 5.1.5 Nature of Support Services Apart from the assistance the Education Department gave in terms of ensuring that the examinations were coordinated, and results released sent to the affected students, very little existed in terms of support services. Again, support also came from relatives and well wishers by way of allowing the candidates taking part in the programmes ample time to plan their lives the way they wanted. Of this phenomenon, it was observed that the first alumni of correspondence Bducation in Nigeria married late2. The only other support: got was in the comments given in the assignments or the candidates by the correspondence colleges as well as the advice generally given on how to succeed in the programme. 1/ Interviewwith Prof. E.E. Ezewu who passed the G.e.E. '0'Level and 'A' level thrcugh the use of W::>lseHyail b.liticn, 24/10/91 at the Banquet Hall, Universityof Benin. 2. MichaelQrolewa, "HistoricalAntecedentsof DistanceEducation in Nigeria, 1887-1960" Ope cit. p. 16. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 223 5.1.6 Pattern of Two-way Interaction There was some form of two-way interaction a~ this time in two respects. First the authorities of the University of London on the one hand interacted with the candidates through the Department of Education which in turn LlaLsed with the various centres, first in Lagos, and later in Calabar and Ijebu-Ode. Also, the candidates had a direct link with the institutional providers of correspond- ence education who relied solely on the existing postal system to communicate information. There was no record whatsoever of the use of audio or any other means of communicating information. There were no face-to-face- sessions organised by the colleges at this point. 5.1 .7 Issues.of Quality and QUUt\tity The number of students; involved in the correspondence education provisions at this time was extremely limited. As Omolewa notes of the London University examl.na t'lons; 1 1 • Michael Ornolewa, "Historical Antecedent,s " op. cit. p. 18 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 224 Up till 1923, for example, Nigeria offered an average of 4 candi~~tes Sierra Leone. 3 and Ghana 2 i In 1887, only one candidate sat for the Intermediate Examination in Arts while another one put in,for . 1 the B.A. Examination in 1888. Both failed. Two sat the Matriculation and Intermediate Arts Examinations in 1889 and passed. In June 1890, the two candidates who sat for The Matriculation Exami- nations failed while the only one who attempted the January 1892 examinations also failed. 2 The result was not different for the two Nigerian candidates who sat the January Matriculation Exami- nation in 1893. The June 1894 Matriculation Examinations recorded two Nigerian passes while more failures, in trickles were recorded in the following years. In 1898, Nigeria's sole candidate in the June Matr:l.culationExa~ination failed. By 1905, the Intermediate Examination candidate ~.nDivinity.hadalso failed. From 191.2 onwards, 1. Michael Omolewa, "London University's Earliest Examinations in Nigeria, 1887-1931" ~AJE, No.2, 1 9 76 • Vol. XX . p. 352 . 2 . ib i d. p. 353 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 225 school candidates started enrolling for the examinations King's College first three candidates of 1912, for the matriculations examinations were not successful Of the results throughout the period, Omolewa notes that they were .generally poor. 1 It would be noticed that before 1912 when school candidates began to enter for the examinations, all the candidates who enrolled had relied on corresp~ ondence education colleges or some other non_formal educational arrangements -One of the hardships they then faced was the problem of distance from both the physical, pedagogical and cultural perspectives~ Apart from the fact that the examinations were British oriented, there was no provision of support services in form of face~to-face elements of teaching and learning. This in effect affected the number of those interested as the number was generally few and far between at this peri'6d•• Aiso, white the quality of instruction could be said to be high, as the examinations were replicas of local examinations 1. Michael Omolewa, "London University's Earliest Examinations in Nigeria, 1887~1931" Ope cit. p. 354. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 226 set for British candidates; the Nigerian candidates had problems coping with the demands of the examiners, thus leading to the failure rate highlighted. 5.1.8 Summary The emergence of correspondence education in Nigeria through what has been aptly described as a circuitous entry has been seen through the activiti~s of the London University whose examination gates were opened to the then colony as from 1887. The level of provisions at this time was the tertiary one which London engaged in through its Matriculation, Intermedia te and Degree examinations. In the same manner, the Cambridge University provided the secondary school level examinations. While these Universities thus provided examinations, the correspondence colleges provided the instruction. But both examinations and instruction were as removed from the point of view of the Socio-Cultural milieu of the Nigerian candidates as they were from the physical realm. However, in the case of the Cambridge examination, existing secondary schools were able to prepare many of the candidates. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 227 While the iflLtidlncri.hods of instruction~:n a corrtxina tion of the face-to-face lectures which individuals got from identified tutors around, on a personal arrangement basis, or from their real tutors in schools, the coming of correspondence colleges made correspondence education the main method of instruction fo~ the private candidates. This again had its problems because of the socia-cultural background of the course text writers which was removed from that of the learners although there was the advantage of the sameness of background of both instructors (the colleges) and the examiners (the London University) . The medium of instruction was mainly print which the use of the course text promoted while the nature of two-way interaction depended solely on the use of the postal system which was quite efficient. For the candidates from sC~ools, the face-to-face instruction was used. Even in Britain, the medium of instruction in correspondence education had not undergone any major transformation apart from the §ne that shifted the practice from the use of hand- written post cards in Pitman's days to the use of UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 228 prepared course materials. Quality was not in doubt at this stage even tirough there was no presence of an accrediting body at the time. Nigerians who were the clientele of the correspondence colleges "and who sat the London university examinations did not find it easy to pass the examinations. Even when their counterparts from the schools joined them as from 1912, the situation did not change significantly. The road had however become opened for, in addition to private individuals who were mostly clerks, teachers and other civil servants, a new army of secondary school students joining the list of candidates. 5.2. 1927-1947: ENTRANCE OF THE ALUMNI AND THE CONTINUATION OF EXTERNAL EXAMINATIONS . . The period 1927-1947 was one in which further developments were recorded in the participation of Nigerians in external examinations, espec~ally after the coming of the first alumni of the system. The close of this period imIhediately prec::eededthe emergence of the University"College Ibadan, where UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 229 even as a local Universi ty, Nigerian students continued to write the examinations of the University of London. 5.2.1 The coming of the Alumni, The year 1927 was significant in the annals of correspondence education history in Nigeria. This was because in that year, the first Nigerian alumn+s of correspondence education, Mr. E.O. Ajayi, bagged his B.A. degree examination in, Philosophy in the Third Class.1 Indeed, two years before 1927, one Eyo Ita and another Hezekiah Olagunju Oladipo Davies had successfully passed their London Matriculation Examinations. The same year had witnessed Ajayi's passing of his Intermediate Arts Examination. Thus in 1927 still, Alvan Ikoku passed his Intermediate Arts degree while he later, in 1929 bagged his B.A. degree in Philosophy. By 1933, S. A. Banjo had also bagged his B.A. degree in Philosophy.2 The coming of the alumni gave the impetus to the fact that in spite of the distance, Nigerians could 1 . Michae I Omolewa, "Historical An tecenden ts " op. cit., p.15 2. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 230 excel. Incidentally, no other remarkable transformation, "- especially along the line o~ method, and media s~pport took place at this time. It is right to observe that the courses offered by Niger·ians at this time were generally in the area of the Arts, or what others regard as the less arduous areas. It would be observed that the Oxford University Delegacy of Examinations carne up later in 19.29, to promote the growth of secondary schools through its external examinations. Thus while more Nigerians became keen on bagging degrees through the University of London Examinations, others in the schools continued to find the Oxford examinations relevant. This was especially so against the backdrop of Cambridge's performance up till 1926, when the latter became the model for secondary school syllabus and standard in the country. The pattern of continuity therefore at this period was the continued reliance on external examinations, which many private candidates as well as those in secondary schools depended upon to fulfil their life ambitions. Neither the curriculum nor the direction of the Oxford examinations Changed from UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 231 what Cambridge was offering. However, by some working o:fr;fatet,he Cambridge examinations outlived the Oxford University Delegacy examinations when the latter came to a close in 1937. 5.2.2 Growth of Media of Instruction The current of correspondence education no doubt reached a height in 1927 with the coming of the first aLumnus , However, some five years later, the coming of the first radio signified' not only a boost in entertainment avenues for Nigerians but also an opportunity for a greater audience to be reached through the new medium in the area of education. An examination of the activities of radio stations in Nigeria did not show much link with correspondence education work. With the advent of the colonial radio in 1932, modern media development had taken root. This later led to :.the era of radio educa +Lon which took its cue from the Nigerian Broadcasting Service (NBS) whose educational programme was a once-in-a-week affair. This situation continued until 1957 when UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 232 tl:eNigerianBroadcastingeorp:>ratiocnarreinto being. It shouldbe noted in 1933, the British Broadcasting Corporation in London had transmitted its first educational programme in its West African Overseas Service.1 Just after the transmission, an articl~had appeared irtthe Nigerian Teacher (a teacher's journal) in which the government was urged to introduce educational radio into schools in the country. There was no evidence of the government having taken an action then as there was move in the case of correspondence colleges. It was therefore not until '1955 when after requests for the establishment of 'School's Broadcasting' in Nigeria had reached some level that the Nigerian Bradcasting Service (NBS) ,invited one Mr. Richmond Postgate to look into such a possibility.2 As Nwamadi observes, even though the Po s.t qat.e Report, after favouring such a move ,;considered' the'cost, high thus making implementation difficult, it could still be aptly described as the beginning of educational 1. C.O. Nwamadi, "The Future of Educational Broadcasting in Nigeria" Ayo Ogunranti (ed.) Problems and Prospects of Educational Technology in Nigeria. Ibadan: Heinemann Educational Books. 1988, p. 256. 2. See NAI/MED/ (FED)"Reportof R.S. Postgate,BBC, to the Federal Adviser on Education,12thAugust, 1955". UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 233 technology in Nigeria. 1 A number of regional government Ministries of Education later went ahead all the same to utilize existing media facilities to transmit instruction to schools. All this while still, correspondence education took a backseat in the use of radio for instructional purposes. The reasons for the non application of radio faci- lities by correspondence education Ln s t.Lt.u t Lon at this time are two-fold. First, the main colleges at this time were still operating from the home bases in the United Kingdom and had not in their own initiated any shift in their tradition of relying on the print medium. Even in the U.K. the British Broadcasting Corpo- ra tion, had ·,-,nlya s early 'as 1926 considered the possib.i.Li.ty of promoting adult educational programmes by air.2 Another reason was the cost that would have been involved especially for the'clien;.t.ele at the tim.e and even the provider of correspondence edu~ation, who would have had to pay for such services in Britain. No evidence abounds of any other private providers 1. C. o. Nwamadi, op. cit. p. 256. 2. Walter Perry, Open Universi!y. Milton Keynes: Open University Press. 1976. p.5 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 234 of correspondence education anywhere in the world at this time making such thrusts in provisions. Meanwhile, existing newspapers like the Lagos Daily News were used in advertis~ng closing dates for various examinations which candidates wanted to offer. There were no pedagogical uses made of the newspapers, a phenomenon that was the hallmark of the Internation~Correspondence Schools in Scranton U-S-A when it first started. 5.2.3 Nature of Support Services Support services at this stage still came in the form of letters and course materials sent to the learners as well as the support given by the relatives and friends who were not averse to the decision by most clients to pursue their educational dreams using the novel s~stem of instruction. Also, the examin~ng bodies whose examinations were taken at this time, notably the Oxford University Delegacy of Local Exami- nations and the London University, in conjunction with the Department of Education continued to make some prDvisions for the candidates. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 235 Many of those who took part in the examinations as students of various secondary schools had the o~portunity of being advised directly by their teachers and principals. Als~ libraries were available for their use and it was not su rpris i.nq that they performed better in the examinations than the purely private candidates. 1 5.2.4 Issues of Quality and Quantity The coming of the Oxford University Delegacy of Local Examinations as from 1929 was a development on the use of external examinations to ascertain and raise the standard of secondary school education in Nigeria as engaged in by the Cambridge University Local Examinations Syndicate as from 1910. On the issue of quality in Nigerian Secondary Schools at the time, E.G. Rowden, the Director of Education had lamented: The so-called secondary schools which are really higher standards of the Primary schools, offer what are called state subjects such as Algebra, 1. This evidence is clear in Michael Omolewa's works. See M. Omolewa, "Oxford University Delegacy of Local Examinations and Secondary Education in Nigeria, 1929-1937." Journal of Educational Administration and History. July 1978. vol.X-- No.2, p.43. UNIVE SITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 236 Geometry, English, Literature, Book-Keeping, Physiology, and French. The standard attained in these subjects varies very much according to the class of school, but in only few instances is the work character- ised as good. This was then one of the major reasons why the external examinations were considered necessary in promoting standard. Thus like Cambridge, Oxford also joined the external examination race in 1929. While as far back as July 1929 when Oxford's examinations were first held, only two schools and twelve students were presented, in 1937, there were entries from eight schools and a total of about ninety students1. Private candidates were also actively involved in the examinations but their performance, against that of the King's College entries was low (see Table 3 ~).2 Even the two candidates presented by correspondence colleges failed. 1. Michael Omolewa, "Oxford University .... 1929-1937" Ope cit. p. .43 2. Source: ibid, p. 43 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 237 Table PERFDRMl\NCOEF 'IHENIGERIANS'IUDENl'SAT 'IRE DEX:EMBE1R937 SGICDLCERTIFICATEEXAMINATIONS Schcx:>l ();..nership No of No of Passes % Passes Candi.dat.es King's College Government '17 15 88.2 William Wilberforce Academy Private 8 2 25.0 Evening Collegiate College Private 1 0 0 Wolsey Hall Private Ehglish Corres- pondence College 1 0 0 BEnnett Colleg= Sheffield Private (as above) 1 0 .- 0 Source: Michael Omolewa, "Oxford University Delegacy of Local Examinations and Secondary Education in Nigeria, 1929=1937". Jf~urnal of Educational ~dministration and History Vol X No.2, 1978, July. p.43 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 238 The state of affairs for private and corresp- dence college candidates in'the examinations was rough rrD doubt but this did not remove the quality and the mark of respectability which was bestowed on those who passed by the nature o£ the Certificate~ Indeed, universi ties were seen to e'asily accept them "as qualifying examinations for entrance". Many of the successful candidates ,also had exemptions from the professional examinations of these bodies. Among these were the Institute of Engineers, the Royal College of Veterlnary Surgeons and many others. Other successful candidates moved on to register for the University of London external examina tion s. 5.2.5 Pattern of two-wav.. Communication Two-way Communication at this period still was by the use of letters sent to the clientele via the colonial post office. As earlier reported, the delivery system was fast, which was a p'Lus for the government. This was however not a reflection of government's peculiar interest in the activities UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 239 of the correspondence colleges but a natural reaction of the environment to happenings within it. The emergence of the radio in 1932 had no effect on the two-way communication-system between the institutional providers 0'£ adan raised was the re lative ly low number of entrants it could take a year. Where more than a thousand applicants applied, it could not take more than 300. This was 1. ibid. 2. ibid. 3. C.O. Taiwo, ..The Nig~rian Education System: Past, Present and Future" Ikeja: Thomas Nelson (Nigeria) Limited. 1980, p.96. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 249 therefore one of the issues the Ashby Commission raised in its 1960 published report. Ibadan's emergence did not therefore kill the impetus of peo~le for higher education through the correspondence system of instruction. It has indeed been observed that as far back as 1956, a lot of thought had been given to the issue of the university organising degree programmes for external or non-residence based students. The University, from available information, may have been restrained in this respect. A possible reason for this could also have been the perception by the authorities in London that Ibadan was itself a centre of an external unit, and ,as such may not be too qualified to give out what it itself has not fully acquired. This argument however appears to have been the least of considera~ions in!the late 1980's when , most affiliated colleges of Education (to other universities) and even universities just struggling to break free of heavy elements of'external moderation of their academic activities started organising sand-wich, part-time, week-end and some form of distance education programmes or the other. However, that UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 250 Ibadan eventually started an external studies programme later shows that the dream was not per- manently deferred. Another tradition which Ibadan had at its independence and which seemed to have prepared it for the position of organising a distance education programme was the nature of its extra-mural provisions from 1949, through the then Department of Extra- Mural Studies. Representing . a ' philosophy of creating the room for linking the theoretical "Gown" with practica 1 "town" Ibadan' s aspirations in this regard was to organise a lot of training programmes both of a long-term duration and short_term to ensure that those who missed out in education have the opportunity of achieving both a mastery in scholarship as well as some relevance in their imm~dia te society. Ibadan 's .suce.ess in this regard , even to the extent of replicat:i,.ngits degree programme on an external basis appears to have had the found- ations laid in its early years.1 1. For an extensive examination of this outreach philosophy, see J. A.,Akinpelu and M.A. Omo Lewa (eds.) Adult Education at Ibadan. Department of Adult Educa tion , University of-Ibadan. 1989. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 251 The University College Ibadan thus provided some kind of transition from an outright situation of the acquiSition of degrees by external examinations by many Nigerians to one of acquisition of same degrees by a new kind of external examinations, relying sOlely though, on the experience, tutelage, tutoring of Nigerian and foreign lecturers, located within a physical setting that is Nigeria, and against the backdrop of local elements of the syllabus as considered necessary by the appropriate academic authorities. Some of the special character- istics which the University College Ibadan displayed were those of : L) a local university affiliated to a British university, and which awards the degree of the university of London (in this case,it was peculiar). ii) a university whose students still wrote the examinations of the University of London (in this case, one that continues the phenomenon of degree by examination) • iii) a university whose students attended classes in Nigeria only to write outside examinations UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 252 (in this case, it continued the traditions of King' s College, .an d other secondary schools that relied on the ,Cambridge and Oxford University Examinations for some time to authenticate 'their standard) . iv) a transitional stage between degrees by external examination and degree by purely local examinations. While the University College Ibadan represented a transition as suggested, it could not, by the level of its output, satisfy the demands of both the lower educational system as well as the manpower needs of the country. This was a major finding of the Ashby Commission as contained in its report published in 1960.1 It therefore did not stop the clamour for the use of the Correspondence System of instruction to obtain degrees lpy Nigerians. Another , , reason given for the continued use of the external facilities of the University of London, even after the University College Ibadan's establishment, was 1 . This issue has been raised in a later section of the thesis. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 253 by the fact that most entrants to Ibadan were sponsored and thus had to go back to the sponsoring missions o~ community schools as teachers to serve for some years before proceeding to other places. The fear of signing such bonds that, would make them teachers against their wish forced others to try the correspond- ence route. 1 5.3.2 rhe Emergence of Television While radio broadcasting was introduced to Nigeria through the advent of the colonial radio in 1932, television did not emerge until some twenty seven years later, specifically in 1959, on the eve of the nation's indep~ndence. With what was described as a modest beginning ina building near Mapo Hall, and with one of its two transmitters located near the ha Ll, , .and the:other in Abafup, near Lagos, the television was officially comm LssLoned on 31 October 1959 as the first television station in Black Africa.~ 1. .This W3.S the reason qivs-n by Chief M.S Adigun for his lack of inl:('n'sitn attenrh:ngthe Uni.vesri.ty 0;IIege, Ibadan,thus ustncrthe tortt.:oursoute of the uee 2.~ 20th AnniversaryHistory of the W'l'J.V Thadan HeinemannEducationalBcx::k(sNig)Ltd 1979, p.4 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 254 Soon, other regions followed suit with the Government of the former Eastern ~egion setting up the Eastern Nigeria Television (now NTA Enugu) , the Northern Regional Government setting up the ~adio Nigeria Television in 1962 which'later metamophorsed into the FRCN and the NTA Kadtina.1 To date,the country has established a total number of 38 functional stations, of which the 14 are owned by various state governments. Also, the television industry has, within the period, acquired a total of 72 trans- mitters, 56 of which belong to the NTA and 16 to the states. 2 Writing on this development further, the compilers of the 1992 Diary of the NTA note: These facilities have no doubt established Nigeria as Africa's largest Television network and ranks among t.heworld's biggest : Television Organisations broad~ casting about 85,000 hours of different programmes annually 1 . 1992 Diary of the NTA 2. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 255 Viewers have grown from a few thousands to a conserv~tive estimate of fifty million.1 Any look at the correspondence education component or use of publtc t~l~vislori in Ni~e~ia would begin with the examination of the educational television component of the nation's television services. The historical document on the History of the WNTV reveals that at the initial stage, television sets were provided free for schools and colleges. 2 The aim was to ensure that the institutions benefittedfrom the school broadcasts. The form the provision here took was an indirect one which saw the WNTV and the Ministry of Education working in close collaboration. The Western Nigeria Ministry of Education, through ies broadcas t, unit. origina ted the pz oqramme s-twhf Le the WNTV provided the technical and production services.3 1. ibid 2. 20th Anniversary History of the WNTV. op. cit. p.7 3 . ibid, pp 41-42 . UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 256 Thus school prograffiffieisn Science, Geography, Engiish, Mathematics and other subjects were produced. These programmes, as Alalade observes, were meant to supplement the efforts of the classroom tea6~er.1 Copies of the teachers' guide for the programmes were sent in advance to the schools where the programmes were beamed. Quite a number of schools reserved special rooms for the T.V. lessons to be aired. However, the initial attempts in this regard were gradually reduced for what Alalade described as lack of financial backing, enthusiasm and technical expertise. Many of the teachers who were expected to have worked through the study guides sent considered the ETV phenomenon an extra burden. 2 Thus the ETV neriods became opportunities for t~achers and students alike to relax and do some other things. Even the visits usually 'planned for ,Ministry Offic,ials to monitor the effective viewing of such programmes in the schools became fewer and fewer until such visits grounded to a halt. with formal educational programmes easing off, educational programmes with a more general and informal Dutlook soon took centre-stage. Among 1. Interviewwith Mr. Bode Alalade,General Manager,NTI\. ChanneL 7, (Ikeja)on 25/5/92. 2. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 257 these were adult literacy agricultural extension services and other programmes on farming or gardening. One major addition was the emergence of the Community Viewing Centres started in 1980.1 Here, television sets are taken to identified community centres for the purpose of being viewed by the members. Various topics of community interest are identified and films on them shown to the members. The issues raised by the Ashby Commission of 1959 whose report, Investment in Education was later submitted in 1960 appears to have projected the role which television would play in educational programmes in Nigeria when in a chapter titled itANote on Educational Techniques," it observed. Television is already available for school use in some parts of 1. Memo from the General Manager (Projects) to the Director of Finance', NTA of 2nd July 1984 Ref. NANTA/ENA/28/83 .. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 258 Nigeria. It would seem to be time to undertake a series· of planned exper imen ts to di.scoverhow televisio~may be used rrore effectivelyand economicallyin Nigerian schools. It would be particularly interesting to experiment with its use in a limited area of one of the more remote sections of the country. 1 The report later went on to add: Channels for educational television should be reserved now, so that when educational television becomes practicable the opportunity will not have been lost by reason of the channels being appropriated by commercial companies. 2 The absence of channels for educational television , . in Nigeria appears to have been: a negation ~f 'this recommendation in spite of the initial thrusts made by the WNTV in collaboration with the Western Nigeria Ministry of Education. The later development of the Instructional Television Section of the NTA 1. Eric Ashby, Investrrenitn Education. FederalMinistryof Education, 1960. p. 125. 2. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 259 on Victoria Island, Lagos for a brief spell was just a mere flash in the pan. If the concept of epucational television is consiaered from the angle of the activities of a body such as the NHK (Nippon Hoso Kyoka L) in Japan, a public,'broadcasting corporation whose precursor," the Tokyo Broadcasting Service was set up as late as 1925~1 then it would have been possible for the NTA to have a whole channel devoted to educational programmes. In addition it would have been possible to have, as time goes on, such achannel assisting correspondence Col- leges and primary and secondary schools to develop educational programmes and air same at specified periods. An examination of the activities of Correspondence Colleges in Nigeria reveals no link in this regard at all. For distance education institutions in the universities, there seems to have been some working relationship between the NTA in Ibadan with the University of Ibadan External studies Programme, the same rapport had existed between the NTA headquarters and the former National ,Gr>enUniversity but these had been at the planning 1. Mito1-iNishirroto,"Corresp::mdencEeducationJapan: Status and 'i'rendsa,nd Innovations." O. Mackenzieand E.L. Christensen, op, cit. p. 327 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 260 stages. The National Open University appeared to have provided the only successful example of such a r~pport but even this had its problems. These issues will be discussed more in later chapters. 5.3.3 Trends in the Growthrif Methods and M~dia While remarkab Ie events were recorded in this period concerning the emergence of television opened up vistas for such phenomenon as the ETV,the enthusiasm for its use appears limited and related only to formal educational provisions for some time, and the more enlightenment-related programmes later. It did however show that the promotion of educational teaching through the television was possible. Again, the use of school teachers as facilitators of already prepared television materials was in a way a pointer to the fact that correspondence education t.u.tio rs could, teachmatericils prepare¢! on cassette tapes or video tapes by others. However, there was no evidence of such possibility put into practice by any of the colleges. Indeed, the phenomenon of people using cassette tapes before and a little after independence in Niger~a, even for entertainment purposes was not common. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 261 5.3.4 Issues of Quality and Quantity The Ashby Commission whose report was published aoout this time had identified the problems of the low rate at which capable hands needed in the various strata of the socio-economic life of the nation were lacking. The Report was also emphatic On the issues of quality and quantity in Nigerian education at this point. Among the many revelations of the study were that: 1 i. most of the 80,000 teachers in primary schools at the time were pitifully unprepared for their tasks; ii. Out of 4,378 teachers on the roll of 1958, about 4/~ were not graduates; iii. the quality of higher education at the University College Ibadan, the only university in the country at the time was beyotid r~proach, but the facility for admission of new entrants was inadequate. To solve these problems, the report recommended among others: 1. Eric Ashby.' op. cit. pp.7-9. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 262 i. a proposal for an educational machine to produce at least 8,000 young people per annum for ten years with some level of post~secondary education, to meet the nation's manpower needs; ii. At least 20,000 of the propOsed 3d,000 of the expected 80,000 (in ten year~) ought to be graduates, with 300 from Ibadan and possibly 600 from overseas ilnnucflllYi iii. No fewer than 50,000 people with intermediate qualifications will be needed within the same period. iv. the need to create places for 18 ,000 more entrants in secondary schools in about 600 more secondary schools. v. the need to increase both quality and the quantity of teachers. The figures raLsed , although directed'at the Federal Government and the ,more formal sector of the country's educational system had a lot of implications for the utilisation of correspondence education potentials at this staqe , However, it should be noted t~at the nearest Ashby went into UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 263 recommending the use of educational television was for the improvement of the standard of English of teachers and pupils in schools while there was some emphasis on the development of general knowledge. correspondence education was not' specifically recognised as a way out of the muddle. The level of involvement of foreign correspondence colleges in providing distance education in Nigeria at the time was still high. Colleges like Wolsey Hall, Rapid Results and the Bennet College still held sway. While their activities were aptly directed at meeting the needs of Nigerians in the areas already identified by Ashby, the number of Nigerians enjoying these facilities did not compare favourably with Ashby's projection of the nation's needs. There was however no problem with the quality of provisions at the ,time,.·1 5 .3 .5 Summary The coming of the University College Ibadan is already seen as a transitional period in the trans- 1 . Interview with Chief M.S. Adigun former'National Planning Minister under the Buhari regime on 21/4/92 at his Orita Basorun Residence in Ibadan. He had used the University Correspondence ~ollege (UCC) for his B.A. degree. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 264 formation process in correspondence education. Itd emergence, the result of the Asquith and the Elliot Cemmissions, was peculiar as it had the combined features of being a local institution to help train the needed manpower in Nigeria at the highest levels as well as continuing the tradition of degree~by- external examinations. Somehow, it also represented the inability of local institutions to meet the growing demand of Nigerians for higher education be- cause of its very low admission rate, thus making a recourse to correspondence education, at that level still a highly needed phenomenon. Even students who were admitted still satisfied the requirements of the Cambridge Higher School Certificate Examinations although they had the option of sitting for the General Certificate of Examinations. As early as 1956, the University had considered the possibility of starting .some degree programmes for external students although this did not fully rnaterialise until 1988 when the External Studies Programme was born. Ibadan's extra-mural provisions , for 1949 however showed its capability for organising non-traditional training programmes to meet the needs of the unserved. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 265 While radio broadcasting had debutted as far back as 1932, television emerged in 1959, opening the room for the possibility of a transformation of the genre. In spite of educational programmes organised by the WNTV and others in the various regions, there was no strong indication of correspondence education and the new media in Nigeria arriving at a very strong merger of ways. The later growth of the entertainment and news media in the country provided no known succour. The setting up of the Ashby Commission in 1959 to look into the area of post secondary education in Nigeria had two major implications for correspondence education transformation., First, like the University College Ibadan's coming, it showed the extent to which other avenues should be sought to make education availabl~ to Niger~ans af~er secondary school. • .r : '. " . : Second, it hinted at the possibility of maximising the potentials of educational television and the general use of the broadcast media. On the issue of quality, its promotion in the country's educational system still relied to a great extent on the foreign examinations which act as UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 266 standard setter s both at the certificate level s of secondary education as well as the tertiary level. Tbis shows that the initial'place of correspondence education as an emerging innovation through external examinations was still a significa:nt phenomenon up till independence. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY CHAPTER SIX 6.0 POST-INDEPENDENCE DEVELOPMENTS 6.1 1960-1973 The Growth of Local Correspondence ·Colleqes While the foreign correspondence colleges were having a field day filling the gaps in educational provisions in Nig~ria through the marketing of their educational services here, local entrepreneurs were busy making frantic efforts to promote correspondence education. Before independence, indeed as f'arback as Qe~ember 1943, the City Correspondence College (CCC) had been founded in Lagos and it p r-epared Nigerian students for the Junior and Senior Cambridge and London Matriculation in Arts subjects. As Omolewa reports, it was not long-lived.1 Later in 1962, another abortive attempt was made by the Olowu Educational Services aimed at offering courses in English, Yoruba, Arithmetic, and Latin.2 It should be noted that an early indigenous 1 . M. Omolewa, "Correspondence Education ~n Nigeria",-191S-75". Adult :t;aucationand Development No. 72, 1978, p. 15. 2 • ibi d. p. 16 . UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY CHAPTER SIX 6.0 POST-INDEPENDENCE DEVELOPMENTS 6.1 1960-1973 The Growth of Local Correspondence ·Colleqes While the foreign correspondence colleges were having a field day filling the gaps in educational provisions in Nig~ria through the marketing of their educational services here, local entrepreneurs were busy making frantic efforts to promote correspondence education. Before independence, indeed as f'arback as Qe~ember 1943, the City Correspondence College (CCC) had been founded in Lagos and it p r-epared Nigerian students for the Junior and Senior Cambridge and London Matriculation in Arts subjects. As Omolewa reports, it was not long-lived.1 Later in 1962, another abortive attempt was made by the Olowu Educational Services aimed at offering courses in English, Yoruba, Arithmetic, and Latin.2 It should be noted that an early indigenous 1 . M. Omolewa, "Correspondence Education ~n Nigeria",-191S-75". Adult :t;aucationand Development No. 72, 1978, p. 15. 2 • ibi d. p. 16 . UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 268 effort had been made in 1924 but it was the setting up of a centinuing education centre in the premises of the King's College. 1 This was shortlived before Mr. G.O.A. Coker' st.a rt.e d the City __ Correspondence College in 1943,'which did not do well "i~; shown Also by 1964 the National Correspondence College in Aba and the Pacific Correspondence College in Onitsha were founded. 2 These eventually succeeded but the early efforts found a bigger focus in the 1967 emergence of the Examination Success Correspondence College which appears to be the most successful proprietary correspondence college in Nigeria to date. The immediate influence of the founder, Mr. T. A. Okudolo had been his undergoing of a B.A. Hons History course through correspondence with the Wolsey Hall. After passing his examinations in 1963; (the result came out in 1964) he felt he could do the same for others. He had in fact been reported to be the only successful candidate in West Africa 1. "Evalua tion of Cor responde rice Colleges in Niger ia: The Pros and Cons from the Proprietors of Correspondence Colleges View Point" Paper presented by the Proprietors of Correspondence Colleges in Nigeria at the End of a Seminar on "Evaluation of Correspondence Education in Nigeria." Nd. NP. p.1 2. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 269 that year. However, a later motivation to found the school was derived from his'continued occupation a~ a teacher, noting the high rate at which students were failing the English Language. 1 This experience was reinforced by his position as a marker with the West African Examinations 'Council. He later asked some people to join him in preparing lectures in English. He did this for three or four years and found that the students were passing. This was the beginning of the Exam Success Correspondence College. The stages in the activities of the Exam Success Correspondence College in instructing its students are six These are: i. identification arid selection of writers ii. production of course materials iii. selection of students and registration iv. teathing and, learping. v. provision of sup~ort services. vi. award of certificates (in some cases) We shall examine these issues one by one. The identification of course writers is done on the basis of their having to be degree holders of recognised universities., After a selection has 1. It should be observed that some of the founders of early correspondence colleges in Britain were teachers. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 270 done, courses are assigned to be written which are later edited, proofread and sent to the printing section of the College. At inception, the Exam Success Corrrespondence College had no printing facilities but this was a later addition to its activities. Advertisementw,ere also placed in the papers for students to apply and register for any of the nume- rous courses available. Initially, the courses were basically General Certificate of Education or West African Examination-bss'ed subjects. Later, professional courses were involved and more of these, according to Mr. Folorunso, the Academic Director, were in the pipeline. Some of the professional courses are Journalism, Salesmanship and such as are examined by the Insurance Institute of London and Marketing.1 The -Lni.t.LaL clientele came mostly from t.ne primary school leavers, workers wanting to further their ',' education and a lot of illiterates from the Army. The catchment area of the clientele later grew to 1 • Interview with Mr. Folorunso, Academic Director, Exam Success Correspondence College. on 5/4/90. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 271 include those seeking profe$sional qualifications and who may have passed their General Certificate of Educa tion Examinations some time earlier. The Exam Success College uses the medium of print in getting across to the students. ~part from the use of radio and television for advertise_ ment, no other media use is identified. The Board of Management of the School however is aware of the p:>tentialbenefits of the use of cassettes, audio or video tapes but is unlikely to mak~ a move in this regard because of what it considers the cost of such facilities. Responding to a question in this regard, Mrs. Okudolo commented: Yes. We have thought about it. I was in the electronic houses abroad. We looked at the computer system. The finance was great. We . . ' " wan't; to turn 'it to a modern educational centre. By the grace of God. 1 Among the problems raised by the students of the College is the issue of faster mail deliveries :a:: 1. Interview with Mrs. V.O. Okudolo, 5/4/90 at the 208 Ikorodu Road office of the College. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 272 To this end, some of the stuients specifically send extra money and write to ask the institution to send their mails by courier. This in a way is the student's reaction to both the problem and the emer~ing context in which,th~y C\f:'e"operating.,If they had the money as they were wont to say, why wait for the College before they get a faster courier service? Some of the changes already taking place at the College are: i. review of lecture~ based on changed syllabuses (Mrs Okudolo says students have to read more~ ii. the need to ada~t their methodology to suit the new demands of Government on continuous assessment. iii. the growing high cost of printing which may spillover to the clientele Some of the expectations of the College from Government are: i. the need to make categorical statements Qn the position of private students in the country. ii. the need to say specifically methods they UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 273 want practitioners to adopt. The College has been a very active member of the Nigeria Association of Accredited Correspondence Colleges (NAACC) through which a greater liaison work is being done with the Federal Ministry of Education and the other members of the Assodiation. It is appropriate to say that the transformation process in proprietary Correspondence education, when the Exam Success Correspondence College is used as an index, is still to have any appreciable impact. Apart from the growth in the number of clientele, and the diversification in the area of courses, no notable improvement has been seen in the choice of media, or the' two-way communication process with students. Whi,le students can phone the office to seek information, this is just an exception to the rule. The elements of face-to-face components is not obligatory and if all students were to seek some support h~re, the facilities available at the College in terms of hall and other space arrangement would not accommodate them. It then becomes necessary to find a way, in addition to print, of communicating with the learners faster. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 274 The initiative which the learners appear to have taken in sending their assignments or requesting that mails be sent to them by courier is another dimension in the transformation process. This is that the learner may be able to effect some of the changes necessary in this regard. The College has reacted to the coming of the Junior Secondary and Senior Secondary School Examinations by working on the production of course materials to meet these needs. The Senior Secondary Certificate Qualifying Examination is also being catered for now. 1 While a bi-lingual cOllege for Secretaries has been lately incorporated into the College's activities the unit is not run on a ~orrespondence basis.2 In addition, two computer sets newly acquired by the College are already being put into operation for composing the lectures. Two IBM typewriters, a functioning library and a well equipped science laboratory are also within the premises for students use. 3 1. Interview with Mr. Y.F. Folorunso, the Director of Studies at the College on 26th May 1992 at the 208 Ikorodu Road, Lagos Office of the College. 2 . ibid. 3. All these were seen during a tour of the premises. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 275 While the College's use of computers to compose the lectures signifies a move forward Ln it.he transformation proce~s, the preference for the use of photocopying machine to re-produce the lectures makes the correspondence programmes costly. Meanwhile, the printing press owned by the College is used on a commercial basis for outside jobs because the cost of plates has gone up. Also, plans to put the College's information on database and to record the lectures on tape are on. 1 One significant development from the activities of the Exam Success Correspondence College has been the influence its operations have had over other Colleges. I Apart from the College serving as the secretariat of the meetings of the NationGl Association of Accredited correspondence Colleges in Nigeria, some of its former workers have gone out to establish their own col,leges. One of such is one Mr. Dagunduro who left the college to found the Lasswell Correspondence' Coaching Classes, in Ibadan in 1978.2 Some of the issues raised by Mr. Dagunduro will be discussed in later parts of this work. 1. Interview with Mr. P.Y. Folorunso of the Exam Success Correspondence College, 26/5/92. 2. Interview with Mr .. Kunle Dagunduro, Managing Director, Lasswell Enterprises on 24/4/92 at his Oke-Ado Office in Ibadan. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 276 It should be noted that there was both an increase in the nurrberof "local",,3.S well a~ foreigncollegesat this pericxi.'Ihe increase in the number of foreign correspondence Colleges, many of whom had no contact with the Federal Ministry of Education1 was a reflection of the growing need of Nigerians to use correspondence education to achieve their goals. A local matching of this upsurge led to an increase of the number of local colleges.-to about 22 by 1978. But even this number was low when compared to the numerous ones that advertised in the papers daily from their various bases in Lagos, Osogbo, Ibadan, Aba, Kano and other towns.2 Euler-Ajayi's 'findings in a ,study carried out in 1983 that most of the colleges were indeed based in Lagos also corroborated this researcher's findings in that respect. 3 The various advertisements that were placed in the newspapers in the 60's also confirmed this assertion. 1. Jude Nwaokoma, "Correspondence Education in Nigeria: An Appraisal of two Correspondence Institutions. M.Ed of Univ. of Ibadan. 1981. 2. See the Daily Times advertisements in its editions spaning 1962~1967. 3. This assertion was corroborated by Mr. P.Y. Folorunso, Secretary of the Nigerian Association of Accredited Correspondence Colleges in separate interviews with him at his Exam Success Correspondence College Office, 1992. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 277 Thus while Wolsey Hall, Rapid Results College and Metropolitan were variously promoting correspondence eQucation, more local initiatives emerged in the form of Zabedna Correspondence College'in Oni tsha, the premier Commercial Syndicate' in Lagos, the English Language by Correspondence (six--month cours~) in Osogbo, the Nigeria Zest Company in Enugu, and the School of Careers in Apapa (with over 500 courses to choose from} 1. There were others like the City Technological Developmental Centre in Owerri, the Gateway Correspondence College Lagos, the Progressive Management and con suLt.ancy Training Group and the School of Accountancy and Business Studies in Apapa, Lagos. In a discussion with Mrs. Euler-Ajayi, it was observed as far back as 1983, most of the correspondence colleges in operation had enrolrrent,fi.gures·Lowe r than 5,000. 3 Meanwhile from 1967 when Exam Success was established and Nov 1977, it,had enr-oLke d 100 ,000 1. A number of advertisements were placed in the Daily Times between 1962 and 1968. 2. Interview with Mrs Euler-Ajayi, first Head of the Vocational Division qf the Federal Ministry of Education on 29/3/90 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 278 students for basic studies.1Again from November 1977 to June 1981 the Exam SuCcess was found to have enrolled a new batch of 74,997 students and this excludes the 9,733 that had enrolled in the professional courses since this came into operation in 1977 and another batch of 2,104 that had enrolled for the college Diploma since its coming in 1973.2 Again the •... Army had enrolled 3,099 in the proyrammes since 1973, the Air Force some 1602 since 1974 and the Navy some 127 candidates since 1979.3 ThGS by 1981, the College had enrolled a total number of 180,488 students. 4 Noticeably, the.courses the colleges embarked upon were replica's of those the foreign colleges had 1. This was a research- finding by Jude Nwaokoma which was confirmed by Mr. P.Y. Folorunso of the College in an interview on5/4/90- 2. Jude Nwaokoma, op cit. ~.37 3. ibid 4. When Dr. T.O. Okudolo started the Exam Success Correspondence College, the English Language was his first subject of interest. Interview with Mrs. Okudolo, wife of the founder. 5/4/90 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 279 been engaged in. It was not uncommon to have the local colleges in their advertisements hinting at their capability to make the courses simpler in their own course texts and English was indeed cited as one of the subjects where such feats could be performed. But the local colleges still had their limitations. One, they could not go into purely tertiary level provisions. Also, their expSrtise in the area of science and technology and other technology subjects were in doubt. 1 r- The nature of transformation about this period was the coming of the local correspondence colleges into the picture, a feat the Exam Success seemed to have championed more than the other colleges. The correspondence education scene then became a sort of mixed grill of local initiatives merged with foreign forays. It was not, surprising later that the' local coLl.e qes thought of totally ousting the foreign colleges at a later date through their Association set up to promote the iot of their members. 1 . This fear was genuinely expressed by Jude Nwaokoma on his·~i.8ertation after doing a detailed study of the Nigerian Technical Correspondence College in Surulere. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 280 Specifically they had gone on to request the Federal Ministry of Education to ban the activities of the f.oreign colleges, and othe~s that were not a ,ccredited .1 A look at the pattern 6f media use and methods of initiative by medium still played a major role in pedagogical practices. Two-way communication relied solely on direct mail deliveries from the college to the learner and vice-versa while such media as cassette tapes, gramophone records'and the television had no use made of them at all. The clientele of the system did not appear to miss any of these media as they were traditionaliy accustomed to correspondence education being carried out through the texts given to them,. 2 Also the clientele of correspondence education were quick to point out that the postal system was no barrier, especially where it had to do with the foreign colleges. 1. Minute of the meeting of the National Association of Approved Correspondence Colleges, 9th May 1986 and Nov. 13, 1987. 2. All the clientele of correspondence education between 1951 and 1966 who were interviewed by the researcher confirmed that the communication system was highly efficient. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 281 6.1.2 Ahmadu Bello University's Involvement in Correspondence Education About the time that the local correspondence colleges were emerging, the first major University foray into the picture carne in ,the form of the Ahmadu Bello University's taking over of the Teacher-In- Service Programme (TISEP) in 1967. Although the provisions of TISEP in this regard were not tertiary in nature, they nonetheless represented a slight shift in the fortune of correspondence education because of the setting of the programme. Apart from this, the nature of correspondence education provisions which had emphasized secondary school education, other basic education programmes and the professional courses took a,different dimension when the grade II teachers' programmes by correspondence got a boost in TISEP through university involvement for'the first time in Nigeria. Al~o, TISEpis involvement in the promotion of the Nigerian certificate in Education (NCE) programme was a later development. The TISEP indeed had its precursor in the 1950's when, as a result of the short supply of teachers experienced in Northern Nigeria, the Ministry of UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 282 Education started the correspondence courses in the late 1950s~ 1 Among the courses offered were Arithmetic, English, Teaching Methods, History, Geography and Health Sciences for the Teachers' Grade II Certificate Examinations. Week-end session~ on Teachin~ Methods were added to the correspondence programmes that relied extensively on the use of assignments.2 Omolewa notes that about 400 teachers took part in the courses while 100 were successful.3 However the civil war later interrupted TISEP as the volunteer tutors from the US Peace Corps, British and Canadian volunteers left for home. Thus Ahmadu Bello University took over TISEP in 1967.4 The TISEP course, as taken over by the Ahmadu Bello University, did not experience any major shift in its method of operations. The course covers three 1 . Michael Omolewa, "Correspondence Education in Nigeria, 1915-75 II op , cit. P .159• 2. ibid. 3. ibid. 4. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 283 years and examinations are held at the end of each year. 1 The marking of students' work is done by toe tutors who may be the staff of the University's Institute of Education or those of the Advanced Teachers Colleges. The marked work is then .returned to the students with model ans.wers. 2 It was noted that the success recorded by the TISEP may have been limited due to the lack of recognitiion of the course and the students' command 3 of English considered poor. Suggestions then given on how to improve the situation were hinged on a possible increase in the amount of face-to-face tuition given and "the use of radio and tape recorder with listening groups" 4 . 6.1.3 Further Developments in Methods and Media The new providers of correspondence education at this stage, like their f.oreLqn counterparts relied solely on the medium of print to get instruction across to the learners. In addition, the use of 1. Antoine Kabwasa and Martin M. Kaunda (ed.) Correspond- ence Education in Africa. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. 1973, p. 134. 2. ibid. 3. ibid. 4 . ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 284 face-to-face instruction to complement correspondence education provisions had not become a possible pxactice except in cases where such colleges are really not correspondence education institutions. TISEP's foray into correspondence educa tionwas thus the only notable exception in this regard with its consideration of the face-to-face option as a viable addition to the correspondence instruction. This shift in method which TISEP brought about was later to emerge in other university-based correspondence education provisions. Perhaps a major reason whY TISEP could easily veer into the use of face-to-face method of instruction, as an exception, was the availability of accommodation facilities both for classroom instruction, practicals, library work and boarding during the vacation. None of the proprietary correspondence colleges or their fbreign counterparts consid~red this dimension to correspondence education privisons. The magnitude of the problem and their narrow perception of what correspondence education entailed may have been res- ponsible for this, and the correspondent lack of study UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 285 centres for their learners. Anyhow, an evaluation of the TISEP programme had indeed shown that mo~e o~ the face-to-face components were then considered necessary to improve the programme's lot. On the issue of media support, the consideration TISEP was having about possible use of radio to promote activities is significant. It also represented a major step in the pattern of transformation in correspondence education provisions even if such a move was only at the stage that could be called a 'thinking aloud'. The growth of the rrediaof ~ntertainmeJ1tin Nigeria.W'iS evident at this t irre . Televisionstationslike the NTA Q,(mnpl 10 in Lagos, NTA Kaduna, NTA,Benin (formerly Mid-west Television) in addition to the former WNTV were already in operation. They had a number of educational programmes which were not in any way tied to the correspond- ence Colleges' activities. .The Educational Services Unit was also on, with broadcasts to schools and colleges throughout Nigeria begu.n in January 1962.1 The goals of the Educational Service are 2 : 1. Federal Radio Corporation of Nigeria 1992 Diary, p.vii. 2. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 286 to provide a service to schools in syllabus- oriented subjects where it is necessary to supplement classroom teaching to provide high quality programmes of general interest to out-of-school adults for a better appreciation and undertstanding of the environment to initiate programmes of interest to the learner and the general public on achievements of science and technology to provide programmes of professional nature to the teacaer to enhance his teaching methods and classroom administration to collaborate with institutions of higher learning in their programmes of studies for external students, and to undertake research into the utilisation and evaluation of educational b.roadc ast . It should be noted that these programmes are not distance education programmes per se in the sense that while there is an institutional provider, the level of rapport between the learner and the provider UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 287 is rather slim, and may in fact not exist at all. Also, such programmes have the tendency to veer into g~neral enlightenment unless schools where such broadcasts are received formally monitor such reception with their pupils, arid even have.cassette recordings of such for repeat listening. However, the readiness on the part of the corporation to liaise with correspondence education institutions at the higher level is a major objective which up till 1973 had not been achieved. 6.1.4 Developments in the Nature of Support Services While the period 1960-1973 witnessed a growth in the activities of local correspondence colleges, it also witnessed the gradual loca11sation of foreign correspondence college activities. These had implications for reducing the distance between the providers of distance educat Lon and the c L'Lent.eLe . The first noticeable trait of the foreign correspondence colleges in 'the early sixties was the increase in the spate of advertisements carried by them in the local newspapers, especially the Daily Times. Between them, the University Correspondence College UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY ·288 the metropolitan college, the Rapid Results College, Wolsey Hall, the School of Accountancy, the Corporation of Secretaries, the Mayflower College, the Bennet College, Gorden Arlen College, Metropolitan, Bennet Airmail College, the National School of Salesmanship, the International Correspondence Schools all in London advertised their activities between 1962 and 1968, among other periods.1 Also conspicuously advertised were the school of Careers in London, the International Associations of Bookkeepers, Pitman's and a host of others. Colleges like the DCC were quick to point out their years of experience in the field as in the advertisement below: For over seventy years, DCC with its staff of highly qualified graduate Tutors has provided a system of instruction for examination or leisure 1. See the Daily Times editions of Oct. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5,8, 10, 13, 16, and 17 of 1962 as well as those of March 19, 24; editions of Nov. 5, 18,19,20,29,1963; ·April 5,6,8,12 of the same year August 22; Sept. 3, 14 of 1968 and March 18 of 1967. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 289 study. Fees are moderate and may be paid by instalments if desired.1 It was also quick to point out areas of provided tuition in, mostly the General Certificate of Education, ordinary and advanced levels, ~London University degrees (open without residence) , the Royal Society of Arts and various other examinations. Chief M.S. Adigun who used the UCC in the 1959's spoke of the academic programme as being thorough~ He had observed in add li .t,1.o2n: The UCC was a bit tough. Tougher than Wolsey. The first unseen Latin that I took was like the examination I took 1~.years later in the real examination. Wolsey Hall approach was simpler but not as thorough. Meanwhile, many of the C~lleges easily pointed out that they were members of the Association of British Correspondence Colleges. By 1965, the attempts 1. Daily Times, October 1, 1962 p.6. 2. Personal Interview with Chief M.S. Adiqun at his Orita Basorun residence in Ibadan On 22/4/92. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 290 of the foreign colleges aimed at keeping their Nigerian clientele in view of the developments of local initiatives in this regard was clear. In a boldly prepared advertisement on April 8, 1965, the Rapid Results College wrote: "The Rapid Results now represented throughout NigeI ria". It then went on to list the various representatives with their full addresses displayed. It 'was a decentralisation move aimed at bridging the distance between the learners and the London provider of correspondence education while at the same time providing opportunity for skeletal support services and ideas. They were: Town Representa tive Kano E.I. Allanah 52 Francis Road Zaria O.A. Akerele Estate Office, Ahmadu Bello University Kaduna I.U .A. Irohan Bridge Section, Nigeria Railway Corporation Jos J .o. Iloba Ministry of Mines & Power Mines Division Ibadan J. Ade Adepo ju I P. O. Box 543 Lagos M.M. Ottah 37 Ogunlana Drive, Surulere UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 291 ' Town Represen tative . Addre•.s..-s Benin City E. Igodan 38 Iwehen Street Enugu L.E. Okolue, 57 Zik Avenue, Uwani Dapele E.,M. Daibo P. O. Box 330 Onitsha N.C. Mbamalu P.O. Box 609 Warri L.I. Okafor P. O. Box 140 Aba C.B. Ileberi 78, Ulasi Road Owerri L.E. Njoku Holy Ghost ,College Port Harcourt W. Charles 4, Niger Street P.M.B. 5117 By 1967, the Rapid Results College had gone on to announce its Career Advisers.1 Lagos, Aba, Benin, Enugu, Onitsha, Owerri, Port Harcourt, Sapele and Warri out of the 1965 list we~e identified as places where the advisers could be contacted. Perhaps this was a reflection of the level of patronage in the place s. )-Again, apart; frorriPort Harcourt where one O.S. Charles was identified,and Lagos where one I.A. Thanni featured, all the other representatives were maintained as career advisers. --------------------------------------------------~~--- , 1 . Daily Times, March 15, 1'967. p.8 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 292 The Rapid Results College (RRC) also specifically advised Nigerians on what examinations they could s~t for in their respective car~rs.1 One Mr~ Ayeni a Mathematic s teacher .rtthe Fed:~ralCbverrurent Girls' College, Sagamu and a chief education officer had used the RRC for his G.C.E. examinations. He had found the College quite useful and efficient. He observed that the letters sent to him carne in early and that distancewas not really much of a barrier. 2 When he finally got admitted to the University of Ibadan through a concessional entrance examination, he had an advantage over other students who carne directly from the formal school system, especially in easily reading his handouts, a method he found something of a footnote to RRC's expectations of its students.3 Mr. Ayeni indeed insists that up till today, he has not seen the face of any of the RRC people. 4 1. A published list in this respect appeared in the Daily Times edition of April 8, .1965, p.8. 2. Interview with Mr. S.O. Ayeni at his Monatan residence Ibadan on 18 April, 1992. 3. Interview with Mr. S.O. Ayeni, Ope cit. 4. ibid. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 293 Meanwhile, the attempt to have local representatives was not peculiar to the RRC: The Wolsey Hall had aJso started operating at some point from its P. O. Box 1936, Lagos address as early as 19651. An examination of Euler-Ajayi's Master's dissertation at the University of Lagos reveals that they had indeed operated from No. 142, Abibu Oki Street in Lagos..2 In the same vein, the Pitman's College also started operating from a .base on No. 21., DuaLa Road, Apapa. Its full address as shown in the Daily Times advertisements was3 Sir Isaac Pitman Correspondence College 21, Duala Road P. O. Box 262, Apap~ Nigeria. It later moved on to No. 54 Broad Street. At the time of this research though it had ceased to operate from any known base in Nigeria. 1. Daily Times, April 8,1965, p.9 2. o. Euler-Ajayi, "Study of the Reactions of Correspondence College Proprietors in Nigeria to the Accreditation of Correspondence Colleges. 1983 M.Ed. dissertation of the University of Lagos. 3. Daily Times, August 27, 1967, p.9. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 294 Wolsey Hall also went onto boldly advertise its presence in Ibadan, asking prospective clientele tQ call at the C.M.S. Bookshop or write to one Francis Ademola of P.M.B. 5242! in the town, 1 in spite of its bold advert of March 26, 1962 ahnouncing its more than 20,000 success cases since 1944·and showing that "Distance is no dis dvantage" The growth of publicity of the activities of the foreign Colleges appearS to have been matched by the efforts of the local colleges which were springing during this period. Colleges such as the Premier Commercial Syndicate, the Nigeria Zest Company in Enugu, the National Correspondence College in Onitshaq the school of Careers in and around Apapa, Lagos. An English Language Correspondence course from Osogbo was being advertised. A lock at their methodsLLng :::;J.t(;dJite systems,.md laterI the development of its own satellite technology. 7.4.1 Recommendation for Further Research There is the need to carry out fUrther research on some aspects of the deve Loj.o.ent; of correspondence education in Nigeria. These are: i. Research in the area of the cost implications of the use of satellite systems and cable television by proprietary correspondence UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 420 colleges and other institutional providers of o r s t ence education. Such research will assist in identifying further strategies to ensure the effective development of this system. 1i. Th~r is n d for r search on the conversion of the various sandwich, part-time and week-end proqramme s in Nigerian Colleges und Universities to dl~tance educution to further maximise the potentials of the system and reduce hazards of travelling long distances to attend such week-end courses. ii1. There is the need for research on the .ne rq i nq of ways between distance education students and conventional learners with a view to improving practice in both situations. Such research may need to concentrate on the possible development of the print and the media components of distance education for conventional learners' use. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 421 iv. There is the need for research on the future role of Government in distance education against the backdrop of new international involvement which appears to be changing the fortunes of distance education. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 422 B IBLIOGRliPHY PRIMARY SOURCES I. National Archives, Ibadan (NAI Documents) (a) NAI/CDE 521, Vol. III, Educational Policy in West Africa, 1952. (b) NAI/MED (FED) and ACC.1!7 "A School Broaocasting Service for Nigeria" Report by R.S. Postgate, B1::lC to the Federal Adviser on Education. 12/8/55. (c) MED (:FED)2nd kc. 1/2 Vol. II External Examination, London University. 1948-52. II. !\'Erroarnda ~mo from vhe General. M3nager, N.'t.A. (Projoot.s) to thu Director of Finance, NrA of 2qd July 1984. l~f. NN~1~/ENA/28/83. III. Minutes of Meeting of the National Association of Approved Coorespon ence Colleges NAACC in Nigeria (a) Minutes of Meeting, 12th December 1986 (b) Minutes of Meeting, November 13, 1987 (c) Minutes of Meeting, 29th April, 1988 (d) Minutes of Meeting, 27th May 1988 (e) Minutes of Meeting, 24~h June 1988 (f) Minutes of Meeting, 28th October, 1988 IV. Oral Evidence (See Appendix 6 ) SECONOl\HY SOLJHCES 1. -Bo-ok-s- Ade. arunb t , Gbolagade. "'l'heConcept of Dis tance in Self-Directed Learning" Huey B. Long and Associates, Advances in' Research and Practice in Self-Dire~ted Learning[ Oklahoma Research Center for Continuing Professionctl unel lligher Educiltlon of t.hu Un Lvc rsLt y of OkL .d. lOlllu. 1990. I UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 423 Aqa s s i z, Elizabeth, C. "Society to Encourage Studies at Home" Mackenzie, O. and Christensen, E.L ...The· Changing World of CorresEond~nce Study University Park: PennsylvaniaState-University Press. 1971. Al~;jnr'oJu, J.A. and qtnolewa, M.A. (ads.) ~duJ-t Education at .Lbadan . Department of A ult Education, University of Ibadan, 1989. Akintayo, M"O. "Inves·tment in Education in Nigeria: The Relevance of Distance Education" The Commonwealth 'of Learning §!.~FellowshiPs ~ro9rarnrne,Vancou~ Ashby, Eric. Investment in Education. Lagos: Fl!deral Ministry of Education. 1960. Baath, J.A .. Correspondence Education in the , Li~ht 01-' a Number of Contemporary Teaching ~o else Malmo: Liberttermods 1979. Briggs, Asa. History'~f th~ Boradcasting in thi £nited Kingdom. London: Oxford University Press, 1965. Commonwealth of Learning (COL) MemQrandum of Und rstanding on the Commonwealth of Learning. Commonwealth Secretariat, September, 1988. Doerf ert, F., Schuemer, R., and 'I'ornhaeowsk i, C. ~~~sriptio~s of Selecled Distance E£iucation Institution~. Hagen: ZIPI', 1989. Educational Research Institute of British Co Lumb i.a (ERIBC), ~~g at a.Distance and the New Technology. Vancouver: ERIBC. 1982. Erdos, R.F. 'I'aechd.nq by Correspondence Paris UNESCO, 1967. - UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 424 Farrant, J.S. Principle1s964a.nd Practice of Ed~cation.London: Longman, - -~~ Faure, Edgar et a 1. 'Learning to Be : The Wor ld of Educatron-Tod~y and Tomorrow. Paris: Unesco , 1972 . Fay, Maureen A. "Harper, William Rainey (1856-1906)" J.E. Thomas and B. Elsey (eds .) tntern~tional BiograQhy of Adult Education. Department of Adult Education, University of Nottingham. 1985. Matiru, B. (eds.> ' Handbook Writin Distance Education DSE. , Glatter, Ron and Wedell, E.G. study by Correspondence London: Longman, 1971. Gleason, G. rr "Technical Developments Re lated to Independent Learning'" Gleason, G.T. (ed ,) ~ Theory and Nature of IndeEendent Learning Scranton, Pennsylvania: International 1'eatbook. 1967. Goodspeed, T.W. ~illiam Rainey Harper. Chicago: The University of Chicago ~ress 1928. Gordon, Donald R. "Print as a Visual Medium" Asheim and Fenwick (eds.) 6ifferentiating the Media Chicago : The Unlversity of Cfiicago Press. 1975. Harper, William Rainey "The System of Correspondence" O. Mackenzie and E.L. Christensen (eds.) ']~b.~Cr~~2i~51..lY2!.l£sfl C2~~E2!ldence Study. O'nlversLt.y ParK: • Harris, D. Openness and Closure in Distance Education. London: The Falmer Press. 1987. HolmbeErdgu,catBoirojne•, L-Sot-ant~uds;--~aoKn-;dn--o:T-rge-npd.s-n-i-n--=-;PD;1:istance---'9a"'-8'g<--"-'e1:-;--. . I ! UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 425 Houle, Cyril. rl'heExternal Degree,. San Franc isco: Jossey Bass, 1m. Kabwasa, Antoine, and Kaunda, Martin M. (ed.) 'or saondence Eduoation in Africa. London: RautIedge and ReganP"aul. '9"7~. KeeganL,ondDo.n:-F:oRobrui-da7tt~i1o-ne~~da~g-De-i -d.t.-a-n~clen9l~!:9uu~c1 uc e '/ · . ·.. .• .. •. ......... .• ........ ..•. .. ... .. •. ...•. .. •. ... •. •. . •. •. . • • • • • • • • • •• • .• • • • • • • • • • eo •• .• • •• • •• • • • • • • •• •• • • •• • •• • •• • • •• •• •• • • • • • •• • • • • • • • • • •• • • •• • • • • • • c • •• • •• •• •• •• • • • •• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• ................................................... · . • •••••••••• e ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••.•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• •. •. . •. •. •. •. •. •. •. •. . it!' neeri t'c~t' 0 c1 j t i (,)nrJ~ t u t 0 [' i n e(/ UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 437 . .. .. ... .. .• .• . .• .. .• .• •. .• .• .• •. .• .• .• .• •. •. .• .• .• •. •. .• •. .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• •. .• .. .. . .. .. •. .. .• .. •. .• .• .• ............................................................................................................. I L' .s 0, w t1e I' t~, ; If 1rI wh » L (I c t. e ['IWi !It~ Ii .y nil t: c:II o ice o r ~i1]c 11 0 n a r'!'H n.-erne nt. '? ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• It •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• II •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• .• .• .• .• .• •. .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• •. .• •. •. .• •. .• •. .• .. .• •. .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .. .• .• .• .• .. .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .. .• .• •. .• .. •. •. .• .• .• .• .• •. •. .• •. .• .• .• .• .• .• .. .• .• •. .• .• .• .• .• •. .. .• .• .• .. .• •. .. .• .• •. .. .• ~. It" y o u us eo c cu r-s e t ex t.u , p]t:":t,.>e d ee c r j be Lh e ru, Or d u y () U h t1V c:: o I d c CIP j e Li tII 1.. h 0 Ine '( .• .• .• .• ~ .• •. •. .• .• .• .• .• .• .• •. •. .• •. .• .• .• .• .• .• •. .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• •. .• •. .• .• .• •. .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• •. .• .• •. .• .• .• .• •. •. .• .• •. .• .• .• .• .• .• •. .• .• •. •. .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .• .. .• .• •. .• .• .• .• •. •. .• .• .• •. .• .• .• •. .• .• •. •. .. •. •. .• .• .• .• .• .• .• •. .• .• •. .• .• .• .• .• •. .• •. .• .. •. .• •. •. •. •. .. .• .• .• .• .• .• .• •. •. .• ..... MIWIA U:3erJ I'o r: 'l'e~ch~ 1 • 'l'h e Co r-r-cu p o nde nc e text, J'Cc:-nlllICrlcicci b oo k., 01" cu~eettes't PleLl::je ex p l a i n how you wl:;re taugllL • .... .............. .. ............. .. .... .. ......... .......................... ............... .. ........ ........................... • 1 •••••••••••••••••••••• UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 438 t up es , el'amopbone r-ec o r-ds , e t c , ) · . ·.......................................... ........ 3. Dj rl yo 11 e v e r- fee] the med i o ue ed (e. [r. j 11Ii d e lt N 200.00 (Rclund.iblc ill clld or course) YOllarc required to make ill led;"! 50% (fifty per cent) payment of the tuition fees and full payment ofother charges stated above before 27th April, 1992. Till! remaining payment will be made on 2nd October, 1992. The fees to be accompanied with the letter of acceptance should be paid to the i"~Ly!cl.i~ of Ahuja in Bank I.>fill'l drawn 011any of the following Banks in Abuja: First !lank or Nigeria lJ IIion llan k of Nigeria A/lkd flank of Nigeria Hilllk of North United Hank for Africa (';I'ill PdYIIIL!1I1will not be accepted. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 459 Ihc tl)lloWlflg arc the hkely ~llIdy l'I'IIIIt:~ where students will regisrcr. You will be:expected III rt:gi~lc:f allhc: study :':1111n'1c'.irc.st tu you orthe (III": III wlll"1i YIIIIIIIC iI!,Sigllcd by the Centre. There you will meet the study centre supervisor II, • will IdJ you whut 10 do, (i) Oyo/Ihadun SI. Andrcws Co+lege of liducution, Oyo. University of Ibadun , Ibudun (Law Progruuuncs only). Uuivcrsity 0" AbllJII, CUllin: for Distuncc LCllfllillj; (Ilhl Couuuuing liducution Gurki , Abuju. (III i ~;illlt) Buyero University, KIlIlO, ( I " ) L.J fI u FIlJ, Cullugu iJ"I~dll!.!lIlll!ll. ZIII'III, (v] EnllgIl/N,ld;hu Uuiversiiy of Nig.;ria, Nsuk ka, Enugu Cuiupus. (For l.uw Prognun only) 11'1)UWe:lrI Al vuu lk oku ClIlk:;v III' blll..:uli,Jlt. (VII) licuin lJl,ivcrsilY 01 Benin. (Viii) I.ilg()~ 1:..:.1e:11CI1(llkgc 01 Edu(;jlljo'l CI'(;cllIIiclli) - Ak ok n. ill lite: 111.1<":I: ICI.:I~llilll"". l"ll \\111 '" 1"1"111:.1III hl,ng llt~ lollowlllg ro lltt: I,.gislralioll centre> I," I'lt.: dn~llIlIh "I }'\lU' \\'11111,tll,", (Il) Sill «(I) 11IIh~p"d ~IJ." 11111I1"l''''I,I", III 1o~1" (e) I:vIJt;IICC of flll),III!!1l1 IIf"'I'I, IInd IJlbd ":"lI'I.:e:~, l'Ic~~..:1!I,d illladlcd II IeItCI ot 11""'1'11111I:'nl thc piovisionnl offer, which YOII should complete and return togcthrr with II,,~/lUIIA Draft 10 Ih.: UCgi,II//1/', /lII/I',T.lllY ('.//11111.1", ~1I as III be received here IHII later than 27111April, I !)92. If we II••1111"1'""il''' )'1111[1,,111.011'11" "1'111111I",y lhul dlll"l YUII will forfuil Iii" ~"'flll, YJIIIII;'S ;lllithzl'lIlly, · Yukubu II. Ilahi Ag, Rcgi~tlar. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY I I 460 ~ l\PPENDIX 12 CORRESPONDENCE AND OPEN STUDIES INSTITUTE UN!VEHS/TY OF l...AG~I)S 'I" i''! MAHCH 1992 .I I. \. 'I I ' I T:.,ABLE Of' CONTtENTSJ UNIL,AG t;.TJAINS THE . ' I' Unilafl A ttsins tn« Middlo-Afl8, 30, MIDD~E~~GE, 30 . ~~ 1 I' , I' 'j' , Three dtlcadn~' ago, the "man" Unilag, ,3:/ (ll/otablo Quote • Protossor Nurudeen Alao WI~e-Choncel/or, Un/lo() was a baby: lit could not even crawl It was t r~( "11" , sucking frorn1its mother constantly the milk of • ,I I q~·t!ctO( wetcomes COSI r Students lifo, which ,Is IllIflllo~tlJal knowledge. !I.,,' ',' ' absorbnd acadornicians from far and wide . 1:frstfO (Eastnrn and ~este~n Europe, US and Canada} 10 .:(ion both indigonos and non-tndlqones and asslonec ~pSIT tor 1991/92 them the tasks of lecturing the young ones and IFalen~8f generating knowledgo through research. ' ~f!~1f " That 'fas tro tirpe 'wo had the 011 boom~OVtI"1fi~r· and the economy yvas bubblinU. So also were ~f'Jdent 08(8 fund~ flowinq inlq the University like a river :' ~ without any artificial darn. There were funds ll'p(l8tion for teaching +Quip~ent; building facilities and '1!lq " research. That was 30 years a go. Today, the ba]min/Jrion MlJlpf8cticu Revisited story Is dll(OI'~flt. The Linlver~'lv IS ojjafatlfi\) I': _ -" , • _ under SAP, Henes. we have had the neod to 1~!(:'r8a$"In servto» ChlffUj,' launch and ro-II!\JrlCIl 1~8 !Jnlverslty of Lllgos 1,'\'. ,I' . Endowment F~md ~ COStT Day At the 25111 Convocation Ceremonies, on Thursday, i20lh Fobruary, 1992, the Pro- cpsrr LOC(LIfI1I1 on VlcI,m 7 "PfI$? ~pancollor and Chalrma~ of Council. Alhaji !Dr.) r • " ': , Garbe Ja Abdulkadir presonted the state-ot-the- fll1(1l1ln,lon, LtlltVII vf A".~I'''C'' UnlvQ(lIltv tIW,I' I 'I, I A .• tile Pro- CllanClIl/or snd Cheirmen 01 Council, it is my pteesu, r« and privileflEl r •• UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBR RY 461 r'1~.(i'~tWH ~Pf.l iI./i (u III;:; I/(JIIIIIII:"/I!)f/ caruruonv QUOT AUlE QUOT!: !-v,/l{C ~ l~oin(:icIOs witt! tlru 3U/II AIlfl/IIUrS(lr¥ ut PROFUSOI\ Nunun~t.;N AI-AO ~tl(l IW(Jqi'1~ of !"/S ~rullt ImHIIII/iufI ot (!i~"/u yIC~·P~~~CEI.~IAU' ~'lAF' . (dfl{fI((ip:, fhO Umv8f:>IIY ull,bi/os, ' , II" , "t« i( no! Ow cuseutuu qyen toduv we "uvt) Sid' first, I vvist) /(J wotcom» tno not.'learnt, 1{l1Ir' ~e are'sf! ottun unuble to Ijl.or~'HnldlivlJ ot IlIIi V,siWI. vic« prus/den(, Septlf~(e noise trom i,! (prmil tion, ttiet we flail '1'1f111(ffl ~t/~ust(JS 'AiA/lomu tor Ilis lilvulu~ul/J notse {Jnd cllscare! inlornllJlion, th at wo (/0 not 1~'f1S(;lICct. Hu f'Vb$ /~tJl Ii witt, II~ dfl(l pftWUU" di;i(if)f)IJ"Sh'bt:f~t:ff) inlorr/wlion ilnd knowit:d()tJ Qllt/'Ii/It (tll{JuI/Chlrl~ of ttio (JIIIV/JfSlly of LlJOoS and between k~Ptv'tJi.lfr end Wlt/V( SltJflUiII{) ". 4/u/HfvaUlflr FUnQ lit wtuct) //Iuru uiaa 'Y 25 Iopnilhi()/ WIIS cottectad UII tho suut, Nu donated, QIRECTOR WELCOME bt!(llJlf of trio fu(/urul MilltMV Govemment. ;!'CO~lrSTUpF!'~TS . the lJum of N:; nutliou urnt nuutu II oorsoo»! The DireClof of COSIT. Professor E. 0, £10il,~',ion 01 N 2 5, aDO, O() 1111 Oulwlf 01 his Faobarniyo, welcomes all cosrr students to tsmhv. YULl' /11/ Allow (11,1/ (IHI Fiulot a! the new vu,ir. 1q91/'J2 session. Hu urues all Govurnmem i.\ :i(III (111I 1111I11I ,HI/II cu of r(}()ulur students to make euorrs to be familiar with "ftJ(//ii, dOl/lI/IUIIS 1111I'"11111I 1111(/1//./111 1I.~·:;i:;/UIICU Univer sitv rOIJutaliolllj .50 as to milllllli:;tl /0 tll., VII/WI! su '(. . problums, l le also advisoli lItUU1J/lt:. ID wad tlio ,COS/{ Nt'W~·Lf.r 'Ell thcrouuhlv :;0 us to bu Ifill civman (1//11"111 • ., III ("uu.\ St at u, up-to-uutu with povuloprnonti ill 1111/III:oIillJlu S" M,(;II/1l1l UIII dll 10, " 11(/1111111/1(1 (Jill' Ulld Iho Ullivtlr:>ilY ounQralty. convocauon corutuauv 'IU 11.001/1.:;1 tint», f/liJ/ it ' ~----..--,---- Univer:>it'( has racuivutt .~IIII/}(11i WId lull coouerutlon trout 1111I :,1/1/1/11 ctvitiut) find REPISTRATION nutnur» Governors 0111/1)1;" SIII(iI. III/Villlivr /l(I}i il I Rc.tSd/Ci in PiJfficuldt ,';11)( aun! /I I,IIUU not cot of All students except. Illu IJ()\Jlllllurs. , land (0 ttus Un/vv,-sily ,'II /l!1"l)uilu, Ltus WaS struuld rlJuislUr /01 IIlis sus sion 1••rui.t I rld<.JY. .$ub·i/iv/ded /1110 1/2 plots uiu! /1i:'lribu(ed to May 2'Jth. 19921• l.are regisiralllln will hlU I lie the Universitv stotl. 'flit.' bendicioril:s have untorWiliod tor whatever russun. All CUSt I allf:ddy received ttie« I,,,hvit/II,II Ccrtilicates of s tudun ts who auunded tho Ii.s t rc~;iuCIII i.J1 Occuoencv ana I/It) UIlIvv'511y nos liJunched a programme WU(o (1uly informed about this nome OYVllt:rship l.oon Scllil/lle lor (/10 stutt. deadline tor ffJoi'stfation. To be tor ewarued as 111/: Hevolv/III) Furu! illr Ihi.\ put p aso will bu wu know is to ,·),u Ioieurruud. mcrenscd tron) N 2. t; nulhur) to N 3. fj nullion 10 If you live outside l.ajjus, rt:ui:'\ldtlUll onobte more and moru of our stutt (0 b/flJc/ their forms VVIIt be fJldue ilvdi/Ju/u at Y(Jllf Study own homes in LIJ[lo.\. MIJY I appcul 10 Sir Centro. You must pay the fult '~II,IIUU:, I/y Iwi!•. Michael Otcdota, Itlw his prcdccussors, (0 draft made to "TIll: Correspondence 1 wutcoino 1/.1.1 /-IOf/, sur vice cli;Jr(Jcs'remain as ill 19~Om 1. hut oIII f ed/)(dl Minis fur ot {tI'Jl..'lIliun, Professor students .Ire IC(!UUtoltjU to jJ<.Jytur IJIlIJ!.. dUjlo:.iI Bab at urut« Faturiwu 10' 11i.~· pI US I.'fIC{J ticro a:; tollqvvs r- . tads», Wu twVtl COIIIIIIII/'(/ /0 rucoivu SPIICiill euonuon 01 (110 Non. Mit us ur: ill s()llIitl{J some 1" AccoufltfllU and [jUSi.H:toto ;\d'"1OOI!.\rd\Il>1I arobtems which IJlII IIIJCIIIIt/( 10 (110 University 1A ·2A - N 200.00 01 LallllS. 2. Science Education N 1 fjO,QO /. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 462 T/lis is !JUCilU5U 11111111:II1lJloU IIIKIIi iI'U now books and study materials as 50011 <.IS tlllJY availdblll for disldlJutloll ro studunts and only rucuive their offur of adrnisaion. Nuw srudurus those who hayti mUlluy III IlllIlf book dupoait must rUQistur within 28 days of tlw offor of "CCOUllt will bu ,u"vlc"d wllllllill dulilY. Nuw admission, otherwise such offur will lapse and studerus are i1dvlllUd tu dupoult N 600.00 for will ue ·oivon t other qualifiod candidates. COSIT CALENDAR FOR 1991/92 October 1991 Saturday 5th I.IIU ul 1990/91 Mondav 11 tn A.P.D. MOOliliU Acudumic ses sion. Thur sdav 14 \11. Bo a r d uf Studios Mfjotinu November 1991 Saturday 16th . Studv Centre Mooting Monday 18th A.I'.IJ. MOUIIII\j Saturday 23rd - Study Centre Muutill\j Wednesday 2~th Advert lor the 1992/93 Dllc/Jlllblir 1 iJ91 Admission 'rhur5da y 12111 - JlII,II'J III !:.ilutJlu:; Friuuy.;lfWl . DuJdlillo for H(Joislrillion MuuIIII\j for Courses Monday 161h A.I'.t). Muutlnu, June 1992 NJiJrcll 1992 :5aturdClYIhh Sluuy (;UIl\tU MUlllinll SilLUrday 7th !:ilildy CUlltrll Muutillu July 1992 .. Th4r1;day 12th· llo,JI(j ot Study Mfluting SiiturdilY ~ th 2nd Continuous MUlllillY 10th AY.D. Muoting Assessment Sillu((JdY ~ lit till/(Jy Cunue Moutinu SaturdilY 111r Sluqy Centre Mllulinu 1992 FrluiJY 1"!tit Mulricul,HlollAp(lJ Saturduv 181h Matriculillion SjllUlday 4th !:illJdy Cuutru Muutillg MvnuilY zou, Husidon 11•.•1 f'IOI/'JIIIII1U Monday 131h AY,(). Muoling beoins. SillUr~ilY 18th ::iIlIlJy Curure Mooting Sil\UrdilV 25th 1~t Cuutiuuous Auous: 19!J2 At.bOlJli,nunl Satur dav 8th Hesidential Tutor: •.l•:, und Tuesday 11 th Sessional Ex•.r•mnauons MIIY 1992 boUin SaJu,dilY 2nd ~llIdy Ceutre MUlltinlJ Friday 2Utli Hesideruial ProuraHlIllu ends. ~...••...--~.. 6TAFf MOVEMENT 1tlU Adllllllllll,.I\IVIl :iUI.:,ul,1Iv, CaSIT, S~IIVI!;U of I'IU OUI-uoiIiU II lUll liJIJ(!> tudent~ ,nowjldaY!i rs a ruul l;dU';U IUf Ibl t.eave ot AllhUIII;U 1lI,Iy I.HI OfllfHuU tor alarm. '[hut e are' unoujjh data to shovv (hut the one yoar dt I) tlmo liut thu tdllClUfll IlIU/il wrilu number 01 fi:tiluros il\ 11l1l~e subiccts IS vury tor Q renewal on 1111IHI/will 11•l.tilu. Sub sequunt hlOh. Ue~idus, npt m~ny of tile pas sus are loll lor Scionca tne Adminiatrativ« SUGIUldlY 1IIlIWI/ull l st Junu and MdtlwlIWlip:i r~liltQH courses in (110 and be fora tho ulld 01 thu ((Ilildontlal Univursiuva h C,l:ilHi 01 [Ilnus s lho 4. 1/Ii"!lJc,i~u me bous of IU,H;IIiIlU,, t '~I next-of-kin 01 II studunt could act on a t.tud&nt's buhalf by liullllllltlJlU u mudlcul rupert It il) on lllU but;ili of this last rnctor that wi ltl j) leuer. this lequr wi~II~:i to .~ddr~~1i It:.iolf on how to 1 " rnake ~ur distal1ce learner~ more eff ective ill IIlu urt ~I luut:hl/IU IlCilll\l;~ Hnd rn'llhulI~jl\ir.~ lhosu 01 you In Ylldf iliA 1/1 Illu ~GI'Jlll II ProurilfTIrnu ,h?uld qH~r .~ course on 11111 methodoloev ot, tOcl(;rling Phvsics, Chumis u v , tiioloOY illlq MiJlhtJmatjc~, Experiuncu 11,1:. lih~wn mat not, lTIilfW of you oro prupar(;d (Il face this cour~~. F~r example, triose of you who a~~ not tfach~rs. are likely to per lonu poorly ,n tnis cqurse 'QolnQ py past experiem.«. The problom tllorelore is "~ow can you pr ep.u o .. I '," 5 I, . ., ~ '" UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 465 yourlillit lor Ihl. 1:\)11I ~II •.l•Id llli 111110 to pur turtn L ,ud Iy. c ,,'I 'r ,,\I Iell:11\ if y "I \Y willi in 11111 couruu 1" Psy(,;lIuloO1('j;j I/pllil()!:' ~"lil: .II 10 d:,1111:. Ior Thill .tlor\ 1111111 IN III hurouucu you \0 'JlJ!ililyin~ Illu LOilcIHH~' JCllolI:;l me 4(1 I)t lOIl<:I!inU IclulICIj IAlld matnernaucs 'j " , throl.!Uh OLJIHHVlltlllli. II vuu ure II iuacher. It is Sunp Ihn orioin.1i copy 01 vour lindiliUll II wuy of (0-')(111111111111.1 '1'\1\11 ¥ull. yuur rntlthod of 10 me butorp the end 01 MJY 1!.J!.J2. Your own tlillchll\\,I IInd bCl 11\ till! jl11M1I1(l1I10 uuy wlltllhtH (;(!py will 1:!9 Y~!ld i.I\:I\lin IJl)rillIJ 1\11) fI)~idell!liIl if il adequate Of nut, IIIIU 011 1111l basis of what proor Jmlll~ I ' ! you find. to bu (1Jlluy Iu olioCI is cnanqe. II you are not In I. .,HUI tOliclilliU pr otus slon, It is is way You ITIdY write to IIIll III CJ:;e you IIl!Uu of expo:;illg you 10 thu pr otession ttlrouoh anv• leuer o.f I Llul!lority in CLlrryiflU out the above direct tlXPO(jUIlCtI [HI/uru vou llOoin the course. exercise. Epclo:.o a self-adurus scd uuvulope. I' THE TASI< I Y",i!ih you all is Iwppy .md truittul 19U 1 IU2 i\uja!J\lInICl Yllar.You should.cnoo su iI school near-by I r· ind oblillrve one or two iuachers teach your sublect N6'(V 9nJQ~ CEf'lTR6In oruer to ouservu» Those students who would liku to how the teacher pIMH! his IUI>:>on:;. attend stuQY centre Illuutinl/:; in OUUII Stare UnlvllrlOily : Ijobll-IObq for AcccHllllino I1l1d the various pruparatlurls 110 makes towards his Business Administration should complete the lesson deliverv, Pro-Forma qulow:, how hll dolivorll hlb 11J~:.on in terms of Miltric Number: .. '......•................................. introduction and oujuctivus, I , Natpe: ... : ... I!' ...•• ; ....•• ; ....................•..•.......••. activities for studurus, discussion with or 1 '. , . iHT10('lQ lIlt! lHudun(tI etc. Coorse: . whilt kinds of evuluuuon hu carries out auor Year: ! ........•.....•...............................• each, lesson, lInd Whal audio-vlau ••1 IIluH hu UUtlij III hili TO ALL COSIT STUDE~TS ,tessons. Please. return tho completed Pro-Iortua with your It I. hopud IlIul lilt! lu,H:llor. YOIl watch RtlyiSlr atlon forms llfll tllo uoolJ ~pol wilo \4110..IiC(;ounl 01 Ihll Nilrno ....•.•. : ; .•••......... ··· ..•. ·····•··· .. ·.. IIluloUI IHlIlll.llaluU lIilllvu. . You IHQruquir ed 10 watch at luast Ihrlll! IlIlIIIon •. At mt ,v1alric No ..........•.............. ····· .. ······· .. ···Clnd of YOIJ( Cll.lurvullonl, you IIhould appralse thu IttbliOna bv iHlalYliing your Con.tact Addr,us s: , ··· .. ··.. olllulrvutiona In l!Jrm. u,: •.......................................................... Teacher dctlvllY Pupil activitv • . :.' , . T~achor • r~PlllnItHilClIlH\ij. Tel~phone:.; . b UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY .' I 466 APPENDIX 13 .,1, III' .-.•.....•.•...- _ .•._ - ..._.._J i ~1II·".•' .•1I .••••••••• , .J I II II III ill I 1'1 I., i 11111111 . , No,1 wlttqU J.'lJgLJtrution (11) Oululu O.l:ILSllll!1 "I'j>lUll 0[' YOlU' (;J'c:liLJ0.tia1;,. .,j (b) BJ:ill/S"Yow' t'(JI'lIlil l"IIII/I'O,l't phOLo(!.l'l.11Jlw. \ ; () ) "I Obtain OI'l/jJ.IJld IIJl'l1! CU.L'tlt'lou.to or DlJo~l".I'u.tion of ,'t""~tl. .\,.,' ( d) r, I'i'''' . ((I) '!. " r i ,: (1') 1I0wt1vur, Any I.J UIl/lWJLJ.ull UlLLUUwill! thu ;J0CI'uta.rillt after ol.ouln~ h(llu'/J will lilli, 1'1/ IJIILlJl.'~ulIHJtI !Ill LIIU on'leu O~l,)u(Ju a t ,. ,OV.w. L.u 1.1/')(," i"lol1duy lJ,ud J",l'laI4Y. , \ I ~ ; , (6) ~tuduntu ujl<)1I1ol ""1,, 1.11111. I'I4Jllu:u t o '\lJtl.lin 1ul.tl;)l' of ,I, oOllfj~'lnl4t1ulI III' 1'''"llllll L'L'OIllWAI~:t: {)/.LII dulllY I'vj)ill1.J.'ut1un. ~',",. -11-f"1'-I'I.II,t1_1-1-/.f-I'-I'I.(.IN.. Now uludulltu ultuiliol I,"i." 1.II,d, 1L lu U"-IUulltilll I'or tllUlJI to :.11(91 tlltl i1l1.Lt.l'ioull.ltl(11i "IIHI"l"I'. AIlYOI1c. who hau not .:Jlb"l'lUd tho r tIl \HllIn 1111"11I,1L llJll 'to tho of£iowl' In OhOll'itil or h;i.lJ!ho;v •.. /» . UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY \ I "~I 11.11 ,", I tl ~J I " -, I~I .,:: I .1 If. It' 4' "t \\ ,I\' tit' /,',JI/, t , /'//:,'1//1/ ,,/1.:, ,',/,11 ',.,1,; •• ,,,, ! I departmunt af'Lv r wille" u Ludun L ill uxpuo t ud to writo Jown his/bel" numo 011 Li II L u r 1IuL:;iutorod S tudcnt e , 5. De f/"l."od or improjlo rl y I'j 110<.1 f.'ugllJtro. lion I'orrnu wi 11 no t be accopted. 6. Students UHI ud vLuud Lo l:uglu\.ur (11' IJOII(Jl.hlu) I'o r couruee to be of'I'o rod In tho next acud omlo YUIU' illUllIl- dla.to1y after the :"wi:J1 orv' cxamt.nat ion pn rd od , :JLIllh/llLtJ uru rulv ItltJd l.o I'LlY Lho I r tu i Lion 1'uoo lJl1.1.'ly In th'J eouo ion (to ill Lu ItlJ.Y'lIlJrI t woulcl 1.1L. t ruot CIOWI! I'I nou, 1"11Ylllun L no rOl.'lJ tJlI" I) J' I Deoember TUlIlldItlJ N)OO.OO •k J unuury - }'ultl'Wu'y NGOO.OOk Maroh 1f700.00k No t.u LlurL .utllll.'JlII.II wllo do not Illiy UWll' tu.t cLon f.(tUI:i I tJ nnd or Mn,r'dl wUl not be allowed to oit fo:~ oxume in thut yuar , I r , '.l'he 1992 tOIl,old rw J,['/l'; LJ)O ut;u.'tu 25th May and endu ~rd July 1992. '\)UJ'uU Oil 1.11 6':~IOkl:l. 'I'ho Part Four Guidance' & CounIJo111111\ :1\.1I,j'1l11.11 w.ll1 ~lUVO t he i r pra.ot:101l1ll1:t:ilJlultlln9- i oua Iy wi th '1.1111'1'11I10:1J1Itg l'.m....:tLco, 'l'he pa.d, four. (400 level) •• ./ 4. ,~, , ':,~ UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY ·-~--.-- ,--.,..-4_70 ..•.-- ~,---...~--',-.,.- --- - ' ..- -..,. "I: , ! " \ " ·r , .'. 'I ) '..( J, ".}'lli'il " 4. pr."dlou Juu of ~200.00j( bunk: d..t:i.4£t pUYi;l.ble llt tlltl vIL.\.',lvulJ u tudy <';t;lltn,~, or. or lJUfon; 10th ..,~.~.•.~.. . - ~f.' 'l't'" droJ.'t Ilh(\.n.llt flit ~l j.n fa.vour of thti UnJvUJ.'Ld Ly ot' Lbudan , Any lu:tt:! pnytnorrt will enhance ~,(1.LlJ,OLJu.l uout , AllY u tudont that J'ul.l u Lo puy tho LiVld,1I iln) Ilul"IlllY ud v J uod to c o Lf c cL Lur'o rtno.t Lon, 1I.jlt"rl1..._, 1"I:1.J1I1lliu II.' VU1:JOUIJ U t udy C(JlIt:!:UU und ac t ucc ord Lng to Lhe lllil L1'\1.1UUIliJ Lhu r'u Ln , C-OIJIII JI': M/-I'J'I-'~/ I I'll,: J ~HudUJlI.II o l' l!:x tllrnul !itudj ou I~L'()~"l'LUIIIIlU (1:::JJ» u.J~U ud.v Laud tu L)~.\.'iIII.Jy wJi;uru t o LI10 uLulw fSiVUIl bu.l.ow wlwn c011uc- L J 1I~ U III I t' I; lJUl:UU iuut, ul:iult:l LL l liu::,11 ~Ilutuc.l ULudy c cn Ln:u. AV ILl 1" Id... UUJlll'UU ur'u uu 'tabu.Lated below; SiNO :.I'L'UJ) ~ -c 1:J~'1!1I~/COOlw INA'fOil LOCfl'i'lCll - - 1. rl)lLduJI Extornal Studioa PrOgTWllLOO ')L'. (r1J'u.) u ,A, l!:gwlyowi lln Lvo ru l Ly of Il.ludurl, IbwlUl1, Oyo !J'LilLu. 2. LllgolJ NaUoD::J.l Inat Ltute of Moru.l rlJ.\.' • It'. A. Abu;.J;J ImJ. lL.;lil.:iou::J Studic;J, Project 'I'Ime , Akoka, Lag-DB, LugOtl Statu. ~ ••• 1'/ J. ',' UN VERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 5. , ' !l/NO S'l'lfDY-Cli:N'J'HI::jC(J(lIU11:NA'JDH W()A'I'ION ~. - -.. -- --- I- _'_I •.!._~_-,-..;....-,...•Mo ..B. klt1 Enu t it ut.o of Educu t Lon , ,l)r. AlOfllttJ Undo 'tlllitu Univurt1:Hy" Ado_Elk.\.U, ' -O-n-d-o-S-t-at-e. '-,.----- •.. - ,...:--"~.'-'--'!"---"f-'4. ']jonir\.ol! ,ll.y :rHO U, tu to--or--lM--u-cn-li-1-o-n-.-~ ])r~ otjnf'a Univ(jtaity -of ,Uul)ilj, JJon In City, --_ .- J'ldo fJ tate.'~- ... ...--.- , 5. Port ..H. uroouit, n lvor Stato Collogo of Dr. Aglna.-Obu Ii:du0a 'lion, Port...llaro ourt _-------- H ivor State.•. ...,...- -,-,,;,.-""'"'!' r, ~-, ,-.---;-~--' 6. j{ano Dopar tmont of Adult and Mr. Sabo Nt!ttbllwtt (J OilunUrti ty ,Extonulon; nayaro UnivortJity" , , " , Kano, --- . -K'ru-I. fJ I;~til.••••• ___ .•••• __________ ._. __ • ' •.4 _ •• --:'.....-------~ (1) [;tudei'lL" are ouLy aLl owod to Luy cour-se mai.cr i a.Le at , " t he Lr choaen t s Ludy c ou t rue , (2) OlJt.!l.in v~lid bllllk d r-uf'L I'o i: thu t;)'luwt wnQuu't of (J!I\li·tIO inatorilllt1. 6l.Vu.iJ,uIJ lo ut Lllo (,;011Ia'cu. Notu that t.ho it,tJUft , , " I of uL.lllrlUllI o u Lr] tUJJlLJllg bUJ.L.LJIUO'OJ: (~ILIIlJIUI) (I LlI: a:LI,.l l'orwl.I.:tll) wilL no llllll)l.I ~' IlfJ IJtI ~Ij I'LI\.I.QI,'l 1'01' IlI'Il0U.IJ 1.1nl, , " , , r(!/iuonu. Dn.t.fl.ll oh Lul.uorl frolo Lanka at;ter twu, fIIOT) LIlli ,will, be d16i1<)HO\.IIl't..l Ily LIlli o ll' I.eor( f.I) :l.mJlq He ou t o our ae '., ,. I . ," mater La.La at vurLouu Clllltl:O*l. '.rh~.Q iLl to pl'!1V(!n~(If.l~as .1 " (3) ,'l'lte following I 1.1I,f1L1 tLI U Iluud (It! for: u o 11(,,) I,loll 0 r "nUI'UI) •. ./6. Li- :',;1: I I t c , ~~; f.', J" I i;'h, , UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 6. 1. ,1'' ; UJ."tHJIIUl oopy of P:L'OPUJ:lrl J,'.l.ll ••J. I.u~l 'LI.••::.~r, p.i/::n'l'd "I OOW,'lIl11 :ru"1.W~:\'IlH{ln fp,','IIU!,! ~~;t~ 'thE! '(J~'I~EI~t, ,Iii,~,~U~~~~ , 1. i,11./ . I • t' ,- ", ,JtU;Jll.t~) ~ O~ '~Ul't'l.on 'fotj'p. ' : :~, , ,I ,II 'I I I 111. Vur tu Id(jnt1~.Y C;.u.'d~,', I • I , .' It, , 1v.1 :l\IU~ dry:{t \'il-th~~~, ~tud,~rlt Ia full nw~';~~~rio."· ':~ j, lIuu\!Jur 'und 'Po8t~1~d.:re:J1 neu tJ y and ~qH~Y ~J;' ~ttOf1, Ilt I.hu bao k,' I " /,' Vi, 1.1,1 LLvJ,' p~' /l';LLI}u,L';L. ,{' {,L'U.I.' l'Luou« (.(,j ll;,~ tl~~:~~~CdUli u,» on /lOIJIt10TlU I B btJ!Ullf)" I .,' " ',' o+op.I'll.' 1 lJ~lt(J.,.t&lu co l Ieo ted IJIU~t Uu ,Ll.l.'opurlyOh\iQKSid by,u ,.~:: ;O"~1~.~,;".;,;;~ o:~ 'b. ~,i(',.J"oy;l~~~, ." '1'1111:1III to uuourtu Ln ~~~ fll4lty IIllLlu.L'Julu w:u 1wwud1uL~1.y I " ,-.,. I I, l~plu<.Jull by of1'1ce:L'~Ij) in charge be f'o.ce be.ing ta.k;un ,!,I,W~l. " Nott! thu t iJJUtu~illlt.i 'tukun: ~.uuy lJy'atty LJ'Ludl.Jl1't 'rlUI1r.lut \ ' l'L'OPOl' olluull.,lnl; 1. 1'tLkam tL\lut at tnu I:Itudtlrr1;IIJOWlll."itJk. I , :ltwll11ltU uhou.Ld pu!'chLWc'rwi'Lel.'ialtl uva J LabLe tJe1'oJ:t; llll) lJlJJ'll)u of lluv1.LliulI/I!:'xI.:,ltnutton (t.r" 1",1' tlwy O(>UlU ill) uo au to 'avoid unneceuaury Tonai.on during tho :revitlion " VtH'lod. l'l:lo.rHy will be ~iv(,n to I:II1_Ltl 0,1" fT~3h courue , IlW. t!.- .1l1.lu (if /lny) during th.1u per Lcd , , I.' ,''. (6) MduiuJu will 'be Lseued out 'within 'lileperlcid ,stipulatud , ., oy duult)IWotuu 'oJf1CU.L{u) ut'vl..:rloud ot udy CUlltJ'UU (uUW1.11y bCit.Wl)tlCl 9.00 a.m. IJ.LlU ~o~J 1;".lo..) fJ.'ullJl'lt.'l~ddy'- l"riduy. !;iuch offJ 1)II1-'U llLllldll;16 lIJlJ,tu).',l/l,lr' ~1::>~I(;V"l." 1l1['Y use thuir diuc:co- 1.,100. • ••1'7. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY -'-.,---_._-- ..•............ "'--'--~"-~ --- -----._ "' ~..__ ..~- '7. Applioation fox lI. ulw.ue,1J o l' ut.udy cuu t ru ulrou.Ld uu nuutly WI!itt&1l 1U1I1 1I.I.1<.U'U/JUuU ~IJI 'I'll •• ::iuuio!: r.IJIJjULUJ1L \(ut.;luLnu:, l!:xtu.cnul ~It ud Iou 1',l'og:nlJJuJlo , ': "'Unlvol.'tJJty of 1lnulun , Tbadun; NeCIHHJlLI:Y in1'ol'llluLllill (uuch uu duva,rtwenLt:I, tuu.ohlng IJ1WJUlg1;, '1lt11'1'1tl III,IIIIII\'L', J uvuJ.. l"1JJ,'UluS.' 1:1.111.i1attllJ(.I1rlt:; utudy c er.t.re e ) should bu uttcl,ud ill Lhu upp'l Lcut Lon lotto!'. 'l'tw ! ::,4 " th" und of th!:, tJuulllull (r ,«, (JutolJu:t' - undi.rlj)), llny i ,,'\ I" , app Lic at Lon IllUde. u.I'Lu r th Ju uu tu will not ue •t:nturtairll:ld. ~.",.,~----,Jl 'J1hutl8 will OOUIIJ UV ill .1U 1.1. '1'110 ox uct du lu ,1111 be tlvtlly fllultJU fill' :il1l)\.II11i1,"I'- UuloiJu.l:. AllY challgu in tllit:l (ltJ.ltmdar will UU UOIIUUllll.Io u Lvrd to u t uduu iu Lut.er, K. E'.XiltHNA'J'ION HI~:JlIl.'I' 1990/91 exanunat Lcn ruuu I i:.J tLrO being d.Lsp•.tchod to IJtudlmto who eubml.t t.od uult'-wldruu;JuJ I:Jrlvulopuu wilh UU. '1'11O;J0;; who UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 474 tl. 1~~1/:J;! tut orf a I tlxufciutl. Nottl tlliJ.t no complu.1nt about 1l;ltl\.WJ.WU of ullwu.i.n..::t.t1on :u,\"1ul°too will b-. ..ntm:.-t"iuwd.. 1i.L"t Ill: t.ilu tut orIu.I tJxtll.'citJe. KIJllll Y IJUI,t1 yUU.!:' 111~ul.°lJw.tlon .JII1 tJLJ~6u;) t Ionu to tllu .l:jJol lo I' L:.•. tU.l.°tatl :J lu(1.11J/J Pr()~-..uull.(;l Uni ve ru Lt.y of I~. JlJIi.(\IiII. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY I "W7S' ,APPENDIX 14 Of'! enrolment. you ere given a Certificate of Studentship. Exam, SIJCI~~SSStudentshlp Ccniticete is the '/isible sign that you are on the road ~o SUCC8$$, . , . • • \. , ..J CERTIFICATE OF STUDENTSHIP·.., , ,~ " -J,. 'I hi~ is 10 certit'y Ihal • M", ~' . has been enrolled I ~ for a COUI'lIC of ~tudy .leadiug II) • • • J 'j in the following ~uhjc('ls:- .J) j I. . , 2. 3. '_,II_, 4.. ~ 5. 6, 7. Student No . , , . . Date .'~1'1 -, .. J: t.. ':.' i '. . Director , of Sl~dles /) EXAM SUCCESS CORRESPONDENCE CQLLEGE , f., '.~.,:1 P. M.B. 10.6\0, YAM,,. '." LAGrtc' ;,..•/, .Ivu. ,Jof 1', I r f, , J.' ! I . - ~ Certificate' by enrolling (~'odaY;.· ~ ) :' ;:.. ~ . ~t J ~. ,,': ,.~ ,J .:;;..~~u..~i_,· .lrIu"".J"J,.1L .. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 476 I .~. I APPENDIX 15 emill l'Al'Ell FOR THE All Iloe COI\IMI'J"I'EE ON rm: ltE()IIC,I.NISATlON OF '1'111':AIII\IINISTllATIVI,:S S'J'IlliCTlJllE UF TIlE CUES'!' IIO(JSES CONFEBENCE CENTHI': CONTI NUINC IWUCATION CENTII I': AND '1'111C':OJ(IU,:SI'ONIII':NCI': ANII OI'I':N STUDIES UNIT UTII NOVEMI11:1I. 1!JU2 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 477 INTRODUCTION TIIU lJ1111 Iida IWUII described humoruuslv as i:I 'universitv within the Uflivllr~lly' iJlld is lllliflU so treated by manv in this University to the disad- vantdue of lilt: unit. Tho UIIII rs un iliLeurdl part of the Universitv of Lauo!), and not an adjunct, 110r' wi tli I.J separate ux istence trom tile University. TIIH loulldinu to thers u f Lhll Uruvursi tv 0 f LilUos hau the vision to include ill lIlt.:ir p ropo- sills for thu :;ullilllJ liP of the University the necessitv for part-time studies which shouh] muku use of amonq other thinjjs mass-media techniuues, in orrtur Iu IIIUX111111111 utu UUu ut uvuilublu tuailltius in un urhuu urua like luuos, wi th li"tlluli(1I1111J1 IIIHJC II , lldb uuu ()I JlllIVldlll1l Uis tuucu Lll"""IJI:i Willi I"Nu Ilti:.:.ud 11111 ()I'JI() I tuni ty ur iHU un.ihlu lor OIiU reason or another t o avail themselves or lull- Limo studies ill il universitv was realised when tile Unit was launched ill Wib, . Thuru I~ 110 doubt tha t slnce It IjturttJd In 1970 \I~ an uxpurimunt ulld !Jioneerinu project il 11iI:>been forced to identify the problems of orqanis inq a Distance Teuchinq System within a university and it lias suuuested and tried to find solutions to them. 1'1111 (ilijlllr "CCHiU in Purspuntivu" writ tun ill 1977 was uutje:>tiolls to :>lIulIULl1ell il to perform its work more efficiuntly and more ef tectivelv. It was this paper which PWIllP IUU the setting up of the casu Review Comrni ttee ill 19"/8 UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 478 lly tile Seuutu III JiJIIUi.IlY 1980. The Unit has been waiting anx roustv since then for L/w nnp temeutuuon ot the mujor .ccommundauon and the !Jlvill!J of serious consiuur ation to suggestions in tile Report about tile positron of the Unit witlun the Uruversrtv. The only positive action WdS the cut unq of iue ulnbillC\J1 (;llOfd between tilt) Fllrt/"10( Educ"won Unil and Lilt) Cor res- pondence 1II1d Open Studies Unit dunng tile bud!Jet meeunq of Develop- ment Corunu t tue for tne 1980/81 session. Since then the Bour d of Can- tinu inU blucd I iUI I has cedses to recoqnise the Correspondence and Open S\\.H.1iu~ UWl lit> (;U((\lIIU wll/1irt us «rasdicua«. Tile Corruspoudence and Open ~tudio!. Uurt hus been tloaunq In nud urr . lilu Unu :iliHlud Willi severul iIS~LJII)PllOfl:i wluch hiJVU NoIIJel;1I louud latur to IJU'hlild, (il) tllJt thu FdculLles and Departments understood the unpltc auons of uccup tud ruspon!libtlily tor thu ucademlc WOf k ot thu Unit. (lJ) that tile Unit did not need a core of academic and protessional ~tclll fur its eduoriul dOU rnedlcl wur k . - (c) tllill Lilli Uui t Will bu il tiny onu vvluch wrll not neud much space. T11U!iU und suveral other factors con urbu ted ill no small measure to ctuute iHld tllllidily problems sornu, of whrch cuultl have lJelJll uvou h«]. Unfor tunurulv thu vurv students who should bunulu most trom tlus learn- ing straluuy liucuruu the victims at these problems, white the stuf t endured and :itrul/ulllli 10 improve the situation. It IliJS houn iJ per IOU at lear nin!J for all involved - cas U stu den ts and staff, DUJr15 ot Facul tres, Head of staff of various Depur truen ts and other au thorrues of the Universrtv. Althouqh there is no end to learning, UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 479 and UIU L11l1l will cununuu lInouuli rUiiuult:11 10 learn, I make IJolu to sav that i t is II llW in iJ very strong posi tion to appl y the acqu ireu experience, skills and I-.lluwludUe to reshaping, consolidating and expanding the Unit. TIII1 tlll"dIUU Appendix A of tilt! statistics of students for the acade- rnic yuur HH!1/02 shows: the growth since the unts early beqinninq. It needs no emphasis that tile economic advantage of a university without walls is in its lalue number. TIIU !:iUlldLu ducidud threo ycars iI!lO tiliJl tho Unit, extend its courses to lncludo blUdulll~ III lhu Fucultv 01 LiJW olld Ihu Depuruuout 01 MiJ!;5 Communlcuuou. tllu !:l.A. (Education, but these are yet to take off). TIIII muiu tillU:it oj this paper will be t~ spccilv the wavs III wluch it O'UII iu;~n'I!'HI 11"'11 Hllllly (Ind uifiniuillly. I twill thunbe obvious lutur, what its rulauo. ••llip :iIWIJIJ bu with other Uroups. "1011 Itlt 11.;1U uu 0 TIIO ex istcuce 01 the Unit confirms the convicuon of the Univer si tv of lllu'IHJltUlIlullU uf IIILI DI~tulluU TULIoltillU tiYWl1l11l 111UX11JIldillU ilw CIJIJIUUUtu those ou taklo 1110 walls of tho campus. The Univursitv therefore opurutes both tho TriJlJitioliul l-ucu-toFucu TUilclllllU iJlIL! thu Distuuco IeoclllliU Systems. It hi pur tinunt to point DU'{ that the University ot l.aqos IS Dilly one of tlw lJ1iJny universities within and outside the Commonwealth that operates both systems. IL is tr uo lildl Cuui so Tux is aru it p.ut ot the Tuuchinq Strale!JY, bu t OJ:;ranee T ucJcI Ii II!J is d IlIU Iti-med ia appr ouch. Corr espondcnce lns li tu nuns offer education IIHouUh the pr int medium only. Tile word "Open" which UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 480 i:; borrowed I'UIII lJlllilill unphus tluu tl iur e il/e IIU Iullnal elll/V ljlhlld,Cd uons. It It; ., 1IIIIIliliioil 011 the WO/" Wl: ar e dOHI!1to desclllH: II •..~• J LJ'III A IUiJclllll\l s.n vu:u Uru t I:; Ilw :'Il1JII(!:.l eSlldJII!>IIIlU:lIl lhaL GJII ell ,:,1 (lllt:ld uouullv, II is p' ~,)u:.ud Illill the uue Cou espoudeuce uud Open UII,l be Llldll !.lud to Distance TeiJchill!,J Cenu e Tms clwnuc I:' ~lgrllrlGiHlI l!0t,;d'.I~1,; Il emphasises dw rolu of offer 109 cleg,ee COUf:.uS of a Depar trnenrs fucullV through D,::iLUfU';U loaclling Method) to Distance Learners. TI,,~ cl'ullUe would enublu the Distance Teaching Centre to oper ate realistically Wu can now look ill thu curr eru ullcl ploposud IIlUlhods ul 0lltlldl'llil al Ihll OIllHII1, ACADEMIC SECTION Current Modus Upc/iJ"!" It is u uu lIldt thu Uuu 11iJ:;moved ilway Ir om lilt: :iIILJilIIUIl wl,,;,, academic ~ildtf of Dupui truen ts were personally Invited lor casu wu, k without allY ul/lelill mvotvemeru 01 the Depai unems An o t ncral ielfel of appoinunem I:; flUW bUI1l9 u,ven by the Re~JI$lry. The stalt Iic!jululiOIl makes.a rufululIl;u to tl,c Commurnent of each FacullY n ..-mber to the Uuu Thuru uru .Iutll\ Advtsorv Conuruueos III LlIU FJcullW!) 01 hluCilllUlI, Science 4I/ld UII~I/IU~!i Admuustr auun, buL these do nOI. InLllltil) ,tli ,II,) luclurlJr~ III um;!1 !"'1Il.alily who UfU casu LUIUI:', TI,u CII.JII'llilli o l LdL/1 committee is a rupr cscn tauve 01 tho Faculty. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 481 -;-IIUIU ilill Iwu SUjJelvISOI:i III the Fucuuv 01 EduCiJliUII 101 tl re Ut u t work, (JIlL udell III thu Depar uuents of Marhemuucs, Cherntsuv. Pllyslcs iJnd BIOIollY wid Accoununq, Thcie art; Counun.uors In the I)(:p,u unenr of Econon ucs dlld Poll tical SCience, bu t ther e IS no Coor L/1110tor III tile Faculty 01 l uw. The 1I1)",d 01 Exumuiers 01 Ilw Foeulty 01 Busrness COIISI(jers 1110 results ot IJIllli 1-1111 tune and casu students. 'l huru I~ d suput ate UOiHLI of Ex airunur s lor casu students III tne faculty 01 LduCul101l which consrders the resurt of casu ex auunauon taken ill tiuplulillJur compr rsmq of all the uxanuners in the FJwllies at Educution ilild S(;IUllce. Thu UUtllI:i ut lilt.: Fucul uus 0.1 Business Aduurust. auou, EdUCdlJOIl and SCiUIICIl IHII:.unt till: respecuve COSU students III therr FdcuIIICS 10r mutriculuuon uiul !jlildu(JIIOrl. IlujJl~lhllIlIIlIIVII' III Ilill F Wllllill JIlII1 COSIJ lilQII In blilUVlllllllilJ1pll cutillil Illl'lll~ 01 I'roapuGlivu quulllillrJ ~llIUUI1IU, hu t thu Du.rn 01 uw:!l Fu~uILY riJliliu:> IIIU 1151 itnd P(Js:>U!i It on to the Vice Chuncullor Iur dpproviJl. Tho I"cully I~ rusuonsthlu tor the JCdtiellllc coruent ul 11,1: C(JIJI~e o l lurud II.: CU~:jLJ utudouts, wr nus tho Cour su-v l ux t Millolloll:., IlIlHh;ldlu~ them iJlld .,11: COII(iJCt·lutOIS at Lite •study cen tr e meetings, IIILiuCllUII (Jild Long Vucution Course. UNIVERSITY OF I ADAN LIBRARY 41)2 '1110 UIIIVtll:'lly I-luy~ houounn tutu 1111:FiIl;ullY :ilull IUI wor k dUIIL:, Proposed Modus Opurund, The uXI~lI)/I';U uf co~u m the UnlvtH~lly means thaI rhe Uruver suv recoqnises two methods of ((WeIIlIlU and IUi.l(llln!J lut' us deyree pr0!J1 ammes. The Unit does IIOL devise courses ot lIS own, It onty helps each Fucuuv to extend Its luuuud lacrliues through Distance Feaclunq Methods, The rnoru- toring of tllll twu svstorus lly cur utul evuluuuon pr ocudur'es will :iU(VU tl u ue purposes (0) uununutu eftorts which illtJ wJ:ilelul (t)) illlPIUVU upon tiff orts Willi UllJilluJ pr onuse (c] plan bene. use 01 Distance Teuclunq and Learninq :ilrJlt:ljlC:i tu tulltf the expectation 01 the Nauon. The relauonstup between il Distuncu Teuchinq Centre and the Fuculnes can best tIC dcscrrbed 1J:i svrnbrouc. The liowl! O'VUII hulow appoxunates LO tho !JuiJl~ of the UlIlVUISILy III lioltlno up cu~u 11111u1lluws II to bu opurulllllILllly /IIJX IIJlu ,Hid IICO/IUIlIf cully CIIU.IPIJr lU run. Wildt) UHI PillW/lflij TlIi1Gh1l1i,1 CuntrO hus Iltl own Gore of academlc 'Idll iL does not set up a lull compurnent ot stall tor each ulJpartrnUlI1. Il'~ own acudernic stu If ar e to spec !iJIISCin D istancu Tuaclunq MtJlhul./s ut thuu uwn Iuupect ive c1i~clp/lntt~ FuW/ly I -, -. heu/ly 11---- Drstuncu TCilclllllul r.IIIIJ·" ~1 !'''''''Y III / UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 483 EUGh' 'f ~,aIi IY shou Id utJ I1lcldu LO IduMif'Y It!. proper roru ulld iJCCUp I IC:'I.lOnsiuility 10/ its Distance Learners bei:lIIIlY III rnmd the'f/riJcUci.l1 II11P- lications of 1.111ilSCCopli./llCO, which include thefoliowl/lg:,- (0) Tho ()lJjjll of each Fucultv IS responsible for the acadeiruc content 01 lhu IJI~LiJlIC(J Luur ner uf the FacultY,whlle tlltl Dir ector ut the Cunu u lti rusuonstblu fur poliov Llhd reports to Senate. (U) -IIIUIII ~llould be i.l Hoard of Mi.Jlluuernl:Jnt responsihle for the Jjol.\;y uf Llltl CUIlLI(;j WILli rCUdr(j to iJll II.:>dledS of oper auon, illCiudlllU Huuds of Depur tmunts. una SIWOrVISO/S With tho Dit ectur iJ:. the Chairman and he IS responsible Lo ll,c VICC- Chancellor (e) There should be a Jornt Advisorv Committee for each Facultv with u ruprusuntuuve ot ouch Fuculrv iJS thu Chuir rnuu, Willi fL!Clrlly end Centre stiltf dtlullnu WILh ucudernic illiU i.l(.J1flIIiIs- uuuvu "IUllIH:;. Hie Committee should report to the Fucul tv UOIJ/(j of Studres. Tile Centre should be represented on each FU'Hllty Unurd IQI whillll u Ilxw:HI:s Ill) ;OlJrtilJ!:i to D,tiliJIIGU Learners. (d) TlwuUh the Universitv (;OntIlI•UU:; to pi.ly ItOIiOIiHld LO lilt: riJClJlly stul}, their annual evaluation form should reflect their addiuonul duues If) their work-load and contribution (0 the University, UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 484 8 (ll) ClIlHliU -Tux I ITlUIUflUl1iwhich UIU WI II tun and mouur ated by tli~ ucuuonuo utul f of the rIJSpUC\.IVfl dupar trnents 10 or der to mum tuu I IiHIIH.larthi and used tor the Distant Learner, should also be jjvjjlldul~ tor the Full-tune students. ThIS will In the long run in lruuncu tor uooLi the teuchrnq methods for the tatter. (t) E.H;II faculty should kt:ep a record ot all Its students through the Distance Teaching System whrch shoutd be supplied by the Conue. (u) Thu pruClIcu HI other Unrver sities in drtter ent par ts of 1/10 world wluch operure tl IIlmilur IiYlIll;lm is 10 employ addmonal stulf ;'1 ouch uupar trnent, In proportion to theu number ot rCUI:iltJred studonts. Tilt: accepted propor uon rs 1 ;50. Approved shoulu he o,vun lor such proportional increase. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 485 MEDIA. SECTION Thu d,:.lIIICIIVU aspect at Distance Teucluuq IS that it IS u mutu-mcuia svstern illciudlll!l tlill pnnt und t1IuCL/OIIIC IllCdli.l as well us ll,e lrJd'llOllul tace+to=tece method. Current ~1()dm Operandi The Medii! Sec uon 01 the Unrt star ted off wuh us own staff II) both print und IJluCIII)IIIC rncdiiJ unci trur licript to uti Cun ue utiltllmtll. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 488 (e) 1110 AcodUIl11C Ottice sllou!d perform tile same tuncuons 101 the Cuntru students as it does tor tull tune students with fI~HJrcJ to exurniuution and results. (d) Tho Students Affairs Office, should extend its services to Centre students to include welfare, accommodation and Student Uruoru sm. BusClry - Current Modus Operandi Thu !Ju/tiwy oxurcises the same responsrbilitv for rile Unit us il does fo/ everv other IHlII 01 tho University. There is il representative of the Bursary III ihe Unit, who is adnurustra tively responsihlu to the Unit but pro lessionallv responsible to the IllHSiJ/Y. Proposed Modus Operandi (a) Thu Bursary should keep i;I seperate iJCCOUnl tor tho !wlu u] IIIUI<.lt.:IIIS of the Faculty is confirmed by the results of the sessional and repeat exami- nations. Thu Fucultius of Social Sciences, Arts shoukl be encour aq/: be undci rukcu by such titudClltli while I""idl:llt ill Nigeria. the proprietor cunccr ncd shull apply for rel:ibtratioll III' II,,: ClII rcspundcuce college ill uccordunce with the following PWVilliulIK III' Ilti" IIccrcc, (:.t.) \Vlac,,' 1111II,,: l:Olllill!: into opcr.uiuu of thi:! Decree any corrcspon- deuce CIII11-11I: ill 1"111)1'illl{ 011 busiucsa ill Nigcria. the proprietor thereof way 1I1'I'Iy WIIIIIII I1IIII1 1111111111t1h1eJt:llfler ttl lie rq;ihtnnl hut tlhall ccu..c tll curry "II ""1'1, 111/111111'1il'"l Ni!(l'rill ufter the expiratioH of six 1I1111lthtl [ruiu the c()lIlillH illill "llI'llllltllI III' tlaiH Decree. unlcus prior tu the cx,liratioJl of the _aiJ 1'~lllId, ~1I111I III I 1'1Ij1"JIIlcnce collq;e ill regi:itefeJ to coutinue its business ill lIJ.:cllrJIIIII'O willI thLl I'/Ilvj~illll!l of thi~ Decree. 2. (I) WIll"I I' II •.••rn:lipIlIlJcllce college is uituutcd ill Nigeria, the J'lun.:dllIC pr"l'riel"r 1111"11"1"' h,dl upply ill writillg to tlle Couuuissioucr for regititraliull fur rCj;iuliulion, und ,IIlull 111'111111III 1111'prescribed form-- (1/) till' 11,111111'11101pilln: of husiucs« or the prol'osed n.uue and place uf hUllilll:"" "I I1Il' l"lll'hp"llllellec eollq:e ; (b) IIIIl llilllll: 111111ud""'IIH of Ihe proprielor wvcrc Illill i~ 1111illdividllill 11111i1ll 111/11.11I.!IIIH'«, of l'ucil \III'I~Ctlll, IlilllllCI'j 1i·II~h.:c 1)1' illlH!r prillcil'al ullin:!' III' till' I",tly (whelh.:r eorpunllc or ~lliIlCurl'0J'all:), us the casu may rcquiu, ; (,.) 1111:11,11",,' III III.: l:1""Hl'lI olh:rcd or tll he oll'ercd uml dIU durutiou III cadi Hlidl Cllllille ; (d) If IIIC I,""inl'lill III' t hc CIJlTt'~I'0lldellce college was commenced before tile cOlldll!! :lItll ol'eilitioll uf thill IJccrcc, the date uJ' the l:OIlIlIlCIiCCIIICIII of such hlldi,\t'litl ; und (I.') Illldl 1·.iWI pal uculau, oW JIIay he jlll:l.cril..t.:d, (2) J II the c.iuc of a corrcspoudcucc college situated uutsidc N igcria, the pruprictur thcrcul tillall "I'ply ill v/rili"i; to the Conuuissioncr Ior rcgisrruuou and shull lid mil ill the pi cscribcd fOllll- UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 492 A 80 1977 Nil, 11 ( (I) 'I 'bl! l:IJlIIIIIIII~itilicr IIIUY by order Jluldiullcil ill the Gasvt!« (:""I'.-IllIli,," cUllcolllll~ ~,~,tlilh ,111111I1l''lliutl utiou- .. of cci ulicutc •• (II) II tltl' 1.,,1<11'111I:lcof ccuscs to curry 011 in Nig\;ria the kiud of busiucsa fill' wldrli 1111'\ l'llllirlllu Wild j~ijlleu OJ' jf the corrcspoudcucc college gues Ililu lll(ltldllllllll III III wound III' OJ' lllhclwiuc ccuscs to Iuncuon a~ u CIII'IUlllllilldllllll' ,."II.·~ •• i ill' (bl If 1111'hllldl'l IIICI'\:1I1'fllilll to Iullil tho prescribed couditions 1111I1 J'CI4111"tlllli. 1111 ' (c) ill thu c!1t:lll11l1tllllceHuud in the 1I1111111wl:rhere under ur purauaut to lhill Dl,lcl co fllililiu tu L:ulllply with lilly provisions thereof or of any sub- aidiury Iclliullitilill thereunder i~ II gruulld fur caucclhuiun of a certificate of rellilllliltillll. (2) WIH:ro the Cuuuuissioucr proPUtlCIi lu called allY ccrrificurc IIf n:gilltrulioll IHlIlilIlliit III aubscctiou (I) of this scctiun, he shall before such CUII\;c1hi till II Hive nut ice III' hiM intention to the corre~l?lJlldencc collq;c concerned IIlId IIIlIdl ~ive it UII opportunity IIJ make rcprcscutuuous and to .submit reU~1)1I11why Uti certificate of rcgistrauon should not Le cancelled. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 494 A 82 .-----------.-_ ...- - .-_.__ .-..__ .__ .._--------- ----- 7. Ally 1'1'11101w1ill) ~clb uJl .IIIY currcspuudcncc college ill Nigeria or, II~ rhc ClI"e IIIIIV III!, rUllll ClJrrCkpllndl:ll\J~ 'Ullrbl:ll which arc undertaken ill Nigeri« "L1II'lwille IIlall ill coruplluncc wirh the pruviuiuna uf thi~ Decree shull lJu j{1Ii1ly 111'11"1ll1'uIII;U und uhull h' liublIJ on couvi 'rioll to a fine of N5,OOO or illlpriHIJ/IJIU'lI1 1'11I1w' u ycar~ or 1Il oOlh such tine und hnprlscnmcut. J'u\\cr ot tI, (I) """' IIIC pllrpU:lCH uf lhi:! D<.:cr<.:ca,ny dcsiguutcd otliccr->- dc:ai~H..atCJ ()fli'l!r~ lu (/I) "11111h1uvc II riHhl of access, at any tunc during the normal working erue r hours or 1111W' ll'l'lIjlollllencc college concerned, to Hl,ly Illtiiding 01' uthcr prCIIlI:H.:ti UIIJ ,.I,Huill PI'I!IIIiIlI'Il 01 lilly IHICh CUITC:lpOIIUellcccollege ; inforrnauou. (b) !lilly hy uutice ill writing served un allY proprietor of a currcspun- d<.:lIce(;01"'1:1:require thut per:lOIl lU furnish in such forlll a:l he may direct illfuflllillioll oil "lieh mutters 1I:llIIay be specified by him, (L) A 1'11,,"11Il:quir<.:u 10 furnish returns p"rtlualll III suhsccuuu (I) (h) "hIlYC 1111,,w11ill,ill IWIl IlIlllltll~ frurn thc uorice cUlilply rVi1h the notice. ()lkll~CIi 9.· (I) If' lilly \,eIW'" required to furnish returns pursuant to section H Ulld PC/lIIllicli. of IlIiH IJccnc LlilH III [uruisl: those returns as required under this Decree, he Hhall be guilty III' 1111ullcncc IIl1d liable 011conviction to 'I fine of N5()1) III" illll'rillllllllll:1I1 lur (, 1I111111(1,I'H' 10 uoll, HIII;I, linc aIII I illlpri~onllient. (4!) Any I" 11111w1h1u, fill' the purp!)"c Ill' lllil,fillillg II ccrt ilicutc ul' I'cg;'ltl"lI- lillli ro, II !II11'''l'lJIlilelll:c eollel{e 01' III' cOlllplyill1{ with any of the provi~iolls of llli'l 111'111'" (11Il;ltlllillf{ purported corupliuncc ' with a requirement 10 flll'lllnh J 11\111110111111'1l:1H1llid) \,I'I'Helllll IIny. illHIClIIIII':lIl or makes 'Illy staLCIII<':lIt Whl:ll"'1 111'1111II1I li,t: 1i:lIlIlIH which ill ['1It1cin a unucrial particular, ~II;"I be "lIilly 01 1111111IW1 I! IIl1kHH lie "lOvell liial lie hatl 11I1(el1l 11r1easonable :111:\,'I;II IldCI'IIIII'1 IIII' h ut h 111'111h\:lalclll!:111 made III' cuutuincd ill 1111in':strument ~II pi1:111'1111'11. (,I) 1\11\ II( I""" HI/lhy IIf ,III 1I11'.-1ICuln:der ~III"I<.:cLilill (2) of this ,;n:lilill shul] Ill' 11,,1"1'"II ""II\'iClillll III II line Ill' NJ,UlIll or i"'l'l"i~lIllIlIellt fill' 12 IIlOlllhH or III 1",11,IIl1dl line allLI iuiprisouurcut. • , (~) Auy I'L"I"""11 \V1~o \~ilflilly IIIH'lr~lcl~," illklfl'r~" .virh, a~:-;;,,,It,, III" rl'hlblH lilly dl'HII:II,lll:d otliccr III Ihe cxccuuon 01 his duties under this Decree Ill' wh" IIldll, illyill:H, illdueu~ 01' 1Ii>a;1l1ilIly other person 10 obsrruct, iuicrfcrc wirlr, 1111111011'1rC11HiKIlilly such olliccr shall be guilty of an offence und liuhlc 011IjIlIlVil:\l1I1I tll II lilll: Il( N200 Ill' IlIIpriMlllllIll!lll flJl' :11I11J11Iho~r to hllih KliCh fine uud irupriu.nuucm , , (.lIf~II~II. Ity 10, (I) Wltere all uIleucc under Ihj~ Decree I~ couuuittcd by a hudy hudl!!. 4i0C- (;Ilqlllllllt: III' tinn 0/' 'Ilher IlllijllCiulIlI1I of ill4lividlllllH I'urlllu, dO. (1/) every director, IIHlllUgCl', secrctury UI' ullllJr uilililul' ulliccr III' 111lI'Hllly corjlulillc , (IJ) eVl'ly IIIlllllcrllrulli(;(;rllflite/irtll; (I') every trustee III' the body concerned (d) every pcnH/1l coucerucd in the IIlallaHelllclI1 IIf the illI'ail'~ III' Ihe usaoci.uiou, III' i (c) every pertiUIl who was Jlurpurling to act ill any such capacity as ufllfeH.liu, UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 495 11)77 Nu. t 1 i\ IlJ "IIIIIIItI'YI'lillI\' I" ,,"IIIY 111'11;1111111'1'I1IH1\l:ll"llhic III hl) prll'.:"di.ld IIllaillHllIlld I'lIlllllhuol IIII' 11101I1Ilr""':l: ill like nuutuur us if he had himuclf conuniucd the oll'clln) 111111-h1u11ll1wv':lj tluu the act or umissiou consrituting the olfcucc took pluce withollt hili knowledge, consent or connivance, (2) Wllcre IIII II/reIlCC i>lcouuuiucd by acorrespondence coli.:ge referred to ill nl'lilill ~(.!) lit' thill lIccrce, every i11;CIIIactill/{ fill' or 1111behalf of uuy sucl, CClIII'tlJI"lIlkIICI: clillege ah.rll be scvcrully gllilly Ill' 11.,lt oHelice alld liable to he Ilroc.:cdcd agailltil ilIlll punished fur that ollcnc« ill like manner all if he hud hilllllrif cuuuuittcd till; ullcncc. 11. Tilt) CIIIIIII IiUlliulI<:f Iliay uiakc n:glllaliuJls gell<:fally for the pllrpuse:; HC!;U/uliull:l. uf Ihill l Jcci cc 1111.1w,ithout prejudice to the generality of the power hereby conferred, I cH"LII iOIl~ lIIay - (II) 11I1:~elllll' the f"rtllo tu he used [ur the l!llrpusl::' uf lhi~ Decree ; (b) 1'1'1::'''d:1ie I Ill: kc:; to be paid fur l'I:gistriliioll under this Decree ami for n:/1I1II1nr kl'tl III' part t hcrcuf ill cases in which he refuses rcgistrauo« ; (c) pil'lInd,,: III' coutuiu such adillilli'slrativ.: ur prot:nlurill provisions as apl'l'lIr III Ililll ill'el'h~i1ry or expedient ill urclcr III Iucilh.uc the opcruriun of Ihit! 1)1'1:11'1:, IlIlurl" ~III· lion. "Iho ('Il""lIi,,"illllCf" 1I1ellllH tho Fcdurul Cunuuiuaiuucr churgcd with n':sl"Jllllil,ili(y rill' cducuuunul correspundcnce colt.:ge~ ; '\:11I11'111'"111"'"1C'\:IJIIl'/{t:" IIICilllt! allY ctJlkgc or illHlillilill1l Ill' uny ut hcr IlIIdy willi II 11I11l11H'luII,I' ill 1't!llIlliiHlil.:d III coud 11I.I;1l:lJIHHC~III' iustrucuuu 1 /ly 1111'11I1II11I1IIJJI'IIj1l1lllll'llce lutwccu il "lid ilt! IIludcllltJ aIII I includes the pfllpdl'llif tlllllI'lil 1111d1llc:l JlOl includc-c- I. (II) II 11I111'1:111o1r1t,lYillli!.11' illhlillilillll of hi/~her Jcaruillg (whether ill NiWI ill '" rluvwhcre] whi~1t aWi~rd:; external degrees or diplomas or which dllllll'llillIlIll.:lI cclucatiuuul rustrucuon or mutcriul by mcaus of currcspundcncc III' I,y sound or television broadcast ; (b) lilly cllrr(,tljllllldt:llce college established solely for religious iustruc- tiuu ; Of (c) illI~ CIIIII:IIJ"IIIlJcIlC': culI.:gc entirely m.uutuiucd and cuutrollcd by lilly (,Ilvefllillelll ill the Fcdcnuiuu ; "dl'Hiltllllh'tl IIlIi,:I'I''' llilll Ih •• 1I,,;unillf{ 1I~lniHllliti111(11',,"1y11lilJlllillll:l (5) Ill' tllill lrceicc ; "proprielllr" IIleilllH lite person whu is 01' holds hiiusul.' (jut ro he tilll owner of II clJrll'HI"llldelll:': collcgl.: or tile lessee or tenant in the case uf lensed prclllilll'lI, III' Ihe p.:rUUII uHillg prcuiiscs [ur t hc IJllrpuse of iI C(JI"'t:~- pOIIJl!lICe l'llllq;c, Ill' lilly person th.it clcrj vcs or is entitled to uny prulus or suuilur /ll'lldiIH ft 011\the business of allY such college and includes an IIgelll ill the cuse Ill' it correspondence college referred III in section 2 (2) of llliH 1.h:l:ll'l' 111'1111I'l''I'Imn rl:cl)glli~ed i1Hpropri.:lorilllllll:lliatciyberurc the cOlllilll{ tllill J'lIrl:l: 411t'hiM Decree lint! references lu perHllll herein include, .whcrc ul'l'liclI"le, rclcrcuccs to l>uJie:l corporatc, IiI'l II:>, trustees or i1lly othor IIt1NIICilllillll of iudividuuls ; UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 496 A IH 11)71 Nu, 11 .--.~----~--------------------------- "suuh-ut " IIII.'UIiN lilly punlJlI whu lululIl lilly 4:1I1IrIIU uf lnstrucrion froru II 1:0ne"JlIIIII!l:m:e college whether 01' not he iij II student at lilly other insu- union, CilUlioli uud 1l. 'J'ldli I )e~1 cu may be cited a!l thc Educational Correspondence &:(IOlfocnl;&:. menlo (;III1~IIl.'1t (ltl'llillllllliIJII, Elc.) Decree 11)77 and tllIaIl CUIIIC into operation on II dutu tu LJe"l'puinll.:d lIy the <":ummltl~lollel'lJy order l*',lidhul.\ ill 1111:G(/~I!II/1, L-I'-GENI!HAI. O. OUASANjO, l lcud of the Federal Military Govcmmciu, Commander-in-Chic] uf the /lrmed Forces, Federal j{epublic uf Nigeria EXI'LANA'I'OIlV NOT!! ('I'hll /111/,/ .tlln not jtJlIII par ! '1the uboue Dccre« but i. intended 11/ cAp/aill its purpurl) The 1)1'1'1<:<:IIH111etluppruvul by the Federal Conunissioner for Educution II J,re-ellmlilillil 1'111t'he cstablisluncut (or cuntiuuariou ill business in the case fit exililillfj illlllillllillllH) uud re!{iHtfalioll of all private educational correspon- deuce cul (;.,(;~ w!ijldllg tll conduct bUtlllleH~ In Nlg crlu, Other provluluus thereof Hi ve general supervisory authority over such instirutious to the Fed c I'll I Millililry III' EdllClltillll, • Auy IHllly found running an illegal correspondence college will be liuhlc ou eOllvkliull Iu II tine of N5,UOO or to imprisomuent fur two years Of both . ._-. _._-_._--- j'UIII.I""1I1) IIY AUTIIOUITY 01' Till! FliUliUAL MII_nAItY (jUVI!:lNMENT 01' NIGEHIA ANI. 1'1111,1111'IIV TIIIl lVllNlij'lllV 01' INI'OIlMhTUIUN, l'UIN'I'INO lJlVllilllN, L.~';I)~ UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY A 237 APPENDIX 17 EIHH ~t\'l'IONAL COJUtESI'ONDENCE COLLEGES ACClmUITATI0N DECIUm 19li7 Ii. Cuuccllut um ul ccrt iticuto ur uccrcdituuon. 1. ElIuIIIIlIlIlIII I 1111 I'''I'''I"II'"~C cullc- lIel lu hu 1I~"f~dj(cd. Y. I'owcr of debi!;II"le&.u! llicc: s lu l. I'rucerlurc I'll" "~t:llldillllluu, cuter 1'1cuuses und ut-I.ill iulunuutiun. J. Ht.:ltuwlll III l:cllilic~lc uf "~!.-fudl"III"". Ill. I'cuulucs fur' ~dlill" lip ill~~.1 cuIlCHC. ~. E.llIlJli.IIIII""1 III '\l!l!lcdilllllllll CUlllllliill'lI. II. Otleuccs IIl1djll·I"lIliu. 5. WillIS 1IIIIdltIly III I.e "IHII lu I 2. (JJI'clI~Cb.y I;udic:.corpurute. _c\'I'llllilUd\,IIIII'.IJlllld~"" liulIcwou. D, HCl'cul., buvill!!:! ""U uuuafcr 01 h~el¥und Iiuhiluica. 6. Power III ICHloI,u "~cl'~diluliun UI' lllljlllK' loulI"lIllIlI Ihcrooll. H. H"HUluliuliu. 7. OjJclIllllj dU'IIIII ul brKltchn. 15. Irucrprcruuun.111I1 16. Ciuuion, D6.!Icr4;l4J No. 32 I~/" NO(',II/,U"" IIlH'lI r:(Unlll •• u, •... Ill.",. 'J'IIJ~ !'Ii 1)1'.1( 1\" 1\11LI'I'AH Y GOV hit N M h NT hereby decrees a. (I.IIUWII : ... l. ..-( I) II' "" y IIIlIllIlI' i~ desi ruus of clLwlliHg ILOt I;;:-;a than IW;;ILyI EdtH.:uliUHftl l.:ili;u:nHuf Nigurililitl IIludlllll~ for any currcapoudcnco course run Of (I) be run currcspun- by iUY wrruHl'llIIdtllll:U college of which he i~or pl'Opo~e~ to be the proprietor deuce thereof then, wi t;uIlCllC1"0 t..".WIU HIII;1waIICbO or part thereof is to bo run by the correspun- accredited. deuce (';olJoHIJII' Nigoria or, a:l tho case may be, to be undertaken by such studenta while I ·.,illuill iu Nigeria, 1111:proprietor concerned shall, in addition 10 iu(';orporntilll:{ tho enterprise under tho 'provioioHS of Ih\: Companies Act l\.l6M. III' Ihll HUlliijl,ralion of Iluaincas Name» Act 1%1, ap/lly 10 the I'II.K " II. 'I. Mini"lu,. fllr 1I(;(;II,dillilioll of 1110 correspondence (,;ollo/;uill accort unco willi I'lld Nil. 11. the pl'llvi~iIlH~ III' Ild'l Decree, (2) WIIUIU 1111 1111II.umill!) into uporauon ur thi~ Decree any corrc~l'ulI- JOUI.:U (';uilullo iH 1.•111yllll:{ on business in Nigeria, the proprjctor thereof may ilpl'ly will.!u tlllllll 1Illllllhd thereafter to be accredited but shall cease to curry UII Illdl "III1II1I1HIIIII Ni~cria after the expiration of six months from the cOlllill1l illill "1'"1,,111111 "I Ililtl Decree, unless prior itl t ho cxpir;ltiull of Ihe IIl1id pUI'!."I, ullllt 1'1I11I)1I1"lIldc/I';u .;olkbu i~ accredited 10 continue il~ h\ll,iu,,~~III 111'';11"1111(1'11 wll I Ihl) pruvbiol~ of this Decree. UNIVERSITY F IBADAN LIBRARY • 498 1~'rll/U/li(JlltIl Corresptuulence CulLtgeI 19!i7 No. 32 A 2JI) /1 ((f,dilulilill (i) 111'"11 lI·n;;l'l of an upplicuriou under subsections (1) and (3) uf LI,i:; scctiou, the !\lillil.ll:J' ~llIdl cause such inquiries 10 be made as lIlay assist hiu, ill (;Ulllilll: I" u dn:illilJll in the particular case. (~) II uh or lucui!,l of particulars ill compliance with the fon:guil1g prllvltdllilH III IltiH lIocli'JII illIIl of the prescribed [ccs lilt l\liJli~h.:r is IIr Iho Hl'llIloll (/11111.11 " '"' 10"1"III"CI1C() I,:olkgc (1IlgiLl III hu uccrcditcd, he ~1"11J i:.:."" il willi II I 1'111Ii",III' ill tho prescribed form III thur vf!CI,;{ with ur Wilhl/II! cOllallllllllil i (b) Ihul " 1I1I"ILl he urulcsi ruhle ill the public interest that uccrcdituunn ho ellocrc.l, ho iuuy refuse such accreditation, uud HII appeal shall I ie [rum all)' dllCitiiol1 IIi' tho Minister in any such case. (1,)WlwllI U ('Ofl iticutu IIf lIuc!"I:dilation i~ issued subject 10 condiLilll1s. 1110 COI'IUU!,'IIHlulI':U clllkgu ~I"dl cllllll'ly wllh Lhllsc cOliditlll~I~, (7) All)' 1:III'fU"jllllhII,)IICV I,!ollugu which f,lil~ to c.;olJlply with rcsidciu ill Nillurin illllh"i'lhUcl III accept uu behalf of the correspondence t:1I11(;1;(: t.el vjru ,d PI"II''';''1 IlIld lilly IICllit:llti required to bu borved on it (c-) if the bll·.ill':";, "I' the t:1I1Te.:SPOlllkIlCIc:lille.:ge.:was conuncncc.l hch nc Ihe l'Il/lIill~ illl •• IIpe:ralioll of lhi~ Decree, the date of the commencement "f "111'11hll,.JIIU"" : 1111.1 U) ;,I/l,I, '11114:11'.'lIli.:ui.IIII 110I0llily llu 1"""l:lilJl:,j [r oru UIJIC tu tiu.c. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 500 A 2.•0 1!l1i'1 Nu. ,I.! t.'.lumliunlll Oorresponitcuc» CcJlI~.I}t'I Accreditation (i) Ii ll'IIII:~I:lltlltiyc of the National Teachers' Insutute, KaJlIna ; (j) II JI'lilllil'lItlltiyc of the Aseuciariun of Accredited Cu ITC:ijlO IIde IIl'l: l :ulJl'gclI ill NIHcri.1 ; (k) u rc 1'1 I'~clltilti vc uf the Correspondence and OpCII . itudies J usutuu, Uuivcrsity uf LUl:lull ; (I) II rcprcscntutivc of the Nigeria Employers Consultative Association; (m) live fe.:IIOWUe:U educationists uf whom two shall be proprietors of currcapundcnce cuJlcged whu shull be appointed UII basis of individuul IIlCritd IIlId gllUl:Illljlhicul reprcscntatiou. (3) '1'1,,; I'cruiuucnt Secretary in the Federal Ministry uf Education shall dCdi~nlllu u ucuior ullicer of the: Correspondence Education Unit ill that Ministry to uct 1111the secretary to the Committee. (~.) '1'1111 ClJlllllliUeu shall, after considering any application ludglld UIIIIJI' Iliu (I"Ivli,loll~ of Ihltl Decree, eulnuit a recommeudation thereon tll tho Mlllllllvl' I 1111111110 Miuistcr ahull thereupon grant or withhold accrcdltu- tiull II" l'nlvldud IIl1dvl' .lIu~uelion (5) <;If sccuon 2 of th\::I Decree. Wid" puuli- city 10 be 5•.... ( 1) III every cusc where the Minister issues it certificate of accredit a- WIVIlfIIII liulllII II CdI'! (JtI\HllldOIiCO cuJlUJ,lUI U th;siWliILOd utlicer ~1i1l1Jcause a puhlicutiun ICCHuil.<;d to be uuulo tll 1111I1ollcct ill tho GIl.:Jclld uud in as Illillly ncwspupcr» hal/ill~ l:urrupon ..• deuce widu circulill i,," III Nlgorlu Ud ho IIIUY tlWIU dusiruhlc, collcl4Cf. (2) '1'111' l\ 1iulutur shull cuuse III he propured urul muintuincd lIy a dc~igHllt\Id IIllielll' II rogietur of tho IUIIIIU::I und addresses, und of such other purtlculure 11,1lliay Iw apocificd, of ull correspondence culll:gu::I uccrudit cd ill accurtlanco will, thu provisiun« of this Decree. (J) It 11110111110 lilt: duly of the designated ollicer-e- (II) III l',IlIHO Ihu I'cgiulcr to be printed, published aud put Oil b,de tll IIIQIIIIII)w 1.1' IIIU public not hl!er tluiu eix months after the couuucnccmcut (,fliliw J)UI'IIlU ; Jill.! . (b) ,,"I 1.:,," IIIIUI twice ill each year alter that ill which IIIC rcgi:.ll.:j' i:l lirllt pulJllt,jll;d under Jllil'ilgrapll (0) of thia subsection, to cause to he printed, pilloli..ht:d and put 011 sule a~ aforesaid a corrected edition of the rUl{iHlur whit-h -hull bu at! up to datu as possible ; am] (c) 1111'1111:,0II print of each edition tu be available ~It all reasonable liIIIC" f"r iIlHpc\:1 ilill I,y 1I11JIIlbem uf the public [rce of charge, (·1) A ,('Ii'iIiIlUIlI 1lil'·jlllililiK 1\, j,u 11 pl'i!Ll lie 1111 I.Idilioll uf II n:l\i.hH J'lIlJli~hi)d 1111.1111Ihlll h\lctil/H Ily t hu ,k"i~11II1I.ld ulJil:"r ~lii\1I (,dthuUlll1l1jlldicl' \11 1111)'IIthvl' 1"".111 III' pl'lIl/f) \)1.' 1~1\'lIi~;;il,lo in lIny l'r~I~~edlHg:i a~ ~v,idclIClI ....) rlnu 14CIII'IIII'I""I.iIlHco clllkgo spcciticd In tl.u docuuicut 1:1 lull yOI' conditionully Ilct:roL\ll"ll Ulld II lilt lilly ':tllle.;o not ~(1 tipecifit;d thcrt.;il\ I:; not so accredited. (~)I" tl"" ,""Iillll. "dcsiguutcd olliccr" lII1:all'; aoy ulliccr in the Fedclal M illi.I, y 01' 1':dllJ:lltlulI whu IIIUY Iroru tiuie tu time be charged with the gl.:lIurnl III"I"III"lldlity 1'111'tho dischurge of the Iunctious specified under or I (III r&1IIIIII 1011.111 IlIa:tillll III' any lither pruvision of thiR J?ccrce. I'IJwcr 10 6. -(I) Tho I\lilLiHtl.:r lIlay at any tiuic \lary or revoke any uf tilt; I"voke IIIl.IcJiluliuli I:IIlldilillllll of II CUlt iliratu of accreditation or impose such conditions or addi- or impose tion,tll'Ol\oIilillll~ 1111ho lIIi1y deem ncccseury. ,·olldilioUI Ihct~OIl. UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 501 1:',"1' o fill,,," (.'uoCSfl()/Ji/(!IICIl Cullt'rel 19!51No, az A 2"1 Ac-t-r.e-dita-tio,,. , ..•..• ...•.... ---~.-- ..- - -._--_ .._ - --~-~..--~..-.,- (:l) \VI'IIII' tI'li M illi"I",. JlWI'UYUH tll vury, rovlIl.c or ill 'I IObll ~lIll1lhi'"11I1" II, '"ldlllll'\I willi t ho p'lll'i,;iuII:lllf auhscct iuu (I) of Ihit! ucctiou, ho ~hllil 111/1'1111"1~III1;llIllIg such power givo notice ufo Ili~ iuteutiun t," Ihe, clirrollIH'II'''illlli ndill/lll "/IIc"rll~\J 1111,1 ahull ullmd II 1111,OJlJ1ml~'!'tly "', lIIaklt'H 1'1'1'1'''"''"11111111111II, him IIl1d In '"Ihlnil rCllllllllti why IIU eul'lIl1elll!! (I' ut,:llrllilhalloll IIliouhl 11011hY "" 11I1Ir.ntlod. (3) '\IIY Cllfl'l::'IlUlldem;u college which fails 10 comply wirh any comli- tiUII~ llii VIIIiud III' IlIlpuMal hy virtue Llf subsection (I) uf Ihb section shull he guilty ul 1111ollcuco uud tthall LIe liable 011 conviction to a Iine of:N 100 fur each duy dllrin/.l which lite cruulition« are, or any of them is, 1101 complied with. 7. Ellory corrospuudcncc college shall inform the Mi~lister of- UpCIIIII!; IIIIJ closing of (a) lilly pl'u[Ju>iill to open or close brunches thereof anywhere in Nignia ; , branches, (b) 1I1I)' IlIujlo:,l,,1 ilgrccmcnt or urrungenicnt fur iI\l)' sale or tlispos.tI uf II~!tll~illl:M:I hy uillaigilflwlioll or otherwise j iLlIJ ' (I:) OI"Y II1'IIIII)~ul for rc-orguuisution, 1I11l1 tli" M illiHIII!, III"Y, ill 11,0 cuse of, II crurospuudoucc CiJlJcgo situated ill NiHuriu, HI'IIIIiVI' 411'witlwld uppruvul of any such pruposa] j uud in any oll,cr 4:/lIIC, ho Ullt)' 1III'tlll111'II dccillilllliltl 110 thilllllI uppropriutc il~ tile circurustunces. H. (J) 'I'11lI 1\IIIIi"II'1' uruy hy Ordel' I',ddjohcd ill tho Gaad/" (~jllh.:dlll(iull tIt' l.erl tli •:.lIlc caurol uny rollllic,111l IIf uccrodluuion=- (If uccrcditn- (0) If lito huldur thereof cease, tu carry 011 ill Nigeria tl.c kind of busiues« t ion. fur which t hu ('crlil/cillu wa~ issued 01' if the correspondence college goc" into lilillidillillll Ill' ill wound-up or otherwise 1:l:iltiC:; II) function as it I.!IIrl'll!ll'"llill'lll'lJ 1',,111'):11 i 1111.1 ' (b) if 1111I hul.lor li,cl'I:lIf filil:l 10 ),,,llil. the pre·,crihed cunditions .uul re~1I1111iOI\H ; III' (d if it., i- ""II,ili.-d Iii II il ill ill II,u public.; ilil""",,1 'ill III d ••, (2) \\'1":111 11111 1\li"i,ll:r prIlPIJ~"':1 10 ,'alll:c! allY l'ellll','.IlI: "f a.:erudilulillil I"" 1111111I1u HIII>~Cl'liulI (I) of this section, he bl ••.ll before ..uch canc\)i1i1lillll I:il U IIl1li,'u of hill intention lu tho currcupnudcncc cullc~:I: \'Ullulrllud illid ,,11.111,;ivu it all ol'I"II'llIIIily lo make rcprcscuuuious "lid (" sulunit fl'HIIUlIl' why ilB ccrtilicatc uf accrcdit.uion shuukl Hot Lc cancelled. 2· (I) 1"111 111\: Jlllrptlu\)t\ Ill' lilid Jk..:I'\)\). lilly dlniiguillcd otlicor I'uwrr III (l/) shnll huvo dc:,iHoaccdII rigllt of access, at any time during the normal working ulliccrs I" huurs III tit!: I'll IlIltilH'lIdcIlCO coJlcgo concerned, to any buildinl{ 01' uihcr enter Pl'llllliflllH "I' lilly III1\;It (;III'IWI'"11dl.:llco'cllllegl.: ; illld IIrt.;.lli:ll'l. OIIIJ 11101.1111 (b) IIIIIY Ily lIolieu ill writing HIH'I'l'd Oil allY proprietor ,,1' a cI)rre:'[lolI- ;OfOlllliitiun. donee \:lIlk);l: fCll'lil\) the pl'ol'rivlul' to furni~;1i in tHICh f'lI,tlI all /It.: III"y diroct illful'llIalioll Oil such mutters as mily be specified by him. (2) 1\ PUI'HIIII i cqnircd III furnish allY inform.uiun pursuunt to IHlhtit:di"/i (J) (b) uf IldM IIoclillll IIh411 within (WI) 11I11111111[Ir.un tho notice cumply Willi 1110 110111,:0, I. 10. AllY I'CI"IIII witu sets IIJl UIIY Cllri'tl~pllndt:IU10 .colh:1I1J ill Nigeria '11'; Pi,tllth it·;/ 'pf II:> the CIlt;CI 1111\1' hu, I'IIIIH correspundcnce courses which am undertaken ill ~t;lljIlH up Ni!)eriill)l.ltuI'WlhU Ihall ill cOlllpliance with the provisions of Ihi:! Decree »hall illc,:ill !Ie ~'!ilty Ill' 1111!!,rllIlI'lJ um] Hindi bu liulol!; 1111';V!lvi~;tillnyl a line of N I0,000 or (;ollcUt:, rll: unprtsourucut IIII' IWII yoanl or to both such hoc an" uupnsunmenr, UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 502 \H2 1~1i7No. H 1I''{41'1I1/(1//(C//u, r'itl/; Wil~l all)' of 11t~provision» uf this Decree (1I1lIudlll!; purportccl compliuucc wuh a I cquncmcut t" furoi~h illfl)I'JlIillij)ll under «ccuun 9 of this Decree] presents any instrument IJI' makes any Mlale:IICIiI whether ur nut in the instrument ur fUrin which is false in a material polltil:IlIi1I', shull be gllill y of illl oljcncc 1I111t:~lSit' proves that v he ha~ taken ull I'II;OII11I1i1ll1itlOuI'll III usccituin rhc tlulh 1)1I' Ill: staterucnt uradc 01' contained ill the illilil II111Clltur form su presented. (3) Auy l't:llilill 1:lIilty ofun UU'I:I'ICeunder subsection (2) or ihie section ahull hu liuhlu 111(1:lllIl'i,'111I1I tu u 'illil of N.I.S00 UI' hnpriaoruucru Ior twclvc InUlIlh~ 1/1'tu 11I1l1ht lldl lillu uud iruprisorunent. (f) Any PUI'HIIII willi wilfllily uhstruct», interferes with, assaults or I't:~i~il~lilly 1\t':Higllllll:d ullicur ill the execution of l.is dutic» under this Decree or whu uids, 1lll'lillH, lu.lucc- 01' ubcts uuy other I'CI':iun tu obstruct, interfere with , iI~:lillllt or l'Il:liNI lilly hllCh olliccr shall he gllilt)' of all utlcucc .uul liublc 1111ruuvictjuu 11/II lillll ()I' N I,O()llur ituprisuruucut flll':l 1I11/1I\1tI:I1I' to \JUI It .Ildl fill" urul 11111i.'l1llllllleill. Jlh Ilfa; 1.1, 12"-(1) \VI,UIII ,III 1J1i1',1!.!UII!lUUI' ihi:. /JI,lChJ., j" elllillllllt" I Ity II "udy "IlIIC,j t:vr- !,Ufutc, c. curpurutu or tinn III' IILllol' illlHllcialioli (,I' individuulu->(C.'t (1/) el'el'), dill:l'llll, 1Il,llIilger. sccr ct.uy III' ut lu.r :lilllilar (jllil'l:1' III' the IJlJdy \ ••rplll'lllO ; (") cvci y 1',11111"I1II 1I11,n;1I'II the tiuu ; (t') every l!'II:,lrc III ihc hudy concerned ; (cI) every I'unlllli l'II/lI,;I;l'ncd ill the IlIilllil!-',l:lllt:lll III' I IIc .t1Llir~ of Ille "~~lICi;lt iUII, IIr ; (I') el'ery I'CI""" 11'1"1IV.I;, llllrl'\lnillg tu act ill uu v :'IIl'I, ';;III.lciIY il~ .1I'llrcsaid , ,hall ~e\'llrally 11111\11V1I1II1' l hut ,,1It:m:ll ,,".1 liable to he !ll'llccl,;dt:.J "1·,aill~1:tlld lllllli,itud fill' tliitl 11I1,,"I'\! ill liko uuruuor 11:1ir ho It".! Itilll:,.clr ("llIllIitlcd Ihllllll'~Ill:U UIlIt)Ii~ 111j1lIIIVU:1ihut tho uct or tlllli'I~,illll ctJlI"lilllting the ullcucc look I'lal,;u wiLltllIll IJiII 1llIlIwlodgo, L;(J1I:i(;1lI1Ir cuunivuuco. (2) Wlllllt) 111I1llt.-Ilt'u i~1Wlltlllillud hy u currespoudcucc l.:ldlc,:,; rclcrrc.l ,,1 ill h411;110:1.qI \) IIi' Ild'l 1)1'1:1'11u1v1u,rv IIl1lml tll~lillg for IIr on 11l:II.'f of unv ".".-11 III/I UIII"1111,t'J!l" ,"111'11I1.1t,111I ", ~'''VIII'II!1v WillI y oJ' 1110.''1~I!·;il"U IIl1d II,d.l., III 111\1'I!'Ii'I"I,j1 ,101111\11'1"111[I1I1I1'11t0.I/III' tlllll 0110111'I''II \ril" 111;111111)1' all if h" hlld 1111111I1"''1il1llI'llltal till! III 1'1II)I':U, j( I I" ..1. , 1.1. ,(I) '1'1111'.111,11I.III,tll:,II'I'Il;llllJlldlllll.;O C"lluJ;\Jj (It(;,;i:lIl'.llillll, 1';1.:,,) ,-,1\ 1111:1. ilud Act 11)'77 In hpi 111\'1Inl'l).Ihl' I. II.HI It'l 1,1 I •t'll .uid (2) N"l\\lldl,d;;,i,JllIl: IIldJlII'Clill1\ (I> ol' tili ••:,I:.:lillll-· I••11"" ICII. \')71 Nil. II, (1/) .IIIY I III III : '"I,/t;1I1 u 1"lIegu wlto:,1.) 11.1111w1.i)s inunc.Ii.ucly bdlll'c tho t.:lllllilll' 1111111"1,,, "I' tltis ))t:cree included in the 1'1:1;i~tcr of 1;lrl'C:'I'"l1dolll II \ 11111'1I :11) 1'1"under IIIll rCI't:alcd cuucuucnt "hall, wiih.nu furlher .I1'I,jil'.IIIOIl of 1',IYlIICIIIlJf any utlicr t'I:C,UU J",,(;IIlt:J I? lrc fugi:;tt:rcd under the .II'III'lIl'l'i04IU l'I"lvi~illli IIf till. UliU'CV ; UNIVERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY 503 h,/I/",I,IIII,Ii I '11"1'.1/",1/,/0:11": (·/JI/.:t;t·l I'Hl7 N/). az A 2·11 ."'" ""illlli'Jll (0) lIlI)' I't'J:i 01111.111'1ill I'iln.,laill:u Ill' l hu 1"(;11I;.IIcoc(nucuucut ~lIall he .!"IJI'llid I" I", 1'.111"I II ••. "'Hi"I.:r I" IIll I\clli ill pl/rillilllcC IIi" 1I,j1l IJccrcc : (I") allY d,,\;IIIIII:." l"I.kllllll( III .1prllvi.,illil ul. the rcpo.ilcd cu.icuucut hhall IIu clI/l~lnJl:d ,1:1.111i1"0l"1:1I1I":(; the 1:lIrru:;pondiOj; prllvi:,i'lII of this Dccrce ; uud (d) wluru 1111.)0"111"1I1f "r1: the curuiuuuucc of which ,I pCllillty was provided, I,ali I,co., 1"11111"11111I:I0II(Ier 1110rupc.ded UllaCI.1I01l1 prucuudinl::> muy Ill; tal,ell uu.lur IIIi,. 1Jill reo ill ruspuct of 1110coruinuunco uf rho ulfollc(; ultcr ihc (;01111111.:.111,,.;11"1I' iI,i:1Decree, ill 1110s.uuc 1lI,1I111uitr:! if the oifcllcu h:ul been UlII"lIill<:d under the cnrrcspondiug provisions )If II,is Decree. (.I) All 111''''''', 11111•0•1r,ouuurccs .uul ,,11101'movcahlc III' iuuuovcubl« I'r"l'urly wlli,'11 illlllllldioliuly bld'"rll thu cuuuncnccrucut of ti,i:; Decree were \"u:,lUd ill IIIii I,,,dill., I: ,,,d,li:,hed I>y tlro rcpe.ilcd cnucuncnt sludl hy virtue 01 lid" I lucrull IlIld 11"1h1""1 ;.IIY Iurrhcr assurauccs, he vested in the Commiuce. H. '1'111)i\li.II,;lI·1 ,".IY uuikc rugul~lilJlI~ gencr;dly fur the l'"rp\}~e~ III Iili,\ I)C\;11l1liI"d. \1.11,1111p1H.:jlldicc III the gCHuralilY (If tI,\.: plJIVcr ilercby e,,,tlul ••.:. III iI,l •• Ikll"I', IlItlc~:, rlrc coutcxt uthcr wisc requires - l1ILc.:qH\ t.l- t ruu, "I '''"111111/· "111111111lI1.u !;lillldiJl!{ Conuuiuce Oil the Ao : 'ditation I,f ("'I"II-"'I'"lld, Ill' t ',,1111:"" i ",'111"1'::'1'"'1''' II'" ,,,Ikl:o" IIIC;III:i uny colkg(; III' iu:,litlltiull or allY ull,cr 1""ly Will,'I, .:1111"'1I1,., or i~ \::;Iil"'i~h.;d tu conduct courses of instrucriou by IIle"II11 01. II"t: '1'"lIoI"HCU between il alld il:; ~llIlklil~ either hy me.ius "I" \l'lillli" '" 1'"111.,,, '''~III, II11Ii1ll IIr vitll;" lilpcS with IIplillll." ilcca:l~il'II." ""'11-1",·1,11/I 111111111110011""1"'l1ill/:. I'"l dlll:a Hill illd"de·· .(f/) /I 111/11,'.011\" or lIilllillir i'Il;lillllil/l\ of Ilighcr ICilruill/; [whether ill Nililliid III ,.1"/11\1,,,,,,) wlli ,~. illVilrdti I ;;1\11'111d1l:1llr~"m ."1" dil'lulIHI>; III' wi,li:" 01., ..• , '"1"0110":11".t1l'·UIIl'lIiil 1i1:.li"IICllIIIl Ill' iu.ucri.rl by IlIC;I/IS "I" "11'11:'/"'"./"'11"" III I,y 111111111I1c1iu1v1i'"illll'liriladcol.il ; (Ii) ill'.\' 1'11"1. '1''''111,,'11'<,,-"'lIu';l; 1;~l;d"i~lll:d ,;,,1"1), {III" n;ligilill'; iw.IIIIl"- Iiuu i III .. (t:) ililY I "'I';'II'lJlldellu: cllllc,~t: entirely IIlailll"iucd ill It! cout rullc.] Ily uuy (i","1"""'""l ill t hc Fcderalilill i ''.k ..il'lI"II·./ ,,1I,,'lil" 1,.".11,1:IIiCoillilll: ;/:.:iigllt:d Iherelll hy :,,,,;li'"1 5 (S) "I" l"i~ 1hit·, •.•; i "l\lilli:.II"I" 1111"""1I0I", 1\IIIIi ••it:1 l:iI.III.;I:.I will, .t:"II/III.,il,lI,ly 1,,1'11.,1111"/:. \llulillU III l'dlll"lIlillll i IIlId "Miuiutrv " hllliliho ("1Il1utruud ~I:':flnlillilly i UNIVERS TY OF IBADAN LIBRARY t' '-', 1~1(, No• .Il '"f,.,jJulld':1/I:v Cull'J;t:i ..__ ..__ ..- ----- ,1, .1,:dlt"l/vll -----_.__ ... - "pl"UpliUlllf" 111(;0111011P1 ·r~l)ll who is or IwldJ I.illlt.df uut lo lie 11.<: owner of \I 1,;01o1"I'UII'/":IICU c"IIl:!ju or t lro lessee or tcruuu ill IIII! case "r luu~iJJ l'n,;tuiae.l, 'II' ihu pUl"tilill lI~illg premises fur the pll fpu~e uf a CUI"Il;,,- pondcucc Wlliil:U, III' illlY person that dciivcs Ill" ij entitled II) allY I'l"olil:; Of klilllilM I'CIII 11111 111I1II1.; l"I:,iIlC~:1uf .IIlY :,lIo:Ii •."lIcI:u alld illdllclc:l all aHUlI1ill Ilw \;11 ,II lIt" ,I l:,Jrru:II'VlhhlllCOculkg(; rclcrrurl 1,1ill "cdiuil ~ (3) III Ihill LJ"I.IU\,JIII" 1111p'UII'"11u;cuClIi:.o<.;:dlJ pwplil-tuf i,"Illl:cli,lldy 1)0.)["01II1,e: l:Ulllilljl iulU/Uil UIll' tlliu Ducrco ulld rclcrcuccs lu "I'er;.oll" ill llti(j 1:k(;l(;(; 11111II1IH1 IlIdo, \I hU1l1IIl'plic.lL,lu, ft:f.:I"CIlLC;i 10 lJ\)lli(;~ CIIIj,I,I-.,lu, linus, IflidloOd III' lilly 1IIIIUf .1o~lJu••cuiou of IIl.liviJ(,.,L ; "etu.loru " 1111;.11lil1ly,1I'Ult"IIl who I.Li.(;J allY 1:1,111:."(f; ill',,11ucrion fllllll .1 l.vl 1U.It' IJIhllij, ,,,II"l(u wl .. or IIf nut I(() is.1 ·1(11Ih.:ll.trt OIlIy urhcr ill.>li· tutiun, lb .. '1'111,.III" II." IlIiI)' 1••1 .;ilud ,,~ JlIU l~ducilti""i11 ('UlI'cuIIUIHlclI"c 1',,110.;".,'\"'II,,jllolllllti 1)0,'1"" I'JI:i7, (;hl'HiU,\1. I. II. 1I,.,lIi1r'WIII.\, I'ln/dclll, ('01111111111,/1 t-il/-{ 'hilf ujOl}U: .I'lJlt.,l Fuu c», Fdr'1I11 U~."d,lic vi NI>ritJ (1'hi! \1111/1' dlln 11(11jfJ/III purt of the: ubouc Deere» 0111 is ill/eillied lu cxpluin it~Pili purt) I Tho J),a:lI;ll I "I '"lib the I~JlIcati(lllal Correspondence l'()"egl:~ (Hcgi:.- u ation,; CIC.) 1\1"1I'ln 1111I0II1.llle:1 uccrcdit.uiou Ily the 1'vlilli:,I.f IIf Edlll"'lliuli it IIIU··Clllldilillll 1111'11"",1"':l'iIliuli (01"cuutiuuutiuu ill IlLlhilll;~:; ill t hc case ,.(' l:xi,,(iug iuuriuuiuu«) ,,{ all privato cduc.uional CUIrespondence c(>lkgcs wi~"iJlg tu ClJlldlict 11I1"illl!:t~ill Nigl:J'ia, Oilier pWI'isioliS tlll:rl:u{ l:ive g(:Ill:';.J H~'I'''l'vl.uHry 1I1~lltilth v .II\'''~' 1011..1il1illtil."liIlIHI '" I IIII 1,~".t'J"." I\/illilolry "f hi ucuuou, i\ 1\)11III NSIIIJ III C":lfI:;U;""C III rClll'l'" (If'l('plwilllilil. --' Ally IltIdy wli" I,/"IIIIIUII Uli 1I1"Hlli CIII:u'''piimlilth'u 4lUil"',Hlhi Ilulhy hl'llII "ll"elll:u hlld ,,1,,"1110I>,""01111CilU\'Ic/iilli lit iI lil.l: IIf N lU,U()(j IIf ilJ diru;llIls 10 illl(lIillllllllll'Jl1 I111IWiI)'I",tru III oillh • .' .. .' ." \ ~ UN VERSITY OF IBADAN LIBRARY